What if we play as Michael Afton in FNAF 4?

[AJ]

Okay, so I'm just gonna come out and say it now. I do not think that Michael Afton is the CC or Cassidy. (Also why do people think the CC is Cassidy? Cassidy is from the missing children's incident!) In my opinion, I think we play as Michael Afton in all games (Excluding Fnaf 2 night's 1-6 and FNAF 4'S cutscenes)

I think that after Fredbear chomped CC (The Chomp Of 83) Michael had nightmares of the animatronics (Because how can a child who had his head crushed survive five nights in the hospital? Unless he dies later that day or the day after) It also explains who is writing in faded ink, the CC. Michael has nightmares about Nightmare Fredbear so he draws it. It also makes his quest to set the souls free a lot more reasonable (We get to see why he did it) also when it says do you remember your name? Simple, Mike has had many different names that we know of; Mike Schmidt, Fritz Smith and there could be more that we don't know of!) I think this is more reasonable than the CC being a robot and all that. But I do think this is what Scott planned. If you have any questions, then feel free to post them :)

[Kaleidio]

But then why would animatronics want to kill him if he helped free them?

[WeltaChara]

I never liked this theory, but that's because it makes for a bad plot. In terms of what makes sense with what we know, unfortunately, it's right.

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Agreed. Michael is the main gameplay protagonist in all the FNaF games, aside from UCN and Jeremy in FNaF 2 imo. CC is most likely Shadow Freddy, while Cassidy (most likely Pigtail Girl in FNaF 4) is Golden Freddy.

[AJ]

Originally posted by LordScrawChristoGradius:

But then why would animatronics want to kill him if he helped free them?

well don't forget that he looks like William, so they probably wouldn't stop to ask him if he was William. Escpeaciily with FNAF 1 and 2. FNAF 5 they didn't kill him (Tbh we don't know what happened after the jumpscares) because they kinda needed him to escape

[Kaleidio]

Originally posted by LordScrawChristoGradius:

But then why would animatronics want to kill him if he helped free them?

oh wait. My mistake. I thought this was a UCN theory

[AJ]

Originally posted by ShadowLink64:

I never liked this theory, but that's because it makes for a bad plot. In terms of what makes sense with what we know, unfortunately, it's right.

which one? My one or the CC is Michael one?

[AJ]

Originally posted by LordScrawChristoGradius:

Originally posted by LordScrawChristoGradius:

But then why would animatronics want to kill him if he helped free them?

oh wait. My mistake. I thought this was a UCN theory

no this is about CC not being Micahel. I Michael is the protagonist in Fnaf UCN

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

Originally posted by LordScrawChristoGradius:

oh wait. My mistake. I thought this was a UCN theory

no this is about CC not being Micahel. I Michael is the protagonist in Fnaf UCN

I still say William is the player character of UCN.

[AJ]

Originally posted by Superintendant Sp4rt4n1295:

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

no this is about CC not being Micahel. I Michael is the protagonist in Fnaf UCN

I still say William is the player character of UCN.

sorry yeah, William is 100% the person in UCN

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

Originally posted by Superintendant Sp4rt4n1295:

I still say William is the player character of UCN.

sorry yeah, William is 100% the person in UCN

This is the thread for people getting mixed up with their theories, isn’t it?

[AJ]

Originally posted by Superintendant Sp4rt4n1295:

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

sorry yeah, William is 100% the person in UCN

This is the thread for people getting mixed up with their theories, isn’t it?

idk I didn't mean to miss out don't

[Kaleidio]

Originally posted by Superintendant Sp4rt4n1295:

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

sorry yeah, William is 100% the person in UCN

This is the thread for people getting mixed up with their theories, isn’t it?

No, just me

sorry! :(

[WeltaChara]

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

Originally posted by ShadowLink64:

I never liked this theory, but that's because it makes for a bad plot. In terms of what makes sense with what we know, unfortunately, it's right.

which one? My one or the CC is Michael one?

After reading the theory, I made a mistake. I thought it meant the actual gameplay. As for Michael being CC, absolutely not.

[AJ]

Originally posted by ShadowLink64:

Originally posted by The AJ Gamer:

which one? My one or the CC is Michael one?

After reading the theory, I made a mistake. I thought it meant the actual gameplay. As for Michael being CC, absolutely not.

yeah Michael is not CC at all

[SWATGUNNER]

well the main gameplay of fnaf 4 occurs during fnaf 1