Total War: THREE KINGDOMS

Total War: THREE KINGDOMS

View Stats:
Atomsk May 22, 2019 @ 4:50pm
Liu Bei = High Elves?
Although not my favourite race, I enjoyed the play style of the High Elves the most.

I think Liu Bei has 2 faction unique archer units, are they similar to Shadow Walkers and Sisters of Averlorn?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
Donttouchmyhohos May 22, 2019 @ 4:52pm 
As in the shoot arrows? Yes.
Atomsk May 22, 2019 @ 4:57pm 
Originally posted by donttouchmyhohos:
As in the shoot arrows? Yes.

Well... Shadow Walkers have hidden, vanguard, and shoots while moving. The sistahs shoot like a plasma cannon.

Anything special about the Yi Archers/Marksmen or do they just have higher stats for an archer unit?
TheSaboteur May 22, 2019 @ 4:58pm 
Zhuge Liang was known for "inventing" the repeating crossbows and generally improving ranged weapons for siege warfare. So it makes sense that Shu has access to advanced ranged units. Is it realistic? No, but I assume Liu Bei's BENEVOLENCE(tm) makes the arrows go faster.
RubyCante May 22, 2019 @ 5:00pm 
from the early gameplay,the unique archer of liu bei is not worth it as they are only better archer and do not get the bonus from liu bei effect of -50%/-100% upkeep as they are not militia unit

they are archer that is good at melee(?),dunno why you want that
need to wait for release patch to see if CA change anything
Nickk May 22, 2019 @ 5:06pm 
All unique units are more of a late game units since they cause so much and their upkeep are also high. Cao Cao's Tiger and Leopard Calvalry costs 3300 gold to recruit and 200 upkeep at the beginning of the game.

Cant wait to recruit all 5 Tiger Generals, Xu Shu, Zhuge Liang and Peng Tong in my Liu Bei campaign.


Actually,they are Skaven Faction! yes yes! Gatling machine guns!
And also, In Chinese, Liu Bei's Kingdom "Shu" has the same pronunciation as rats.
reevestone May 22, 2019 @ 5:24pm 
Not exactly. The big thing that sets Liu Bei's unique archers apart is that they're considerably better in melee than regular archers. Which is... unusual, but does in theory serve a purpose, it means they'll be more useful when they run out of ammo and not get so trivially annihilated by cavalry charging into them.

If you're looking for a faction capable of ranged domination, I feel that Kong Rong or Gongsun Zan would be better choices. As a Strategist Kong Rong already specializes in using archers and giving them a lot more ammo, and what sets his unique crossbowmen apart is that they have far more ammo natively than regular crossbows. These obviously stack on each other, and given that the general ranged unit balance in 3K is that they're very high-damage but have low ammo capacity, you have a faction that's quite well-suited to annihilating their enemies from range.

I say Gongsun Zan because he has by far the best horse archers in the game, that do some really high damage and outrange almost everything else. Since they are horse archers that can fire while moving and outrange most archers, his unique horse archers are incredibly good at harassing the enemy with relatively little that can directly counter them when they're well-micro'd, and they're still pretty decent as melee cav once they run out of arrows.
Atomsk May 22, 2019 @ 5:51pm 
Originally posted by reevestone:
Not exactly. The big thing that sets Liu Bei's unique archers apart is that they're considerably better in melee than regular archers. Which is... unusual, but does in theory serve a purpose, it means they'll be more useful when they run out of ammo and not get so trivially annihilated by cavalry charging into them.

If you're looking for a faction capable of ranged domination, I feel that Kong Rong or Gongsun Zan would be better choices. As a Strategist Kong Rong already specializes in using archers and giving them a lot more ammo, and what sets his unique crossbowmen apart is that they have far more ammo natively than regular crossbows. These obviously stack on each other, and given that the general ranged unit balance in 3K is that they're very high-damage but have low ammo capacity, you have a faction that's quite well-suited to annihilating their enemies from range.

I say Gongsun Zan because he has by far the best horse archers in the game, that do some really high damage and outrange almost everything else. Since they are horse archers that can fire while moving and outrange most archers, his unique horse archers are incredibly good at harassing the enemy with relatively little that can directly counter them when they're well-micro'd, and they're still pretty decent as melee cav once they run out of arrows.

Thanks, sound pretty broken to have mounted archers that outrange regular archers. Have to say Gongsun's artwork looks pretty cool as well.

Right now I'm torn between Liu Bei, Zheng Jiang, Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan for a Legendary first playthrough.
reevestone May 22, 2019 @ 5:56pm 
Originally posted by Atomsk:
Thanks, sound pretty broken to have mounted archers that outrange regular archers. Have to say Gongsun's artwork looks pretty cool as well.

Right now I'm torn between Liu Bei, Zheng Jiang, Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan for a Legendary first playthrough.

We'll know more when the game actually comes out and we can pull all the stats apart, but it from what I observed with people playing Gongsun Zan, his unique horse archers are at least intended to be balanced by being the same range as crossbows (so they at least can trade fire with them, crossbows have a greater range than archers, repeating crossbows have a smaller range than archers), not being as fast as light raider cav so those can catch up to them, and being pretty damn expensive. Though that last one's hardly unique to Gongsun Zan, pretty much all the faction unique units are pretty damn expensive and seem mostly intended for the mid-late game.
Atomsk May 22, 2019 @ 6:21pm 
After watching some youtube vids, I think Cao Cao just became my favourite faction leader.

He's got Grail Knights for unique units.
Originally posted by Atomsk:
Although not my favourite race, I enjoyed the play style of the High Elves the most.

I think Liu Bei has 2 faction unique archer units, are they similar to Shadow Walkers and Sisters of Averlorn?
Dunno about comparisons yet. Will be making them tomorrow though lol
mustachewarfare May 22, 2019 @ 8:35pm 
obviously. Liu bei was known for his long ears
The Former May 22, 2019 @ 8:45pm 
Originally posted by Atomsk:
Originally posted by donttouchmyhohos:
As in the shoot arrows? Yes.

Well... Shadow Walkers have hidden, vanguard, and shoots while moving. The sistahs shoot like a plasma cannon.

Anything special about the Yi Archers/Marksmen or do they just have higher stats for an archer unit?

I've heard they're actually quite good in melee, unlike most ranged units. But at the same time, I've heard the increase they offer as a ranged unit isn't substantial enough to use them over militia, because with Liu Bei's militia upkeep reduction, you can field 6 militia units for the cost of 1 Yi Archer unit or something.
The Former May 22, 2019 @ 8:46pm 
Originally posted by 可以赢但没必要:
Actually,they are Skaven Faction! yes yes! Gatling machine guns!
And also, In Chinese, Liu Bei's Kingdom "Shu" has the same pronunciation as rats.

I always thought Yuan Shu was the rat. But the pronunciation is different for him, isn't it?
Atomsk May 22, 2019 @ 8:51pm 
Originally posted by Sheriff of Nothingham:
Originally posted by Atomsk:

Well... Shadow Walkers have hidden, vanguard, and shoots while moving. The sistahs shoot like a plasma cannon.

Anything special about the Yi Archers/Marksmen or do they just have higher stats for an archer unit?

I've heard they're actually quite good in melee, unlike most ranged units. But at the same time, I've heard the increase they offer as a ranged unit isn't substantial enough to use them over militia, because with Liu Bei's militia upkeep reduction, you can field 6 militia units for the cost of 1 Yi Archer unit or something.

Yeah I decided to go with Cao Cao for 1st playthrough, will try Liu Bei later on.

I am all #FOR ZE LADIEEE now and the Cao Cao specific cav units.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: May 22, 2019 @ 4:50pm
Posts: 19