Demiguise moons not tracking

[S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com]

as title says. my demiguise moons stopped tracking on the first part at 7/9. i decided after collecting a few to go see the sauced up asian guy and still got lvl2 alohomora but it still will not track. anyone else having this?

[halfmonkey]

I ended up with 9 statues stuck in inventory at the end, despite turning them all in.

[Zorg]

Mine is stuck at 1/9 after finding 3 :)
However, I don't really care anymore. Hopefully main storyline is not bound to alohomora lvl 2-3..
I figured out there is not much reward for opening chests and stuff.. always some random low lvl crap to find

[AndyJS]

I think it tracks how many you have handed over, rather than how many you have found.

[Orion Invictus]

Originally posted by AndyJS:

I think it tracks how many you have handed over, rather than how many you have found.

This is correct. I think that's also explicitly pointed out in the journal entry, but I'm not sure.

[MajorAssman]

Originally posted by AndyJS:

I think it tracks how many you have handed over, rather than how many you have found.

this, you can check how many you currently have in your inventory

[⛧NecRoBile⛧]

I just got Alohomora III and I found that the journal tracks those you've turned in. I had 8 out of 13 for awhile until I had 5 in my inventory, and once I turned them in I got the spell.

That could be the issue

[IchigoMait]

The quest says that you can collect all the demiguises if you want, it's just for the achievement. So you will have 9 of them at the end in the inventory, quest itself only needs some of it, not all, like with every other side quest.

You'll never turn all of 'em in.

[S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com]

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

Originally posted by AndyJS:

I think it tracks how many you have handed over, rather than how many you have found.

This is correct. I think that's also explicitly pointed out in the journal entry, but I'm not sure.

that has to be wrong. i hadnt handed in any outside of the 2 you get as part of the story to get alohomora at first but was stuck at 7/9

[IchigoMait]

Originally posted by S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com:

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

This is correct. I think that's also explicitly pointed out in the journal entry, but I'm not sure.

that has to be wrong. i hadnt handed in any outside of the 2 you get as part of the story to get alohomora at first but was stuck at 7/9

You get the Alohomora spell after removing the first demiguise moon.
Then you get 2 demiguises in the quest itself 1 in Prefects' Bathroom and 1 in Hospital Wing.
So after completing the tutorial questline for Alohomora and demiguises, you already have 2 out of 9, aka you need 7 more from 9, you can't skip 'em, unless there was an option to not give him those 2 yet, but clearly you gave those 2 away.


It tracks how many you have handed over, the count doesn't change when I pick up demiguises it only changes when I hand 'em over, I handed over what it wanted, after I got my 3rd Alohomora spell, the quest giver literally tells you that you can go on collect the rest of 'em if you want.

I had to check the inventory to see when I can give more in, as the quest will never tell you when you can give 'em in, you can always turn 'em in, you just to have some in the inv, it was the only quest where you had to be active about checking what you collect.

I have 9 left over.
On the fextralife page though it says for the trophy you need 33, which I have gotten, but then I should have 11 left, I'm suspecting that when you're handing over the demiguises, it either gives more away than what it needs.
Or considering the guide itself mentioned that 3 demiguises do not exist on the world map, but they say you need 'em to get the achievement, and that leaves us with 9 from 11 that are left over in the inventory.

[margalus]

Originally posted by S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com:

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

This is correct. I think that's also explicitly pointed out in the journal entry, but I'm not sure.

that has to be wrong. i hadnt handed in any outside of the 2 you get as part of the story to get alohomora at first but was stuck at 7/9

It's not wrong. The game only tracks the ones that are turned in. The ones in your inventory do not count.

[S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com]

Originally posted by IchigoMait:

Originally posted by S0lv3ntFl3X allkeyshop.com:

that has to be wrong. i hadnt handed in any outside of the 2 you get as part of the story to get alohomora at first but was stuck at 7/9

You get the Alohomora spell after removing the first demiguise moon.
Then you get 2 demiguises in the quest itself 1 in Prefects' Bathroom and 1 in Hospital Wing.
So after completing the tutorial questline for Alohomora and demiguises, you already have 2 out of 9, aka you need 7 more from 9, you can't skip 'em, unless there was an option to not give him those 2 yet, but clearly you gave those 2 away.


It tracks how many you have handed over, the count doesn't change when I pick up demiguises it only changes when I hand 'em over, I handed over what it wanted, after I got my 3rd Alohomora spell, the quest giver literally tells you that you can go on collect the rest of 'em if you want.

I had to check the inventory to see when I can give more in, as the quest will never tell you when you can give 'em in, you can always turn 'em in, you just to have some in the inv, it was the only quest where you had to be active about checking what you collect.

I have 9 left over.
On the fextralife page though it says for the trophy you need 33, which I have gotten, but then I should have 11 left, I'm suspecting that when you're handing over the demiguises, it either gives more away than what it needs.
Or considering the guide itself mentioned that 3 demiguises do not exist on the world map, but they say you need 'em to get the achievement, and that leaves us with 9 from 11 that are left over in the inventory.

that still doesnt explain why it said 7/9 not 2/9 i received the second level spell regardless. now i have handed in 8 more moons and guess what? it says 0/13 so...

[...]

Anyone has any idea where can we find Moon guy after the entire questline is over ? I have collected all the moons but i never realised he didnt take all of them. Now i cant find that guy anywhere on the map and i havent recieved the achievement (even though i have collected all the moons)

Alternatively any idea if i can just mod or something and get the achievement ?

[halfmonkey]

Originally posted by .......:

Anyone has any idea where can we find Moon guy after the entire questline is over ? I have collected all the moons but i never realised he didnt take all of them. Now i cant find that guy anywhere on the map and i havent recieved the achievement (even though i have collected all the moons)

Alternatively any idea if i can just mod or something and get the achievement ?

Try either his quarters outside by the thestral stables in the ramparts or (if he specifically mentions visiting Hogsmeade at the quest end,) The Three Broomsticks. Visit either place at night. (No idea where he goes during the day after the quest...)

Should warn you that he won't take the last 9 moons, but he does have a few lines of dialogue.

[Snerfette]

I am also having the problem being stuck at 7/9 demiguise. I just picked up another 2 demiguose and my count hasn't changed.