Rank Every FNAF game

[Jesse]

7. Sister Location
The main thing I really didnt like about Sister Location was the gameplay. The presentation, voice acting, and graphics were all great, but I missed the office gameplay and the gameplay elements you do have are boring and lack depth. The two things that makes me consider this game good and not mediocre are the presention as mentioned above, and the custom night gameplay, which is really good.

6. FNAF World
To be honest I really didnt like it at first, the overworld was ugly, and there were other issues. Update 1 made it better, but still not great, but I LOVED update 2. I loved each character and minigame and is much better than the main campaign.

5. FNAF 2
I really do like the gameplay mechanics of 2. The mask is unique, the music box creates some tense situations, and the designs of the animatronics are amazing, the main flaw lies in how hard it will get, such as if Withered Bonnie is in the office, so you need to wear the mask, but the music box is about to run out, so you need to TAKE OFF the mask and go into the cameras, allowing Withered Bonnie to attack you, and if you dont the Puppet will attack you

4. FNAF 4
If you asked me why a didnt rank it higher, I legitimetally couldnt say. I can't name a single problem I have with this game, I just don't like it as much as some of the other games.

3. FNAF 6/PS
The night gameplay isn't really even that great, probably the worst night gameplay in the series. The main thing that I love about this game is easily the tycoon elements. Tycoons are one of my favorite genre, and I always wanted a tycoon FNAF game. While a bit shallow, it was still enough fun to make this game 3rd, and UCN could even make it rank up a spot if it is good enough

2. FNAF 3
While every FNAF game feels like it has a little luck in it, FNAF 3 is easily the least luck based in my opinion, which I enjoy. It really feels awesome luring Springtrap from one room to another, keeping him away. On top of that, Springtrap is easily the best character design in the series, which doesnt hurt. Its also the only game where I feel you HAVE to use the cameras, besides the arbitrary things like the Music Box or Foxy

1. FNAF 1
While it is the first and probably most simplistic, it is still my favorite. I adore each and every animatronic in this game, they all are memorable and unique. The gameplay is tough and tense, but almost always still feels managable and never gets too chaotic. I would also say it is personally the second scariest game in the series, only behind FNAF 4.

[BeetleDude]

7. FNaF World - Very fun and underrated game. But compared to the others, definitely the weakest.
6. FNaF 3 - To me, the most lacking in gameplay but the best at storytelling through the minigames and phone calls. Overall not bad.
5. FNaF: SL/FNaF 5 - Like Badger, kind of disappointing, but still pretty good. The main game is lacking but once you get to the Custom Night is where the real fun begins.
4. FNaF 4 - Pretty fun and has the creepiest animatronic designs. Not a fan of the earrape though.
3. FNaF 2 - Very fun, very addicting, and when we first played it, had an amazing twist at the very end that it was actually a prequel.
2. FFPS/FNaF 6 - Amazing tycoon sections, very fun-to-play salvage minigames, and while pretty annoying at times, the nights are very well executed. Once UCN comes out, this could get boosted to #1.
1. FNaF - The original game that started it all. Terrifying jumpscares, simple yet terrifying mechanics and gameplay, and when the story was very deep, yet still pretty simple.

[Sp4rt4n1295]

7. FNaF SL: Main story was a jumbled, linear, mess of minigames strung together by a decent plot. It added to the lore, but some of what was added stretched my suspension of disbelief (you really expect me to believe that a walking purple flesh suit can do what he did in the other FNaF games... yeah, I don’t buy it). Other than certain parts of the game that felt more like good ol’ FNaF (Private Room, Custom Night, and Breaker Room to a lesser extent), the game was rather disappointing.

6. FNaF 2: Expansions to the lore were nice, especially with the minigames (who saw those coming first time around, honestly), and the animatronic designs were nice. However, the gameplay is very tedious and unfair, with the music box mechanic being the biggest factor in why the game is so mindnumbingly frustrating (that and there’s ten freakin’ animatronics on top of that), and the jumpscares were so lame that coupled with the fact that you see them so often from dying so much, they wear on you really quickly.

5. FNaF 3: Once upon a time this was my favorite FNaF game, but over time, I came to appreciate the others more. The only things I can really say bad about this game is that the jumpscares aren’t that scary after a while (mostly due to the Phantoms jumpscaring you so often and not killing you), and that the lack of Custom Night was disappointing. Other than that, I really liked this one. The cameras are their most useful yet as they are the only thing keeping the one animatronic that can kill you (good ol’ Springtrap) at bay, and the atmosphere is great, much better than the annoying siren noise in FNaF 2.

4. FNaF World: Messy launch, and not the most polished RPG, but it was still fun regardless. I especially enjoyed it after Update 2 added those stellar minigames (<3 Freddy in Space). Music was great too (Freddy in Space music, and Animdude’s boss theme are some highlights).

3. FFPS: Tycoon Mode was good fun, but I feel it’s icing in the cake for the office mode. The lack of cameras and reliance on audio made the atmosphere really tense. The only downside imo is the lackluster jumpscare animations and lack of ambient music in the background like in every other FNaF game. Couple with the great ending to the franchise (whether some believe it to be or not (not naming names here)), and we have a great entry in the franchise and a great sendoff for Scott’s FNaF games.

2. FNaF 1: What can I say? It’s the first game. It’s where the lore was it’s most simple, and when the gameplay was fresh and new. I guess the only thing I can complain about is how random Foxy can be at times and... that’s about it. Great game that spawned a great indie horror phenomenon.

1. FNaF 4: Basically take FNaF 1, take away the cameras, replace the security office with a bedroom, and bump the scary visuals (animatronics included) and sound design up to 10. That’s FNaF 4 in a nutshell. The lack of Custom Night and confusing elements of the plot that leave people baffled to this day are the only things holding it back from being called a perfect game. By far the scariest game in the franchise (probably the only game to consistently scare me every time I play it), and is a nightmare to play (in a good way), pun intended.

[Sp00ky_Matt]

7. FNaF 2

Even though this game really kicked off the story and franchise, this is my least favorite to play due to the fact that after playing the game for a couple hours you will be a pro with the very predictable patterns

6. FNaF 4

Forcing the player to turn up volume is an ingenious mechanic in this series, but how about no. Also this game drove one man to the break of insanity *cough *cough.

5. FNaF 6

This game had the potential to be my favorite, but Scott tried to tend to the people who wanted the tycoon and the people that wanted fnaf 6 at the same time. In the end I think this detracted from the experience (this is going to trigger people)

4. FNaF World

I would like to ban wagon with everyone else and put this at the back of the list, but my save file says other wise.

3. FNaF SL

I really don't have much to say just that this is an amazing game with very unique gameplay for the series

2. FNaF

Though it is not technologically the best of the pack it's the magical experience of playing this one first that me and millions of others felt that puts this at 2

1. FNaF 3

Look I know this one is a love it or hate it for most people. It's just this was the one that broke the story wide open, 1v1ed the series main protagonist, brought the best animations, and easily had the best and hippest phone guy

[NickDroid]

7. FNaF 4
Hate the mechanics, soundtrack makes the breathing hard to hear, which gets confusing. Too much teeth.

6. FNaF 2
Wind up box, put on mask, spam CTRL, repeat. Mangle and withered are cool.

5. FNaF 3
Love the prominent use of cameras something that doesn’t happen in the other games. Literally just have to play audio in top right, and make sure you don’t look at the any of the phantoms. Phantom Puppet ruined the game for me, with its 15 second staring contest

4. FNaF SL
Main game is good, but frustrating at points. Secret room is fun and challenging, Custom Night is the best part. It was very difficult, and we got to see Lobit.

3. FNaF World
What introduced me to the series, and it’s is just a good time. The dialogue, battling, Flipside, Update 2 Minigames, and multiple endings, make it a game you can just play once to say you did, or get all endings and get the full expiration.

2. FNaF 1
Definitely one of the spookiest, the atmosphere is phenomenal, and the moaning and other weird sounds the animatronics make really add to the horror.
1. FFPS (FNaF 6)
The tycoon section is neat, and allowed us to see a lot of new faces. I loved that the player was the one who had to make the night continue by doing tasks, and it wasn’t just “survive until 6am.” Similar to World, I love the multiple endings and how unique each one was. With the addition of UCN, it’s gonna be a fun time

[PresPy]

• FNaF 2- Five Nights at Freddy's 2 seemed pretty bland to me. Not only does the shock value of the Withered animatronics go away pretty fast, but the Toy animatronics having a cute design makes me think that Scott was TRYING to make me not be scared.
  
  
• FNaF 3- Five Nights at Freddy's 3 isn't very good. Not only are the mechanics extremely difficult to learn, but Phone Dude's voice is annoying and so are the training tapes. And the Phantom animatronics can't even kill you!
  
  
• FNaF World- Five Nights at Freddy's World is mediocre, but it isn't bad so-to-speak. Yes, it isn't the best game in my opinion; it's honestly kind of boring, the boss battles are monotonous, the lore isn't great; at least it had some fun secrets and easter eggs, especially Update 2.
  
  
• FNaF 4- Five Nights at Freddy's 4 is terrible because those whom are deaf, have bad hearing, or don't use/own headphones can't play; the entire game is strictly sound-based. Personally, I only like the Halloween update because of the redesigned characters.
  
  
• FNaF SL- Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location is 3rd place because it was the first game to not use the annoying FNaF formula, and it actually tried something new. It was also technically free roam, and I liked the secret room on Night 5.
  
  
• FNaF 1- The first Five Nights at Freddy's is 2nd place because I find it to be terrifying compared to its sequels and prequels. Not only are the characters spooky, but the fact that it was a new idea at the time makes it good to me. Sure, the Chica porn is an issue, but I think that it's awesome besides that. It makes you terrified, and that's why it's my subjective favorite.
  
  And to those saying 'WELL IF YOU LIKED IT THEN WHY DON'T YOU PUT IT IN FIRST?!!?!', that's because I'm trying to be objective with only a few opinions.
  
  
• FFPS- Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator is probably the best game from an objective standpoint because not only does it allow you to do whatever you want for the first third of the night, but it also has multiple endings. Congratulations, FFPS, you came in first place.

[Kaleidio]

FNaF4, FNaF6, FNaFSL, FNaF3, FNaF1, FNaF2

(best to worst, sorry)

[Lord Egg]

Al ev them bed xddddddddddd please pay attention to me





anyways jokes aside worst to best
Fnaf sl Fnaf world Fnaf 2 Fnaf 1 Fnaf 3 FFPS

[Kaleidio]

Originally posted by The Earthdragonninja:

Al ev them bed xddddddddddd please pay attention to me





anyways jokes aside worst to best
Fnaf sl Fnaf world Fnaf 2 Fnaf 1 Fnaf 3 FFPS

WhAt aboUT FOur????

[chuckster]

Originally posted by me:

It was also technically free roam

free roam is the complete freedom of movement within a 3D space

sl has limited movement and limited camera angles

[Kaleidio]

Originally posted by Aubergine Man:

Originally posted by me:

It was also technically free roam

free roam is the complete freedom of movement within a 3D space

sl has limited movement and limited camera angles

upvote. Free Roam would mean you could choose your auditorium and the direction you travel them in normally, not being forced out of an auditorium and only be able to change directions when leaving on night 5.

[chuckster]

Originally posted by GradiusLover2000:

Originally posted by Aubergine Man:

free roam is the complete freedom of movement within a 3D space

sl has limited movement and limited camera angles

upvote. Free Roam would mean you could choose your auditorium and the direction you travel them in normally, not being forced out of an auditorium and only be able to change directions when leaving on night 5.

sl is more like an on-rail shooter type of thing

[Kaleidio]

Originally posted by Aubergine Man:

Originally posted by GradiusLover2000:

upvote. Free Roam would mean you could choose your auditorium and the direction you travel them in normally, not being forced out of an auditorium and only be able to change directions when leaving on night 5.

sl is more like an on-rail shooter type of thing

upvote2

[76561198828782529]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by badger9123:

In the logbook its confirmed that Michael is the one having the nightmares.

Oh cool. Guess it makes sense if you believe that he is also Mike Schmidt from 1, as in

FNAF 4:
Bonnie attacks from left
Chica attacks from right
Foxy hides in closet and you need to check on him to make it go away
Freddy hides under your bed

and in

FNAF 1:
Bonnie attacks from left
Chica attacks from right
Foxy hides in pirates cove and you need to check on him to make him go away
Freddy hides in dark places

That doesn't make sense in the timeline though. The person having nightmares is in a coma and eventually DIES. Mike is quite clearly alive and fit in FFPS as he manages a restaurant. I don't think a suicidal businessman is running it nor some possessed animatronics. Michael can't be the one having nightmares. The room itself was childish and Mike was fairly old at the time. Some parts must be deemed non-canon otherwise Scott has ruined the entire timeline.

[76561198828782529]

Originally posted by me:

• FNaF 4- Five Nights at Freddy's 4 is terrible because those whom are deaf, have bad hearing, or don't use/own headphones can't play; the entire game is strictly sound-based. Personally, I only like the Halloween update because of the redesigned characters.
  
  
• FFPS- Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator is probably the best game from an objective standpoint because not only does it allow you to do whatever you want for the first third of the night, but it also has multiple endings. Congratulations, FFPS, you came in first place.
  
  

  FFPS is also about sound, hypocrite. You need to hear them in the vents signalling they're gone.

[NickDroid]

Originally posted by ThoseOtherGamers:

Originally posted by Smear:

Oh cool. Guess it makes sense if you believe that he is also Mike Schmidt from 1, as in

FNAF 4:
Bonnie attacks from left
Chica attacks from right
Foxy hides in closet and you need to check on him to make it go away
Freddy hides under your bed

and in

FNAF 1:
Bonnie attacks from left
Chica attacks from right
Foxy hides in pirates cove and you need to check on him to make him go away
Freddy hides in dark places

That doesn't make sense in the timeline though. The person having nightmares is in a coma and eventually DIES. Mike is quite clearly alive and fit in FFPS as he manages a restaurant. I don't think a suicidal businessman is running it nor some possessed animatronics. Michael can't be the one having nightmares. The room itself was childish and Mike was fairly old at the time. Some parts must be deemed non-canon otherwise Scott has ruined the entire timeline.

You realize adults can dream abou being kids? Anything can happen in a dream...