Hit Detection in Halo 3 is Broken

[Flavorful]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4jTsS_otY4

Seriously pathetic. The game has been out for 5+ years and the hit detection still is not right.

[DukeoftheAges]

I haven't had a single issue with it

[Flavorful]

Originally posted by DukeoftheAges:

I haven't had a single issue with it

I have had countless. I watch bullets hit people from like 15 feet away without registration, and my ping is around 30 at most.

[TheNamesJT]

I have experenced the same thing in many lobbies i also have encountered hitreg and aim assist being so strong where i die in 2 shots full health on normal slayer the game is legit broken for me about to get a refund....

[Pyrocitor]

Watch this part of the discussion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBwFyNp8t2o&feature=youtu.be&t=2206
if the timed link doesnt work, go to 36 minutes, 45 seconds.

the gist of it is that they ARE working on it, they don't want to just slap a band-aid fix like bullet velocities, that breaks other stuff. they seem to be fully deconstructing how the bullet tracking works, and figuring out where and how it's become different with the increased tick-rate, and how to repair it.

[Lugen]

The proof of hitreg being broken is it is impossible to 4shot br someone. Once again 343 manages to release a game with horrible hitreg.

[Sahara Vice]

Originally posted by Pyrocitor:

Watch this part of the discussion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBwFyNp8t2o&feature=youtu.be&t=2206
if the timed link doesnt work, go to 36 minutes, 45 seconds.

the gist of it is that they ARE working on it, they don't want to just slap a band-aid fix like bullet velocities, that breaks other stuff. they seem to be fully deconstructing how the bullet tracking works, and figuring out where and how it's become different with the increased tick-rate, and how to repair it.

TBF, it’s been 5-6 years since people had reported problems about the H3 stuff

[Flavorful]

Originally posted by Pyrocitor:

Watch this part of the discussion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBwFyNp8t2o&feature=youtu.be&t=2206
if the timed link doesnt work, go to 36 minutes, 45 seconds.

the gist of it is that they ARE working on it, they don't want to just slap a band-aid fix like bullet velocities, that breaks other stuff. they seem to be fully deconstructing how the bullet tracking works, and figuring out where and how it's become different with the increased tick-rate, and how to repair it.

Hurray! 5 years later and they finally decide to start working on it!

[Pyrocitor]

Originally posted by Neon Sand:

Originally posted by Pyrocitor:

Watch this part of the discussion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBwFyNp8t2o&feature=youtu.be&t=2206
if the timed link doesnt work, go to 36 minutes, 45 seconds.

the gist of it is that they ARE working on it, they don't want to just slap a band-aid fix like bullet velocities, that breaks other stuff. they seem to be fully deconstructing how the bullet tracking works, and figuring out where and how it's become different with the increased tick-rate, and how to repair it.

TBF, it’s been 5-6 years since people had reported problems about the H3 stuff

I'm not saying it's not broken.
I'm just providing the most recent discussion that they're aiming to fix that.
They HAVE recently fixed some things which were previously broken for years (heck, i think elite dual wield in Halo 2 again as of yesterdays update - don't quote me on that just yet though, i'm checking myself now)

[Flavorful]

Originally posted by Pyrocitor:

Originally posted by Neon Sand:

TBF, it’s been 5-6 years since people had reported problems about the H3 stuff

I'm not saying it's not broken.
I'm just providing the most recent discussion that they're aiming to fix that.
They HAVE recently fixed some things which were previously broken for years (heck, i think elite dual wield in Halo 2 again as of yesterdays update - don't quote me on that just yet though, i'm checking myself now)

I just think its scummy for them to leave console users hanging for 5+ years then decide to finally get around to it AFTER PC launches. Also his wording implies they don't plan to urgently fix this, which is even more pathetic.

[JellyPants7]

I am not usually uppity about these things but I think I agree on this one. Something feels off with the BR, isn't the same. Been playing this game for years and some games I dominate and others I am piss poor. Also, why is nobody playing objective? Endless slayer is getting boring.

[Zangato]

Yep 10$ saved. gonna wait for Halo 4.

[Flavorful]

Originally posted by Shadowlet:

It's the same hit detection that's been in the game 13 years ago.

It's not? Maybe watch the video I posted.

[TheNamesJT]

Originally posted by Lügenpresse:

The proof of hitreg being broken is it is impossible to 4shot br someone. Once again 343 manages to release a game with horrible hitreg.

I been 2 shot killed by a br today what you talking about dude maybe you just haven't experienced it yet i also experience putting 15 br shots above the torso more then enough landed that shoud of been a kill but it wasn't....just because you haven't experineced any issues doesn't mean its not present

[Flavorful]

Originally posted by TheNamesJT:

Originally posted by Lügenpresse:

The proof of hitreg being broken is it is impossible to 4shot br someone. Once again 343 manages to release a game with horrible hitreg.

I been 2 shot killed by a br today what you talking about dude maybe you just haven't experienced it yet i also experience putting 15 br shots above the torso more then enough landed that shoud of been a kill but it wasn't....just because you haven't experineced any issues doesn't mean its not present

He isn't saying the problem doesn't exist, he is saying the opposite. And 2 shotting people isn't possible so chances are you are lagging.

[TheNamesJT]

Originally posted by Flavorful:

Originally posted by TheNamesJT:

I been 2 shot killed by a br today what you talking about dude maybe you just haven't experienced it yet i also experience putting 15 br shots above the torso more then enough landed that shoud of been a kill but it wasn't....just because you haven't experineced any issues doesn't mean its not present

He isn't saying the problem doesn't exist, he is saying the opposite. And 2 shotting people isn't possible so chances are you are lagging.

I wan't lagging bro it happen many times today in different lobbies where 1 br shot would put my hp bar to blinking red and the next shot would kill me vs me putting 15 br shots in a dude and nothing happends to him there is 100% something off with the game and i been playing since the beggining i'm now on pc and can tell something doesn't feel right....time will tell