I think I solved Midnight Motorist

[Kaleidio]

So, I looked at the game again. And I've pieced together a very solid theory...

On reddit, a user who decompiled FFPS found out the bonus minigame is named "later that night." The purple car in the game may very well be the car William used to grab Charlie, and he was now making a run for it back home. When he arrives home though, he's...ORANGE?

Okay, hear me out from here. Orange is a skin color; leading me to believe the purple is a uniform for freddy's security guards. This can be confirmed by the drawings at the beginning of FFPS; there is not one image where that man isn't wearing something blue or purple, and any time he is, it is either a tuxedo or a security uniform. I think this means William took his uniform off so he could not be identified while he ran from the scene.

Now, when he gets home, we see a man in a chair with gray (pajamas? I'm just gonna call them that) watching television. Not only is this a very clear reference to Sister Location, but it also means that HAS to be Michael Afton during Sister Location; confirming Sister Location happened directly beside the other games.

Now here's where I get different from most. I have the ability to confirm the Bite of 83 Victim was in the locked room; it is because the murders happened before his death. This would explain why he grew a fear of them, and not the puppet; because Charlie died while he wasn't there; he was at home, locked in his room. This means the child had just ran off to Freddy's, and has yet to find the dead children when he steps inside, thus giving him the fears of the pizzeria. William says "he'll be sorry when he gets back," because I think at this point, he's 100% sure his second son will find out what he did. This also explains the line in FNaF4 night 3, "No! Don't you remember what you saw?" That's because he DID see the murders. That's why he got afraid of them in the first place, and Midnight Motorist helps cofirm it.

What do you guys think? I think this explains that minigame 70% (because I am NOT touching Jr's: NEVER) but also confirms the murders happened before the child's bite.

the following is a joke to reference Hollywood "five stars" advertisements.

Major critics review this theory:
TigerBear991 - It's one of the more intriguing theories on Midnight Motorist I've ever seen.

PhantomCube08 - This theory is actually pretty solid

Holy Crater™ - Interesting!

[Tiger-Bear991]

I was going to give my thoughts on Scrawn's Midnight Motorist theory. But this thread has turned into a MatPat flame war. So I'm just gonna back off...

[Glorious M e l o n]

Messaggio originale di Smear:

Messaggio originale di Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

No but he uses it as a defence of his theories by saying "Hey it's just a theory, you can't tear apart my video."

You are still making up something. He says that, but never said "You cant hate it its just a theory" when someone says his theory is bad

But the thing is: that's what he implies. He says that as a pre-argument defence to ward off any criticism, but he doesn't seem to realize how his defence doesn't make sense.

[Jesse]

Messaggio originale di Tiger-Bear991:

I was going to give my thoughts on Scrawn's Midnight Motorist theory. But this thread has turned into a MatPat flame war. So I'm just gonna back off...

Its my fault. I brought it up.

[Kaleidio]

Let's all just drop the Matpat thing and just talk about my theory, okay? I kinda feel awkward now...

Edit: hmm...never mind. That was already dropped. Anyway, what are your thoughts badger, Endergamer and Tigerbear?

[Tiger-Bear991]

Messaggio originale di Chivelle the Scrawn:

Let's all just drop the Matpat thing and just talk about my theory, okay? I kinda feel awkward now...

Edit: hmm...never mind. That was already dropped. Anyway, what are your thoughts badger and Tigerbear?

It's one of the more intriguing Midnight Motorist theories I've seen.

[Glorious M e l o n]

Eh...it's alright. But why would CC run off to a place he hates? And also Michael is the one having the FNaF 4 nightmares, not CC.

[Kaleidio]

Messaggio originale di Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Eh...it's alright. But why would CC run off to a place he hates? And also Michael is the one having the FNaF 4 nightmares, not CC.

My theory is he didn't hate it until that night. He would stumble upon Charlie's dead body or something like that and thus spark the emotions.

I also agree with him not being the main player. I meant more in the parts of the minigames - I'll edit that now.

[Glorious M e l o n]

Messaggio originale di Chivelle the Scrawn:

Messaggio originale di Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Eh...it's alright. But why would CC run off to a place he hates? And also Michael is the one having the FNaF 4 nightmares, not CC.

My theory is he didn't hate it until that night. He would stumble upon Charlie's dead body or something like that and thus spark the emotions.

I also agree with him not being the main player. I meant more in the parts of the minigames - I'll edit that now.

But the whole thing about FNaF 4 is that his brother has bullied CC so much and for so long while also wearing one of the Freddy's Character's heads that he hates going to that place. And plus, no offence, there's no real evidence that he saw a dead body.

[Kaleidio]

Messaggio originale di Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Messaggio originale di Chivelle the Scrawn:

My theory is he didn't hate it until that night. He would stumble upon Charlie's dead body or something like that and thus spark the emotions.

I also agree with him not being the main player. I meant more in the parts of the minigames - I'll edit that now.

But the whole thing about FNaF 4 is that his brother has bullied CC so much and for so long while also wearing one of the Freddy's Character's heads that he hates going to that place. And plus, no offence, there's no real evidence that he saw a dead body.

True.

I also just noticed a major flaw; Michael is an adult at this point.

[WhiteNinji]

Messaggio originale di Chivelle the Scrawn:

Messaggio originale di Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

But the whole thing about FNaF 4 is that his brother has bullied CC so much and for so long while also wearing one of the Freddy's Character's heads that he hates going to that place. And plus, no offence, there's no real evidence that he saw a dead body.

True.

I also just noticed a major flaw; Michael is an adult at this point.

I though he was an older teen in Midnight Motorist.

[Kaleidio]

Messaggio originale di TheShowWillBeginMomentarily:

Messaggio originale di Chivelle the Scrawn:

True.

I also just noticed a major flaw; Michael is an adult at this point.

I though he was an older teen in Midnight Motorist.

In that case this may still be possible...