Total War: THREE KINGDOMS
Тема закрыта
I hope this is based on the real history.
Much of history today available from China has been altered by the CCP and alike. And they have been referencing "ancient China" everywhere to snatch territories and spread propaganda. I can give you many links to get you aware you on real history.
Here is two of many unbiased, unaltered history about the Chinese-
https://youtu.be/k9KMcCeow_I

https://youtu.be/VITZ-Oyy9Os

Anyways I wanted to know, is this game based on ACTUAL history or some made up history or worse, altered history? I would buy it if there is a factual representation of their history.



Thanks.
Отредактировано b9thirty99; 27 янв. 2020 г. в 4:34
Автор сообщения: ElPrezCBF:
From what I understand, TK is based on a novel inspired by historical events. Which means it's a mix of history and fiction to some extent. All these don't affect the game imho although TW tries to be historically authentic where possible. TW is about you deciding whether to follow history or make your own.
< >
Сообщения 115 из 125
.... Basic Reading the Store Page and their Youtube Trailer literally already explain....
It's literally based on Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Hence Total War THREE KINGDOMS
Отредактировано PFC Demigo [29th ID]; 22 янв. 2020 г. в 13:59
Автор сообщения: ♋️LunarCainEX🐶
.... Basic Reading the Store Page and their Youtube Trailer literally already explain....
It's literally based on Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Hence Total War THREE KINGDOMS
It is based on Romance and Records. Hence Romance and Records mode.

The game is based mostly on Romance of the Three Kingdoms, which is itself based on real history+a whole lot of myth and legend, and a fair bit of artistic flair to flesh out the narrative of the novel. There are two modes, Romance, which is based on the novel, and Records, which is honestly not historical, but less fictitious than Records (though it still has a fair deal of fiction, like Zheng Jiang).

Also wow. That video. In the first ~5 minutes he has gotten multiple things wrong. What he called "east Turkestan" has been connected to the Chinese (and controlled by them of and on) since the at LEAST the early Han. He is talking about antiquity, and then goes back to the Neolithic. The hell does that have to do with Classical China? Absolutely nothing. He calls the Shang the "first historical dynasty". We know the Shang as a culture existed, but the dynasty is not itself historical. That is still pre-history. This guy doesn't know wtf he is talking about. He talks about the Qin having "nothing in the far west of China". Yes they did; they had hegemony. This guy acts like hegemony isn't a thing, soft power isn't a thing. He calls the Han "uninterrupted". Yeah, Wang Mang was a pretty big interruption, he founded a dynasty that forced the Han to relocate and separated the Eastern from Western Han. Don't listen to this dude.
Отредактировано Haddon; 22 янв. 2020 г. в 14:18
As much as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is real history.

One can easily make the argument that nothing of what is considered "History" is accurate because people who wrote ♥♥♥♥ down had biases. Take the war with Persia and Greece for example. Greek historians depict it as an apocalyptic battle between good and evil. It's barely a footnote in Persian records that no one really cared about.
Отредактировано Hex; 22 янв. 2020 г. в 14:31
He is obviously just a troll with an axe to grind.
Автор сообщения: lemurs2
He is obviously just a troll with an axe to grind.

Everyone should have an exe to grind against the CCP because they are systematically destroying China, it's culture and heritage.
RCMidas (Заблокирован) 22 янв. 2020 г. в 15:02 
Автор сообщения: Hex
Everyone should have an exe to grind against the CCP because they are systematically destroying China, it's culture and heritage.
They can try. They seem to forget that the rest of the world has a record of everything that happened before they came into power. A dictatorship can only erase history within its own borders. Everyone else is basically unaffected.
Says a bunch of gamers who don't speak the Chinese language while thinking themselves as those who possess of omniscience in Chinese history and culture. Get a life, guys! Stop this circle-jerking!
Отредактировано Mr. Reese and Doc. Fitch; 22 янв. 2020 г. в 15:07
Автор сообщения: Mr. Reese and Doc. Fitch
Says a bunch of gamers who don't speak the Chinese language while thinking themselves as those who possess of omniscience in Chinese history and culture. Get a life, guys! Stop this circle-jerking!
Or, you know...people who are interested in Chinese history, so they have learned it...

I love the "you don't speak ___ language, how can you know anything about them?!". So, almost nobody can know anything about the Sumerians, because the language is almost completely extinct? Nobody can know anything about the Harrapans, because the language is completely dead? The 20 years of Roman history I have learned I can only slightly know, because I only know a bit of Latin? That is stupid.
Автор сообщения: Mr. Reese and Doc. Fitch
Says a bunch of gamers who don't speak the Chinese language while thinking themselves as those who possess of omniscience in Chinese history and culture. Get a life, guys! Stop this circle-jerking!
Oh please, you don't know a damn thing about any of us. Get off your high horse.
And another troll wanders in. The CCP is not communist they are capitalist and if I was teaching students today I would say the CCP reminds me a great deal of the Tang dynasty.
Автор сообщения: lemurs2
The CCP is not communist they are capitalist
Wrong. It's not as simple as "they are" or "they are not" capitalist. Anyway, I'm going to vacate this thread before the war kicks off.
No, I am not wrong. Don't come in and say 'wrong' when you have no idea what you are talking about.
Автор сообщения: lemurs2
No, I am not wrong. Don't come in and say 'wrong' when you have no idea what you are talking about.
lmao I had to come back for this. I'll be leaving for real after this comment.

You did almost the same exact thing in the post I quoted. You stated what you believe to be a fact and you provided absolutely no source.

All I have to do is google "Is China Capitalist?" to prove your wrong. Literally every single article, study, etc. says essentially what I said, just in more words.

Sorry. Bye bye.
Отредактировано Crowkeeper; 22 янв. 2020 г. в 16:32
Well it's 2000 years ago. The ancient history is not very reliable. They only got the information from old archives.
And it's Romance, It means they alter the history but keep the fundamental.
Dude, did you just say google it and google will provide truth? :steamhappy:
I would not allow my students to use wikipedia either.
< >
Сообщения 115 из 125
Показывать на странице: 1530 50

Дата создания: 22 янв. 2020 г. в 13:55
Сообщений: 125