FNaF - THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING (GAME THEORY)

[Jesse]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bXCbVGb04A

[JustThatOneGuy13]

Very interesting.

[GhostMami]

*aggressively slams head on desk*

[Jesse]

I am dissapointed he didnt mention Cassidy at all but did mention UCN trailer which is newer than Cassidy

[Glorious M e l o n]

Why

[Jesse]

Copy/Pasted this over from Freddit

"Don't get me wrong here, I enjoyed the new theory and think that it had some good evidence and points, but there are a few things that I feel are very easily debunked

Matpat decides that Michael is not biologically related to William, and was instead kidnapped. I find this very hard to believe when Michael looks and sounds so similar to his father that the animations mistake Michael for his father. They also have the same VA, furthering the point that they are most likely biologically related

Matpat also concludes that Michael is BV and was brought back as a robot by William. If Mike truly was brought back as a robot, how were his organs scooped out in Sister Location?

While this is smaller, I still wanted to bring this up. Near the beginning Mat claims that Midnight Motorist takes place right after Security Puppet, but later (Though this was in a quick unscripted segment, so I understand how he could make a mistake) he claims that the reason he wasn't let into JRs. because this is in the FNaF 2 location during the lock-down that happened during the MCI, even though the MCI happens way after Security Puppet

Again, don't get me wrong, I think it was a good video with some good parts, just these few things in particular don't make that much sense to me."

[BeetleDude]

I am not the biggest fan of MatPat... but man that was actually pretty good and interesting... ;)

[JMaster]

That JRs thing is so silly. Really, he's saying Midnight Motorist takes place after William kills Charlie, but he then says JRs is the FNAF 2 location, which is impossible. Unless I'm misunderstanding him, but whatever.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by JMaster:

That JRs thing is so silly. Really, he's saying Midnight Motorist takes place after William kills Charlie, but he then says JRs is the FNAF 2 location, which is impossible. Unless I'm misunderstanding him, but whatever.

To be fair, he talked about JR.s = FNAF 2 during a quick unscripted segment, but it's still a big hole in the theory and should have been caught during editing

[JMaster]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by JMaster:

That JRs thing is so silly. Really, he's saying Midnight Motorist takes place after William kills Charlie, but he then says JRs is the FNAF 2 location, which is impossible. Unless I'm misunderstanding him, but whatever.

To be fair, he talked about JR.s = FNAF 2 during a quick unscripted segment, but it's still a big hole in the theory and should have been caught during editing

Honestly, I don't like any of this theory, but that part especially stood out to me. I can understand it was unscripted, but he and the editors decided to include it anyway.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by JMaster:

Originally posted by Smear:

To be fair, he talked about JR.s = FNAF 2 during a quick unscripted segment, but it's still a big hole in the theory and should have been caught during editing

Honestly, I don't like any of this theory, but that part especially stood out to me. I can understand it was unscripted, but he and the editors decided to include it anyway.

Yup part 1 was so much better. Really dissapointed in part 2 even if I enjoyed it

[Glorious M e l o n]

I don't understand why he still says that Nightmare is representation of death. Like does he not know what he's called in the game fjles or does he think Shadow Freddy also represents death? And why does he treat his older theory as 100% fact when it was never confirmed? Matpat, you're hurting my brain rn.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

I don't understand why he still says that Nightmare is representation of death. Like does he not know what he's called in the game fjles or does he think Shadow Freddy also represents death? And why does he treat his older theory as 100% fact when it was never confirmed? Matpat, you're hurting my brain rn.

Nightmare isn’t called shadow Freddy
The nightmare NIGHT is called shadow freddy

[Glorious M e l o n]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

I don't understand why he still says that Nightmare is representation of death. Like does he not know what he's called in the game fjles or does he think Shadow Freddy also represents death? And why does he treat his older theory as 100% fact when it was never confirmed? Matpat, you're hurting my brain rn.

Nightmare isn’t called shadow Freddy
The nightmare NIGHT is called shadow freddy

And? That's still obviously referring to who Nightmare is.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Originally posted by Smear:

Nightmare isn’t called shadow Freddy
The nightmare NIGHT is called shadow freddy

And? That's still obviously referring to who Nightmare is.

True I was just saying Nightmare wasn’t called shadow Freddy in the files

[Glorious M e l o n]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

And? That's still obviously referring to who Nightmare is.

True I was just saying Nightmare wasn’t called shadow Freddy in the files

He basically is though..