Is this game worth replaying?

[EidolonBae]

Was wondering if this game has enough of a difference in content between houses to justify another play through despite reaching 100% field guide completion in Ravenclaw?

[ZodaSoda]

That depends on you and your love of Harry Potter, You get to see a different house, get a few very minor dialogue changes when you meet people and you get 1 different quest per house (2 for Hufflepuff)

Personally for me, no not worth it.

[Captain Flappy]

Originally posted by EidolonBae:

Was wondering if this game has enough of a difference in content between houses to justify another play through despite reaching 100% field guide completion in Ravenclaw?

if you have 100% field guide completion surely you can answer it yourself? :/

Do you feel like you will replay it? if so then you will have you your answer.

I am 26 hours in and have around 53% challenges in total completed (PS5.) I will def replay one day after I complete it, but not anytime soon.

[Coyote]

To me, its a one and done. but i already have an absurd amount of hours in it since im taking my time.

Too much linear fluff for the first 10 hours of the game for me to say its replayable.
And your character build will mostly be the exact same.

Hell, lots of the dialog doesnt even give you a choice on how to respond. Like, i didnt want to fly the broom with that kid that got me in trouble for example.
But i was forced to. kinda lame.

The only thing that is really all that different is the loot system. I think its randomized, however nothing interesting drops until you are halfway through the game anyways.

[Nightskies]

Consider what you spent your time doing in the game and what the result of different choices would be.

A 1-and-done game, really.

[Lyric]

Imo, there's zero replayability value. The only difference in houses is a useless common room and one very early quest in the main story. Your choices, dialogue or action, do not matter. There will be no difference at all between your first character and any subsequent characters except for whatever you imagine in your head. Collecting random junk is the bulk of the game. It's only good for one playthrough and that's it unless you really love Harry Potter and don't have a dozen other better games in your library.

[Bob Gnarly]

Most of the dialogue and quests are the same, there's a only a few changes based on your chosen house which doesn't warrant another playthrough IMO.

[MugHug]

Originally posted by EidolonBae:

Is this game worth replaying?

What is your criteria?

You pose a question that even an educated professor could not answer, because he is not you and in turn the posters that part with their grand knowledge are also not you. We all look for different things in our games.

[DocA]

I'm sitting near the end of my first playthrough, and I'm not really drawn to restart. The lack of impactful endings is a biggie, but there is more. The game gets a 10 out of 10 for straight up charm. Many of the puzzles are fun and challenging. But there is a repetitiveness to the game that starts to weigh on it. Bandit camps are almost all identical, towns same, the challenge of the Merlin puzzles is more about finding the stuff once you learned the four or five ways to beat them, etc. So restarting at level one or zipping around at level 40 doesn't really feel that different to me. As a one off, I would give this game a solid 9/10, but its open world replay value is almost nill.

[[RSB]DonnyBresko]

Yes and No - I "replayed" the game 3 times, for each house, but just for the one Mission that is different to other houses and for the achievement. So i played as Gryffindor till 100% and then all other houses until the Map Chamber. The rest is not different to the rest.

[Supgad]

I plan to replay each House, only to complete the achievements I need for Perfection.

Those House-specific quests happen early enough in the game, though, that it's not a colossal undertaking.

[Dragon Master]

Before the game released I was planning in multiple playthroughs. Now that I've completed the game and did 100% of my field guide, I still plan to replay the game because it's a lot of fun and a great game to the point it reminds me of games back in the early 2000's that released in a complete state and everything can be unlocked in the game without a single microtransaction, but I've got other games to play first.

[[RSB]DonnyBresko]

Originally posted by Lyric:

Your choices, dialogue or action, do not matter.

This is not true tho
There are some dialogues where your answers have an impact (No Spoiler)

[Punished Rusty Shackleford]

I'm probably going to replay it in a few months. I have a huge backlog but I enjoyed what I played overall.

[kiaralight]

I am playing through a second time, though the 2nd time has mods I can play with. I would say so long as you are having fun play as many times as you want. once you get tired of it then stop.

[NatalieSauvage]

Definitively not. THe only difference is in one mission - is about how you find lost pages. The other things is the same. After completing all 4 houses beginings there is no reason to return into the game.