Diona

[douglas0828]

Well obviously I chose wrong and didn't hit a save file before the darn quest but it was kinda a coin flip situation for me since I was kinda talking to the exact same ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ person with no clear personal difference between the two people. I still have yet to finish the game but I am slightly annoyed that im playing a game where my choices don't matter other than story flavor.

[Keldrath]

I picked the wrong one too but I'm still not quite sure what the actual giveaway is. The wrong one just seemed to say exactly all the things I would have expected the right one to say.

[Coldfire]

Well you did go there because Diona was going to kill her sister. And when you arrive, one is strangling the other.

[MASTAN]

Is it in a quest "By the Fates"? The giveaway then is "by the Fates".

[CursedPanther]

At first I thought it was a careless mistake made by the writers when speaking to the fake twin, but at the precise moment I suddenly realized the thing was planned all along.

Right choice on first try.

[Gray Matter Guerrilla]

Does the choice have long-lasting effects (main story or side quests)?

I chose wrong (left). I saw one twin strangling another, but I figured maybe the real Diona was getting her butt kicked after a failed assassination attempt.....but nope. Dialogue seemed to point to the left twin as well (imo). Oh well.

I should stop over-thinking video games.....lol

[Keldrath]

nah it doesn't matter.

[Darth Wadewilson]

Truth is we should be knowing that diona is bad. Coz we get that feeling of being played when we complete her quests. So we should be knowing that everything is apparently the opposite of what it seems.

[😎Astran😾]

What happens in case of wrong choice? I got it righ in both play-throughs.

[Gray Matter Guerrilla]

Originally posted by Astran:

What happens in case of wrong choice? I got it righ in both play-throughs.

You kill the innocent twin (obviously) and realize it when the evil twin - Diona - basically congratulates you for doing so. A fight between Diona + 2 Cult guards ensues. Not a very difficult fight (as long as you're on equal XP rank). You kill Diona and check off another dead Cultist.

And that's pretty much it. The island doesn't turn against you or anything like that.

[Goilveig]

Originally posted by MASTAN:

Is it in a quest "By the Fates"? The giveaway then is "by the Fates".

Yup, Diona has a catchphrase which was hinted at in several places, including the note that you found from a body earlier in the quest chain.

[Zloth]

I think you also have the choice of telling Diona what was in that message earlier on. If you don't tell her, I expect the option to ask the priestess what was in the letter would reveal Diona. So an earlier choice made the later choice harder!

[Perseus son of Zeus]

I would like to kill them both if it do not get any affect ..hehe. ><

[JL::Jose-Juan Kenobi]

Originally posted by Zloth:

I think you also have the choice of telling Diona what was in that message earlier on. If you don't tell her, I expect the option to ask the priestess what was in the letter would reveal Diona. So an earlier choice made the later choice harder!

I'm sorry I'm reviving an old thread, but I just finished this quest last night, and this part really bugged me haha.

Can anyone answer, "how on earth did the real Diona knew what was in the letter?"

While confronting them, I had the option to ask what was in the letter, and she responded right away.
so how the heck did she knew!?!?!

I don't recall telling her when I reported back about the side quest, it wouldn't make sense me telling her what was in the letter, then asking when confronting them

If anyone know, please tell me :D

Anyways, that was a fun set of side quests. Best part, is I landed on that island while doing another quest, some sculptor sends you to find some statues to find some clues, love that part of this game... feels like... an Odyssey...