So... Why do I have to add a roof of some sort just to use a crafting table...

[JoJoFan87]

HUGE NEGATIVE... In my opinion.

[Washell]

Next time it rains, go outside and make a bird house. It'll start making sense then. ;)

On topic, wood is all around you, and you can stick a roof piece to a tree or rock outcropping so it's fairly trivial to put a roof over a crafting station.

[JoJoFan87]

Originally posted by Washell:

Next time it rains, go outside and make a bird house. It'll start making sense then. ;)

On topic, wood is all around you, and you can stick a roof piece to a tree or rock outcropping so it's fairly trivial to put a roof over a crafting station.

Just not a fan of it compared to the likes of Minecraft where you just plop it down and there you go.

[John]

Originally posted by JoJoFan87:

Originally posted by Washell:

Next time it rains, go outside and make a bird house. It'll start making sense then. ;)

On topic, wood is all around you, and you can stick a roof piece to a tree or rock outcropping so it's fairly trivial to put a roof over a crafting station.

Just not a fan of it compared to the likes of Minecraft where you just plop it down and there you go.

Then go play minecraft.

[Arachnyd]

4 wall segments, two in back, one on each side, connected; 2 45 degree wall segs and 2 45 degree roofs....push the workbench as far back into the structure and it'll work (there are probably some more simple ones, but this is what I use :-) )

Arach

[Megahurts]

Why? Simple answer is for game balance. Being able to plop a bench down and (no cost) repair all your stuff (amongst other reasons) would be too easy.

[JoJoFan87]

Originally posted by Megahurts:

Why? Simple answer is for game balance. Being able to plop a bench down and (no cost) repair all your stuff (amongst other reasons) would be too easy.

Yet they add the function to fix all gear without cost...

[Megahurts]

...but you need a roof...so a base of even the simplest sorts. So there is a cost.

[Krayor Krelion]

Originally posted by Washell:

Next time it rains, go outside and make a bird house. It'll start making sense then. ;)

Rain doesn't prevent someone from using a work bench let alone being outside. <_<

No, this is just another one of those strange design restrictions that make little sense to all but the dev who designed it that way.

[Nightlistic]

You can drop a crafting table down to do basic crafting you just can't repair stuff. I make one covered crafting table then place several around my base so they stretch out allowing me to craft quite far around the perimeter of my base.

[GeoForce]

Originally posted by Nightlistic:

You can drop a crafting table down to do basic crafting you just can't repair stuff. I make one covered crafting table then place several around my base so they stretch out allowing me to craft quite far around the perimeter of my base.

I do the same. Cant get the garden and everything I need in radius of 1 crafting table

[jonnin]

what are you balancing?!
its just an aggravation. Its a valid one: try building something when your tools are 100 yards away from what you are working on, or out in the rain or even hot mid-day sun. But there is no real game change to make it have a bigger radius or not need a roof; it may be a dose of realism but it does not change much either way. Its < 2 min to gather 30 wood and nail one up even as a new character -- hardly a big deal in terms of gameplay.

[Altimely]

Originally posted by Krayor Krelion:

Originally posted by Washell:

Next time it rains, go outside and make a bird house. It'll start making sense then. ;)

Rain doesn't prevent someone from using a work bench let alone being outside. <_<

No, this is just another one of those strange design restrictions that make little sense to all but the dev who designed it that way.

...it doesn't? I'm not saying it's impossible but people usually put up some kind of cover if they're working on a project. Rain definitely impedes the ability to work. This isn't some arbitrary design restriction, it makes about as much sense as anything else in the game.

[warrenchmobile]

"No, this is just another one of those strange design restrictions that make little sense to all but the dev who designed it that way."

-- Krayor Krelion

I could not agree more. The game is full of them. My viking can refuse to eat and not starve to death. My viking can refuse to sleep and not collapse from exhaustion. My viking can 'remember' how to craft items he never encountered in his life on Earth once he gathers resources he never encountered in his life on Earth. My viking can craft, in a few minutes, a set of armor that would have taken him days or weeks to make in his life on Earth if he had been a master armorer. And the list goes on and on.

Perhaps that dev made this particular "strange design restriction" just to annoy you. In that case, thanks a lot.

[us271934-Слава Україн]

Originally posted by JoJoFan87:

HUGE NEGATIVE... In my opinion.

I'm having trouble getting past "HUGE NEGATIVE" about a few pieces of wood. I think John had the most spot on comment.

[Lavarious]

Originally posted by Megahurts:

Why? Simple answer is for game balance. Being able to plop a bench down and (no cost) repair all your stuff (amongst other reasons) would be too easy.

It's not for game balance. It's really just an odd design choice that doesn't really need to be there.

However at the same time, it really doesn't matter. It takes an extra 10 seconds if your going slow to either put it next to a tree and put two roof segments down. Or to put a wall with a few roof segments. Out of all the major time sinks in this game. This is basically the most minor of nitpicky details.