The Wizarding World officially has a trans character

[Awaken]

How would you feel if Sirona Ryan the transgender witch was included in the next Harry Potter book

[PocketYoda]

Actually Avalanche worked with JK Rowlings team Portkey..

[Imufur]

I wouldnt care, dont get the people nitpicking about a single character or waiting for mods to remove black characters, its sad

[greypoe]

If wizards and witches wanted to be a transvestite all they have to do is wear female clothes. With enchantments they can make it look like they have tits, and with good enchantments they would give themselves a female voice. I would just prefer a good ol tomboy girl who is a girl that is cute, but just wants to hang around boys and be one of the boys. We didn't call those transgenders in our time, we just accepted them as tomboys.

I would rather that bartender just come out and say he is a male who plays female characters.

[Kenshiro]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Awaken:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Kenshiro:

I already have a mod that changes the voice to something feminine and I installed it before hearing what she sounded like before.
So honestly... I don't care. There will always be something to address the issue.

The English version is the canon version, Sirona is canonically a trasgender who doesn't pass, you are modding him to be a transgender who passes. Are you really okay with this:wfmerc:

As long as it doesn't ruin my immersion. Yes.
Having a someone look feminine and having an obviously masculine voice is jarring and immersion breaking.
If making the voice match the look to keep the immersion, I'm doing it. If they can pretend it's a trans character, I can pretend it's not.
Out of sight, out of mind essentially, but for like.... Voices? Whatever. You get it.

[felixader]

There is a mod out there that fixes the pitch. It is still a deep voice but it doesn't make the voice feel like someone dubbed over the original voice after the fact.

I am really sorry, for everyone offended by this, but it was just absolutely distracting. It was just done badly.

[zcaalock]

I think trans character in wizarding world is the only scenario, since sex transition in real world is impossible

[Madjar]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von greypoe:

If wizards and witches wanted to be a transvestite all they have to do is wear female clothes. With enchantments they can make it look like they have tits, and with good enchantments they would give themselves a female voice. I would just prefer a good ol tomboy girl who is a girl that is cute, but just wants to hang around boys and be one of the boys. We didn't call those transgenders in our time, we just accepted them as tomboys.

I would rather that bartender just come out and say he is a male who plays female characters.

Tomboy supremacy.

[Craiberk]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Imufur:

I wouldnt care, dont get the people nitpicking about a single character or waiting for mods to remove black characters, its sad

What is sad is the fact that you dismiss any legitimate points as nitpicking out of hand for no other reason than because they contradict your political views.

That you dismiss them on the basis of your prejudice that "everyone who is against diversity can only hold that position because they are hateful. My friends who never actually talk or listen to those people told me so" is even sadder.

[Yeast Lord]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Awaken:

How would you feel if Sirona Ryan the transgender witch was included in the next Harry Potter book:wfmerc:

lol

[zero.calvin]

I dont really have any problem with Sirona Ryan, her character is well written... being transgender is just part of her character as whole, it's not her defining characteristic like many woke character tend to be...

[Tachyon]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Awaken:

How would you feel if Sirona Ryan the transgender witch was included in the next Harry Potter book:wfmerc:

Well, since this game is set in the late 1800's I think it's safe to say she'd be dead in an actual Harry Potter book set sometime in the 20th or 21st Centuries..

[Alzakiel]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Awaken:

How would you feel if Sirona Ryan the transgender witch was included in the next Harry Potter book:wfmerc:

If that's the only reason to add it to the book, no.

If it's because the character is indeed interesting, yes.

Also no, being trans doesn't make a character interesting by itself.