Cookbook / Collection bug?

[Hannibal Lahr]

I filled out the cookbook and got the achievement for finding all the recipes, but when I went to the collector to cash in I found that I was still missing two recipes that weren't in the book (turned out to be garlic bread and wonton soup). Anyone else have an issue?

[Sassmotron]

I think for it to count for Susan you need to have made the dish yourself, not just found the recipe/dish.

[Hannibal Lahr]

Originally posted by Sassmotron:

I think for it to count for Susan you need to have made the dish yourself, not just found the recipe/dish.

That makes sense. Thank you.

[Rud Passos]

I have the same problem. There are 2 recipes left for me to complete Susan's collection, but I've already cooked these dishes. I do not know what to do.

[rmsgrey]

Originally posted by Rud Passos:

I have the same problem. There are 2 recipes left for me to complete Susan's collection, but I've already cooked these dishes. I do not know what to do.

Have you tried cooking them again?

Some of the treasure chests around the world include recipes, so the kitchen recipe list isn't a perfect record of what you've cooked, only of the recipes you've discovered (mostly by cooking them).

My recollection is that Susan tracks dishes you've ever owned, so being given food by a spirit would count for Susan, but not for the recipe book. I could be misremembering, and you might need to cook everything for her.