HARRY DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE

[M.A.C.H.I.N.E.]

Dumbledore said calmly

[Witch ~]

CALMLY

[Witch ~]

Have they ever explained why they changed it like that

[Leon]

I just re-read GoF and i should say , 90% of the book felt like filler .

Its is good , dont get me wrong , i like the plot , the tournment, the other schools , Cedric is my fav character in th efranchise , but i have to say , with a good editor this book could be cut to a third of its lenght to make a much better reading.

And , my god , that Quidditch world cup is SO BORING

[PocketYoda]

Originally posted by Leon:

I just re-read GoF and i should say , 90% of the book felt like filler .

Its is good , dont get me wrong , i like the plot , the tournment, the other schools , Cedric is my fav character in th efranchise , but i have to say , with a good editor this book could be cut to a third of its lenght to make a much better reading.

And , my god , that Quidditch world cup is SO BORING

I agree book 5 and 6 did feel like filler to me as well.

[Ragnarr Loðbrók]

Originally posted by Leon:

I just re-read GoF and i should say , 90% of the book felt like filler .

Its is good , dont get me wrong , i like the plot , the tournment, the other schools , Cedric is my fav character in th efranchise , but i have to say , with a good editor this book could be cut to a third of its lenght to make a much better reading.

And , my god , that Quidditch world cup is SO BORING

don't dare to cut the book!, i love those "fillers" since they are relevant and enriches the background story

[Leon]

Originally posted by PocketYoda:

I agree book 5 and 6 did feel like filler to me as well.

Years ago i read the first 4 books and droped the franchise , now this game got me back to HP and i re-read then but i really never read books 5 to 7, it will be my first.
Right now i'm at Order of Phoenix chapter 6 and i'm liking it a lot.A much more focused and relevant beggning then GoF ... and i'm already in love with Tonks xD

Originally posted by Ragnarr Loðbrók:

don't dare to cut the book!, i love those "fillers" since they are relevant and enriches the background story

I dont mind the subplots like S.P.E.W , Rita Skeeter , the romance , etc.But i think JKR could have been much more economic with words. Tone dawn some long winded descriptions and dialogues.Like the quidditc world cup "arc" could have been done in just 1 or 2 chapters.

[Lord_Triscen]

wtf Goblet of Fire Book and Movie are the best ones...

[EXØRCiST]

Calmly... but it's all in caps.

[Си́нтез]

why would DD need to raise the voice, he either reads you or already knows the truth through his elf-spies anyway.

[Captain Flappy]

Originally posted by Witch ~:

Have they ever explained why they changed it like that

Michael Gambon never read the books and had no idea to play Dumbledore. not me guessing either.

[Captain Flappy]

Originally posted by Lord_Triscen:

wtf Goblet of Fire Book and Movie are the best ones...

book, yes... movie? lol.

[PocketYoda]

Originally posted by Captain Flappy:

Originally posted by Lord_Triscen:

wtf Goblet of Fire Book and Movie are the best ones...

book, yes... movie? lol.

Nahh one i'm not a huge fan of Quidditch myself and the 5 and 6th books were laced with backstory which is good but for me they were a dry read.