UCN Ultimate Custom Night Theory

[AV_The_Warrior_1207]

SO… The Ultimate Custom Night came out, there’s a lot of lore, first and foremost after every death has voices depending on the character that kills you, and I found out that some of them say a line that goes something like this, “The one You Shouldn’t have Killed”(More on that later), I think that we are playing as William Afton (A.K.A The killer that killed, Stuffed, and Trapped all of the kids spirits in the Animatronics, The one who Killed Michael Afton his son, And his Daughter Elisabeth Afton who went on to become Baby and scrap Baby, By the Way both incidents were an accident (not defending him in any way), The other half who owned the business (Money, and ETC.)) so those are the three that I think could possibly be your character.

Now we can get back to that saying, these are the animatronics that said that; Jack-o Chica said, “Greeting’s from The Fire, and From the One’s you should not have Killed”, The next one is, Mangle which says; “She’s Here, and Always Watching, The One you Shouldn’t have Killed”, The next one to say it is Nightmare Freddy which says; I Am Remade, but not by You, By the One you should not have killed”, the Next one is old Chica and she says “I Have Seen Him, The one You Shouldn’t have Killed!”, So every character that has a line close to this is; Jack-o Chica, Mangle, Nightmare Freddy.

My first time hearing this I thought that maybe they were talking about the puppet because of what Nightmare Mangle said “She’s Here, and Always watching, The One You Shouldn’t Have Killed” my first indication is that it says “She’s Here” and the puppets soul is a girl (Charlotte), my second indication that this is the puppet; is that it says “Always Watching” and in the Puppets voice Dialogue after killing you she says “The others are Under My Protection” which indicates that she is watching over them and protecting them from any harm over the purple guy. The other evidence I have that this is the Puppet, and that is in Nightmare Freddy’s Voice dialogue, and it goes something like this “I am Remade, but not By You, By the One You Should Not Have Killed”, The “Remade” quote is a big Hint because The Puppet is the one that “Gives Gifts, Gives Life” and the fact that Nightmare Freddy is saying that “He is Remade” is saying that he Is reborn and the “But Not By You, By The One You Should not Have Killed” is saying that He was given a new life but not by Afton, By the puppet, The Girl he should not have killed, The Reason this all started.

I have another solution that makes a little less sense than the puppet one, what if the person their talking about in the voices… is Golden Freddy, think about it, the spirit in Golden Freddy is a girl Cassidy, she’s only briefly mentioned in the newest Novel The Fourth Closet, There’s not a whole lot of evidence other than Jack-o Chica, and Mangle’s voice Dialogue, There’s more logic reasons than evidence, Golden Freddy was one of the first to die, And if not The First to get killed, so it would make sense, she wants revenge for what William did to Her and her Friends, This all would start with her being the first, She is trying to set them free.

My Other theory is that the person their talking about is Michael Afton, Williams son. There’s not a whole lot of evidence but here’s what I’ve got; Old Chica in her voice dialogue says, “I Have Seen Him, The One You Shouldn’t Have Killed!” The “Him” Part is obviously pointing to the fact that he is a Boy, and yes I know that you think he hasn’t died yet but he did, Michael is the Crying Child from FNaF 4 (I’m not going to get into it just look at Game Theory’s newest Theory), so I think that Old Chica saw him, Remember she is the original Chica just Mangled, In another voice dialogue she said “I was The First, I Have Seen Everything” she had to have seen him if she was the first, so since she is the first she saw both lives of Michael, His Childhood which is where the first death came, and his Robotic Remnant life The life in which he tried to undo all of his fathers wrong doings, she has seen both lives. Since he is going location to location to undo everything his father did.

Now for the Final one, I think that there is a big possibility that the “One” Their talking about is Two People; The Puppet (Charlotte), and Michael Afton. I know this sounds crazy but hear me out, In Jack-o Chica’s Voice Dialogue she says “Greeting’s from The Fire, and From the One’s you should not have Killed” which is saying she’s talking about 2 or more people, the Jack-o Chica voice Dialogue says “Greetings from the Fire" part is referring to the fact that they all died by a fire that Henry made to set the Souls Free, The puppet was in Lefty which burned, and Michael was the security guard that burned also. Think about it both want to undo William Afton’s Acton’s, and wrong doings. Mangle’s Voice Dialogue says, “She’s Here, and Always Watching, The One You Shouldn’t Have Killed” which is referring to the puppet, look up at my Puppet Theory, and Old Chica’s Dialogue says, “I Have Seen Him, the one You Shouldn’t Have Killed!” Which is as you guessed referring to Michael Afton, in both dialogues there’s a “Him” and a “She” a Michael and Puppet. It all starts with these two, the puppet gives all of the animatronics life, Via Give Gifts, Give Life, The Puppet gave them Life to Stop William in his wrong actions, Michael went to every restaurant to free the souls of the animatronics that Afton created when they didn’t fulfill the purpose they were meant to do when the Puppet Give Gifts, Give Life. Finally, in the end both the Puppet and Michael did what they had to do the puppet got him to be Spring Trapped by Afton freeing the spirits on accident because The Puppet gave them life, Michael managed to free all of the souls and tried to kill his father at Fazbear Frights, but he didn’t manage to do that, He also managed to help Henry lure all of circus Baby’s animatronics and others and finally for the last time kill them. I think that when all of the Voice Dialogues say “The One You shouldn’t Have Killed” they’re saying that it was a mistake, That he’s the reason that he is in his Hell, the reason he’s going to die over and over and over again for the rest of his life, He is the Old Man Consequences.

This is my first FNaF Theory and Hopefully not the last I really want your feedback on my theory, which one do you think is right, or do you have your own please let me know, Thank you very much.

[BeetleDude]

For da love of God, paragraphs, not a single thing.

[Chrispy]

I won't read a huge wall of text without paragraphs, it's so unorganized that it's going to break my eyes.