Please return stamina potions as it was!

[lich87]

Please return minors stamina potion to Recover up to two of your discarded cards and Major to three. That neft is very stupid and almost ruin whole game.

[Sloth]

This nerf is old, and justified...
But if you want this modification, it is conceivable and there's a mod in the Steam Workshop for that.

[lich87]

I dont know how old that was, but it works in old good way in board game version. Now I tried use these, and at least minor stamina potion is absolute useless.

My main in board game is tree spear, and minor and major stamina potions is everything for that character. Without theses is 100% broken.

[Loqaun]

It was nerfed in board game version in errata 1,5 year ago. I played a lot with 3 spear character and is ridiculously OP even with this nerf.

[Valmar]

No its not nerfed in the boardgame.
Other than that, yeah, it's OP.

More about this matter here:
https://steamcommunity.com/app/780290/discussions/0/2289464808480604474/

[RbdPanda]

Originally posted by Valmar:

No its not nerfed in the boardgame.
Other than that, yeah, it's OP.

More about this matter here:
https://steamcommunity.com/app/780290/discussions/0/2289464808480604474/

It is nerfed in the board game, if you go by the official FAQ and errata listed online. There are numerous changes to the game there, as well as rule clarifications.

[Valmar]

Originally posted by RbdPanda:

Originally posted by Valmar:

No its not nerfed in the boardgame.
Other than that, yeah, it's OP.

More about this matter here:
https://steamcommunity.com/app/780290/discussions/0/2289464808480604474/

It is nerfed in the board game, if you go by the official FAQ and errata listed online. There are numerous changes to the game there, as well as rule clarifications.

Again, no it IS NOT.
From the FAQ:

Item 013
Minor Stamina Potion - A future expansion will change this item so that you only recover one discarded card. Players may optionally play with the card that way in the base game if they feel they wish to nerf it. Note that the nerf has been included in some non-english versions of the core game.

Also, in the new kickstarter, printing 6 -second edition, it is confirmed by the developer of the boardgame, Isaac, that the stamina potion will remain the same.


They will be nerfed in Frosthaven (a new game), but in Gloomhaven, even in the new printing (in official English), will remain like the old one.


Of course, as I have said, you can play houserule as you want (I personaly like the videogame version, because stamina are OP and unbalanced in the bordgame), but what I am trying to say is that in the official FAQ and official game it is STILL not nerfed, and won't be even in the next printing coming this year.


So yeah, as FAQ says, you can OPTIONALLY change it, but the official printing and official rules still work in a different way than this boardgame, which is what I was trying to say.

[Calmon]

The old version just means: You use it on every character. This is why it got changed because now its way more of a decision than before and still useable.

[hannibal_pjv]

Yes this game has the right version of stamina potion!
It was errated to heal only one card and that is a good thing. Old version was too good. Every character has to have it!