ominis or sebastian?

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

who do u prefer?
i like them both but seb's first impression on me was 100% better lol, ommie threatened to report me just for KNOWING where the undercroft is, made me want to punch him or hex him a lil' bit tbh but he got nicer and more interesting later on

[t.jacobs]

Let me think: Ominis is a super responsible person who knows the danger of the dark secrets his family keeps and wants to make sure noone gets ever harmed from them. Sebastian is convinced that he can heal his sister better than the most knowledgable and experienced healers in the word, starts digging into dark secrets he has no idea about and doesn't care about harming and eventually killing dozens of people to maybe find cure.

Though Sebastian may have best intention he is essentially a lunatic who unfortunately has the gift to persuade others to follow him. My Hufflepuff wizard didn't hesitate a second to turn him in. My Slytherin witch however may come to a different decision, once she reaches this point. :-)

[Alshain]

I feel like Ominis' early threat was just posturing. Here is this complete stranger who could be a threat to something he loves.

In any story a character has to grow, the difference is the direction of growth, Ominis' starts as a rival and becomes a friend. Sebastian starts as a friend and declines on a sort of anti-hero path, which is still growth from a literary sense, there is no negative growth, it doesn't matter whether you perceived it as good or bad. I think they are both some of the best fleshed out characters in the story. No other characters in the game exhibit this.

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by Alshain:

I feel like Ominis' early threat was just posturing. Here is this complete stranger who could be a threat to something he loves.

In any story a character has to grow, the difference is the direction of growth, Ominis' starts as a rival and becomes a friend. Sebastian starts as a friend and declines on a sort of anti-hero path, which is still growth from a literary sense, there is no negative growth, it doesn't matter whether you perceived it as good or bad. I think they are both some of the best fleshed out characters in the story. No other characters in the game exhibit this.

i love them both too :) i think they r mah favies! imelda seems to have a bit of growth with the mc tho just not as much
and i love the rest of the npcs too but their personalities dont get many changes through the story

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by t.jacobs:

Let me think: Ominis is a super responsible person who knows the danger of the dark secrets his family keeps and wants to make sure noone gets ever harmed from them. Sebastian is convinced that he can heal his sister better than the most knowledgable and experienced healers in the word, starts digging into dark secrets he has no idea about and doesn't care about harming and eventually killing dozens of people to maybe find cure.

Though Sebastian may have best intention he is essentially a lunatic who unfortunately has the gift to persuade others to follow him. My Hufflepuff wizard didn't hesitate a second to turn him in. My Slytherin witch however may come to a different decision, once she reaches this point. :-)

*cries* the brutal truth abt mah sebbie... he persuaded me, so i made my mc kinda persuade ommie... ITS AN EEEEEVIL DOMINOOOOO EFFEEEEEECT- SOMEHOW BEING EEEEEEEEVIL IS FUNNN FOR MEEEEEEE HEEEELP *faints dramatically*
i can never bring mahself to turn in seb, regardless of the house of my mc- ok fine maaaaaaaaybe i'll turn him in as a puff or my gryff girl cyrene dumbledore, but im gonna be so saaaad! (i have an mc in every house but puff but i will make a puff soon who is a scammander like newt hehe)
im glad that at least ur slyth girlie might keep seb around tho :D

[antoniatonia44444]

Through my first playthrough i must say that Sebastian did appeal to me more. But the more I play, I do realize that Ominis is overall a better person. He despises the dark arts, he is way more responsible and understands the severity of each situation. He was given the opportunity to interfere with the dark arts but he never did. That is a big difference between them. Lets face it. Sebastian would have LOVED to see himself using the dark arts no matter what. And don't tell me otherwise because he DOES know ALL the unforgivable curses and he is also able to cast them successfully. I mean a 15 year old knowing how to cast avada kedavra isn't that innocent is he?And why would you feel the urge to know that spell? Like if i were him i would have been terrified, I wouldn't get into learning the spell knowing the aftermaths of such dark arts. And let me point out something that a lot of people don't seem to notice: I don't think that the part where Sebastian witnesses the memory of Isidora is unintentional. The game showed us that he always had the choice not to interfere with the dark arts to find a cure. He could have easily just keep insisting that we talk to the Keepers. And i mean INSISTING not just telling us once or twice to talk to them. He could have waited for us to do so, to find a different solution but no. He chose the relic instead. I think his complex character was the reason a lot of people like him. The others who simp him are just delusional from these wattpad stories and AI audios on the Internet. But that's not Seb in the game right now, unfortunately. Hopefully he changes in the sequel.

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by antoniatonia44444:

Through my first playthrough i must say that Sebastian did appeal to me more. But the more I play, I do realize that Ominis is overall a better person. He despises the dark arts, he is way more responsible and understands the severity of each situation. He was given the opportunity to interfere with the dark arts but he never did. That is a big difference between them. Lets face it. Sebastian would have LOVED to see himself using the dark arts no matter what. And don't tell me otherwise because he DOES know ALL the unforgivable curses and he is also able to cast them successfully. I mean a 15 year old knowing how to cast avada kedavra isn't that innocent is he?And why would you feel the urge to know that spell? Like if i were him i would have been terrified, I wouldn't get into learning the spell knowing the aftermaths of such dark arts. And let me point out something that a lot of people don't seem to notice: I don't think that the part where Sebastian witnesses the memory of Isidora is unintentional. The game showed us that he always had the choice not to interfere with the dark arts to find a cure. He could have easily just keep insisting that we talk to the Keepers. And i mean INSISTING not just telling us once or twice to talk to them. He could have waited for us to do so, to find a different solution but no. He chose the relic instead. I think his complex character was the reason a lot of people like him. The others who simp him are just delusional from these wattpad stories and AI audios on the Internet. But that's not Seb in the game right now, unfortunately. Hopefully he changes in the sequel.

somehow him casing those curses was admirable to me. no need for me to glorify him when i like him just the way he is: all evil and ruthless
still, i love sweet ommie too <3

[ULTRA]

It depends: do you prefer the sane guy or the insane guy

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by ULTRA:

It depends: do you prefer the sane guy or the insane guy

lol, tbh i like insanity... >:) the sane guy, aka ommie, is still lovely tho :D

[Tanch0]

Ominis of course, and we must fight those who wrongly tarnish the image of Slytherin house

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by Tanch0:

Ominis of course, and we must fight those who wrongly tarnish the image of Slytherin house

That would be people like Draco Malfoy, not people like Sebastian...
I do like Ominis thouhg, I just also like going on adventures with my naughty murdery baddie boi Sebby 😈😋🤤 *Eeeeeevil laugh*

[yogisgoat]

Sebastian, hands down. It's a game, not real life. IRL Ominis would never teach you any of the unforgiveable curses and they bring so much fun. To the game.

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by yogisgoat:

Sebastian, hands down. It's a game, not real life. IRL Ominis would never teach you any of the unforgiveable curses and they bring so much fun. To the game.

Lol finally a fellow Sebby fan!
Idk who I'd prefer IRl cus they are both fun in different ways tbh
But for le game, I think I'm more of a Sebby supporter lol

[Kuma]

The twist that happens with Sebastian really spoils him for me. Omnis all the way.

[EricHVela]

Prefer? Meh.

Who I think is the better person? Ominis. Morals despite everything his family tried to teach him.

Who I think has the better writing? Sebastian. Conflicting morals with deep compassion.

For the story's tone as written, I think it's appropriate toexpelthat kid and letthe Ministrysort him out. Sebastian's story is a parable. It's meant to show the consequences of actions regardless of intentions. The road to ruin, being paved with good intentions, still leads to ruin.

[SheWhoMustNotBeNamed🔮🎭🧛]

Originally posted by EricHVela:

Prefer? Meh.

Who I think is the better person? Ominis. Morals despite everything his family tried to teach him.

Who I think has the better writing? Sebastian. Conflicting morals with deep compassion.

For the story's tone as written, I think it's appropriate toexpelthat kid and letthe Ministrysort him out. Sebastian's story is a parable. It's meant to show the consequences of actions regardless of intentions. The road to ruin, being paved with good intentions, still leads to ruin.

I like them both for those reasons too, Sebby is my precious boi tho so no one's gonna punish him on my watch- his guilt and his sister disappearing and not wanting to be found will be punishment enough for him
Maybe his sister will come around one day, though... and I want him to be in a better, happier place when/if that happens