Yes Hogwarts Legacy is better then Witcher 3 game

[placeforpets]

In Witcher 3 is have a quest called the Blood Baron line and it is an the carrying quest for the game if you removing that quest than an game is down hard to be honest and Hogwarts Legacy is it not having this problem plus infinte better combat so it is obvious

[Uranio 235]

storyline is betther in the witcher, combat is better here

[Unrighteous]

I have to disagree when it comes to the writing. I think the witcher is better, but the combat and exploration are definitely way better in Legacy.

[Tenshin51]

Witcher 3 have a ton of decent story quest and dialogue compared to Hogswart Legacy. The only thing good is Sebastian story then the writers in Legacy go 360 ruined that story. Even Legacy Main story is terrible.
The only good w/ Legacy:
Exploration and collectibles are really good but a poor man version of BOTW
Combat is definitely better than Witcher 3 clunky design sadly Legacy AI is just terrible. Even W3 level scaling mode is just plain terrible rats and the Djinn can instantly kill. I am not even sure CDPR fix their level scaling mode. Anyone saying W3 combat is good have nostalgia glasses on.
Gear and loot system are better than W3. W3 loot and reward are trash. One of leader of Skellige giving you his priceless heirloom sword then when you check the gear trash it's trash that's the loot system of W3.

If you want story and dialogue matters play W3. If you want an average BOTW clone play Hogswart Legacy w/ Wizarding World.

[aL]

I found the combat way too easy in the early game and the enemies far too tanky in the late game, I do really like the world of The Witcher 3 and its dlc's but I find Hogwarts Legacy a bit lackluster, if the game wasn't associated with Harry Potter, a lot of people would find it more of a mid-tier game

[Jellie Juice]

Anyone who thinks HL is better than Witcher 3 is either a kid or someone who is smoking some special crack.

[Takingdomscosimog]

Originally posted by Jellie Juice:

Anyone who thinks HL is better than Witcher 3 is either a kid or someone who is smoking some special crack.

100%

[Calv]

Yeah, Witcher 3 is definitely over hyped but is also better than HL in pretty much every way.

The RPG elements are more substantial, your choices actually impact the story, the combat is a lot more challenging and requires actual thought and preparation.

[LexCondran]

Originally posted by IlIIlIIlI:

In Witcher 3 is have a quest called the Blood Baron line and it is an the carrying quest for the game if you removing that quest than an game is down hard to be honest and Hogwarts Legacy is it not having this problem plus infinte better combat so it is obvious

witcher just feels exceedingly boring

i love exploring and fighting in hogwarts
But the room of requirement, pets potions plants, is best

[Uranio 235]

ps3 still hold the best rpg games ever made, fallouts and elder scrolls. these new gen games have good graphics poor interactable scenarios and npcs

[Spazfrag]

Originally posted by Jellie Juice:

Anyone who thinks HL is better than Witcher 3 is either a kid or someone who is smoking some special crack.

This. Holy hell.

[BrentONI]

I actually Gree, i hate to be drunk to enjoy witcher "dancing around with a sword like a prick"

[ComradCommodore]

Originally posted by Jellie Juice:

Anyone who thinks HL is better than Witcher 3 is either a kid or someone who is smoking some special crack.

I just figured the person was trolling lol , cause there isnt even a conversation to be had. I like HL but its brain dead easy, story is as linear as they come.

[Simbe]

Sure, mate. It's so much better playing as an absolute nobody of a character with no background, no family, no friends. That's not how HP universe works.

[Takingdomscosimog]

Originally posted by ComradCommodore:

Originally posted by Jellie Juice:

Anyone who thinks HL is better than Witcher 3 is either a kid or someone who is smoking some special crack.

I just figured the person was trolling lol , cause there isnt even a conversation to be had. I like HL but its brain dead easy, story is as linear as they come.

Even without going into specifics although it's pretty obvious TW3 is in another league in terms of quality anyway, TW3 has actual content. Good content, that keeps you interested for a long time.

TW3 is one of those games that once you fall into will keep you enraptured for ages, I mean I got so into gwent that it became 50% of the game for me, building decks and playing for money etc.

Top tier game, where as HL got very stale already.

[ComradCommodore]

Originally posted by Takingdomscosimog:

Originally posted by ComradCommodore:

I just figured the person was trolling lol , cause there isnt even a conversation to be had. I like HL but its brain dead easy, story is as linear as they come.

Even without going into specifics although it's pretty obvious TW3 is in another league in terms of quality anyway, TW3 has actual content. Good content, that keeps you interested for a long time.

TW3 is one of those games that once you fall into will keep you enraptured for ages, I mean I got so into gwent that it became 50% of the game for me, building decks and playing for money etc.

Top tier game, where as HL got very stale already.

100%

I dont want to trash HL (really wanna love this game), but as i said its just soooooooooooo easy.
-Puzzles with obvious solutions, often times 2 ft away from the objective
-Your character telling you exactly what to do when standing in a room for more than 2 seconds
-Unlocking locked doors is just a time waster
-Plz god no more spiders
-Wish Hogwarts was more than just a quest hub (common room is useless, potions class is useless, plant class is useless. exc.)
-Linear story, conversation choices really dont matter at all

Convinced if this wasnt Harry Potter the score would be somewhere in the high-mid 70s low 80s