question about Amnesia: Rebirth

[elikos1]

thank you for helping me. Is there a good ending and a bad ending in this game?

If there is a bad ending,,does it have any connection with how many times character has died and been transformed back into life?

Is there a specific scenario in game that could or will trigger the death of unborn child?


At what crossroad or juncture within game is main character destined on the bad ending scenario or the good ending scenario?

[Neptune Towers]

There are three endings to the game and they can all be triggered from the very final level, so you can experience them all in a single play-through by loading your last save. As far as I can tell, absolutely nothing that you do throughout the course of the game has any impact whatsoever, at least not on the game itself. There may be a few choices that are irrelevant to the game but should in principle affect the player personally, but I found the overall writing to be too shallow and the characters to be ham-fisted caricatures so I couldn't really care about them and ponder my decisions.

[elikos1]

Originally posted by .xXx.W4R10KK.xXx.:

There are three endings to the game and they can all be triggered from the very final level, so you can experience them all in a single play-through by loading your last save. As far as I can tell, absolutely nothing that you do throughout the course of the game has any impact whatsoever, at least not on the game itself. There may be a few choices that are irrelevant to the game but should in principle affect the player personally, but I found the overall writing to be too shallow and the characters to be ham-fisted caricatures so I couldn't really care about them and ponder my decisions.

thank you for helping.

Basically right now I have just completed this scenario at;

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k104gu7OsH4 at 35:32

I'm past this part but I would really like to know something.. my main character chose not to torture the guy herewith.

Does this choice mean that in my game the unborn child will die because they did not get the vitae?

[Neptune Towers]

I don't think it has any impact whatsoever on how the story progresses. Only what you do in the final level matters.

[๋NeThZOR]

There are only 3 endings, and they can all be obtained no matter what your 'ghoul progression' meter is, that is to say how many times you have died and respawned, accelerating your transformation into a ghoul.

The only affect with regards to endings that the ghoul progression has is that Tasi looks a bit different in a certain ending cutscene.

Also, there is no point or decision in the game that affects the outcomes

[elikos1]

Originally posted by NeThZOR:

There are only 3 endings, and they can all be obtained no matter what your 'ghoul progression' meter is, that is to say how many times you have died and respawned, accelerating your transformation into a ghoul.

The only affect with regards to endings that the ghoul progression has is that Tasi looks a bit different in a certain ending cutscene.

Also, there is no point or decision in the game that affects the outcomes

But it sounds like if there are three endings then maybe they could be classified as

1.Best
2. Bad
3.Really Bad

Is that a correct way of classifying them?

And if so,from everything on this thread, it sounds like that those endings are all chosen within this "final level"

But what I can't piece together is:

What is it about this "final level" that makes it the sole and primary catalyst for one of the three endings?

[๋NeThZOR]

Originally posted by elikos1:

Originally posted by NeThZOR:

There are only 3 endings, and they can all be obtained no matter what your 'ghoul progression' meter is, that is to say how many times you have died and respawned, accelerating your transformation into a ghoul.

The only affect with regards to endings that the ghoul progression has is that Tasi looks a bit different in a certain ending cutscene.

Also, there is no point or decision in the game that affects the outcomes

But it sounds like if there are three endings then maybe they could be classified as

1.Best
2. Bad
3.Really Bad

Is that a correct way of classifying them?

And if so,from everything on this thread, it sounds like that those endings are all chosen within this "final level"

But what I can't piece together is:

What is it about this "final level" that makes it the sole and primary catalyst for one of the three endings?

The 'primary catalyst' is how you choose to end the game, in the final level.

I would suggest you just go to the final level and find out for yourself. You can just reload your last autosave and do each ending consecutively

I don't understand why you would spoil it for yourself if you are so close to the end.

[Neptune Towers]

Originally posted by elikos1:

But it sounds like if there are three endings then maybe they could be classified as

1.Best
2. Bad
3.Really Bad

Is that a correct way of classifying them?

And if so,from everything on this thread, it sounds like that those endings are all chosen within this "final level"

But what I can't piece together is:

What is it about this "final level" that makes it the sole and primary catalyst for one of the three endings?

They depend on what choices you make in the final level, so just see for yourself. Nothing else up to that point is relevant in determining the outcome.

[elikos1]

Can you tell me:

Is it inevitable that main character turns into a ghoul or can it be prevented?

Can you also tell me:

How do you turn on captions so that you can read on screen what main character is saying?

[Bankai9212]

Originally posted by elikos1:

Can you tell me:

Is it inevitable that main character turns into a ghoul or can it be prevented?

Can you also tell me:

How do you turn on captions so that you can read on screen what main character is saying?

First question yes it is, second turn on subtitles.

[elikos1]

In this particular ending :


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9cCclqe77s

at 1:00:21


I'm not sure that I understand: Does the baby girl live or die in this scenario? Is this ending considered good or bad ending?

[elikos1]

allow me to understand:

If main character destroys all stations with hypodermic needle and then observes monster being destroyed at end they will have no opportunity to enter time room and time-warp back to Paris. Is this correct?

[der.dida83]

I don't think either ending could be classified as good or bad. There is no happily ever after ending but if you expect that you probably didn't play their previous games ;)

[Bankai9212]

Originally posted by elikos1:

allow me to understand:

If main character destroys all stations with hypodermic needle and then observes monster being destroyed at end they will have no opportunity to enter time room and time-warp back to Paris. Is this correct?

Yes that’s correct.

[Stealth]

So the way I see it, there are three paths, but technically five endings:

1) Provider "Good" Paris ending - Tasi and Amari make it to Paris with Tasi still human (at least for now)
2) Provider "Bad" Paris ending - Tasi and Amari make it to Paris with Tasi already mostly turned
3) Iconoclast - Tasi sacrifices herself and Amari to destroy the Dark World
4) Harvester - Tasi says goodbye to Amari, and becomes a ghul willingly
5) Harvester - Tasi falls to the Empress and becomes a ghul, doesn't get to say her goodbyes

Note that each ending has a specific credits scene, which is why I consider them separate endings.

[Bankai9212]

Originally posted by Stealth:

So the way I see it, there are three paths, but technically five endings:

1) Provider "Good" Paris ending - Tasi and Amari make it to Paris with Tasi still human (at least for now)
2) Provider "Bad" Paris ending - Tasi and Amari make it to Paris with Tasi already mostly turned
3) Iconoclast - Tasi sacrifices herself and Amari to destroy the Dark World
4) Harvester - Tasi says goodbye to Amari, and becomes a ghul willingly
5) Harvester - Tasi falls to the Empress and becomes a ghul, doesn't get to say her goodbyes

Note that each ending has a specific credits scene, which is why I consider them separate endings.

honestly its 3, minor variations aside harvester and provider end up the same.