I don't think they're all dead.

[Caped Crochetder]

I know they all got set on fire and everything the good ending, but I don't think it's quite over for 2 reasons:

1) Lefty's absence.
We see pictures of Baby, Freddy, and Springtrap roasting in an open fire, but we don't see Lefty. Considering Lefty is the Marionette stuck in a suit, this is a pretty hefty absence since the Marionette has been pretty damn important.

2) Springtrap is fireproof!
This isn't exactly the first time good ol' Willy Afton should've died. He was scooped out, springlocked multiple times in the books, rotted in a sealed up back room for 30 years without food and water, and already survived a fire in FNaF3. With all of that in mind, I highly doubt he's dead.

[Caped Crochetder]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von rashann:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

plus, the books are practically canon according to scott. their events did take place within the world of FNaF. just not as a part of the games. plus, if william isn't the purple guy we see in SL, then what the ♥♥♥♥ happened to michael? do you really not think he would just be left alone after even saying he was going to come find william? FNaFPS showed us everyone but michael, and i'm sure henry would be aware of michael's presence since the whole plan was to end the entire haunting issue once and for all. if he doesn't know who we're playing as, then it's most likely not michael and he's still out there, which confirms my suspicion that the story may not be over.

We play as Michael in SL and the cutscenes show his skin rot and turn purple after being scooped. He is physically purple but is not The Purple guy, that's William.

Its unlikely that Henry knows about Michael. He might know that William had a son names Michael but he has no reason to be keeping up with his life especially after William killed his daughter. Also Michael says that he has been living in shadows this whole time.

BTW the working theory is that we've been playing a Michael under different names throughout all the games (except 4th) and its all but confirmed we're Michael in this game because all the animatronics act as if they recognize our character and he's the only one who would want to die in the fire with the remains of his family.

henry's death was also shown to us in FNaF World when baby killed him.

[Caped Crochetder]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von smithboys5:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

I know they all got set on fire and everything the good ending, but I don't think it's quite over for 2 reasons:

1) Lefty's absence.
We see pictures of Baby, Freddy, and Springtrap roasting in an open fire, but we don't see Lefty. Considering Lefty is the Marionette stuck in a suit, this is a pretty hefty absence since the Marionette has been pretty damn important.

2) Springtrap is fireproof!
This isn't exactly the first time good ol' Willy Afton should've died. He was scooped out, springlocked multiple times in the books, rotted in a sealed up back room for 30 years without food and water, and already survived a fire in FNaF3. With all of that in mind, I highly doubt he's dead.

I agree but maybe casset tape guy was unaware of the events of fnaf 3, otherwise he wouldnt
have given that speech (I watched markiplier get the completion ending because I am definitely not able to get that on my own) as for lefty, you're right charlie might still be out there, trying to protect the lost souls of the crying children seeing as how all we saw about charlie was an image of the marionette standing in his box on camera in fnaf 2, you dont even get an image of lefty, so I think these are very valid arguments as to why scott must make a 7th game

i wouldn't say he "must" make FNaF 7. he "could" but i say it's up to him. he did say he wanted to wrap it up and was considering just making fun spin-offs.

[Smithsiblings4]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von smithboys5:

I agree but maybe casset tape guy was unaware of the events of fnaf 3, otherwise he wouldnt
have given that speech (I watched markiplier get the completion ending because I am definitely not able to get that on my own) as for lefty, you're right charlie might still be out there, trying to protect the lost souls of the crying children seeing as how all we saw about charlie was an image of the marionette standing in his box on camera in fnaf 2, you dont even get an image of lefty, so I think these are very valid arguments as to why scott must make a 7th game

i wouldn't say he "must" make FNaF 7. he "could" but i say it's up to him. he did say he wanted to wrap it up and was considering just making fun spin-offs.

fun spinoffs? that sounds like reason to spread hype for five nights at fredbear's once more (as long as the idea of scott making fnaf spinoffs exists so will the idea a fredbear spinoff) heheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheheh (it will never die)

[Philbert]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sp4rt4n1295:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von I use my IQ for games:

Hey, Metroid!

My name’s Commander Shepherd, thank you!

The names snake.

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von rashann:

We play as Michael in SL and the cutscenes show his skin rot and turn purple after being scooped. He is physically purple but is not The Purple guy, that's William.

Its unlikely that Henry knows about Michael. He might know that William had a son names Michael but he has no reason to be keeping up with his life especially after William killed his daughter. Also Michael says that he has been living in shadows this whole time.

BTW the working theory is that we've been playing a Michael under different names throughout all the games (except 4th) and its all but confirmed we're Michael in this game because all the animatronics act as if they recognize our character and he's the only one who would want to die in the fire with the remains of his family.

henry's death was also shown to us in FNaF World when baby killed him.

FNaF World isn’t canon. Even if it was, the desk man isn’t Henry, but an in game representation of Scott. Notice how he says he makes games instead of machines.

[Caped Crochetder]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sp4rt4n1295:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

henry's death was also shown to us in FNaF World when baby killed him.

FNaF World isn’t canon. Even if it was, the desk man isn’t Henry, but an in game representation of Scott. Notice how he says he makes games instead of machines.

i vaguely remember scott saying that wasn't meant to be himself and that Animdude (playable; not the hard mode boss) and the "Freddy in Space" boss were the only two representations. if i can find it again, i'll link it. if you find otherwise, send me a link. please know that i'm only accepting info from scott in this kind of case.

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sp4rt4n1295:

FNaF World isn’t canon. Even if it was, the desk man isn’t Henry, but an in game representation of Scott. Notice how he says he makes games instead of machines.

i vaguely remember scott saying that wasn't meant to be himself and that Animdude (playable; not the hard mode boss) and the "Freddy in Space" boss were the only two representations. if i can find it again, i'll link it. if you find otherwise, send me a link. please know that i'm only accepting info from scott in this kind of case.

Either way, it doesn’t make sense for Desk Man to be Henry, at least not the Henry from FNaF 6. Henry didn’t die to Baby murdering him, he died to the fire at the end of the game. Plus Desk Man is a character in FNaF World, the game that has Purple Guy fighting in the same party as Springtrap and the Puppet. The Puppet would never fight with Springtrap or Purple Guy. Purple Guy and Springtrap fighting together make no sense anyway because they are the same person.

[BB Azurite]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sp4rt4n1295:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von p1r6t30fr0ck:

i vaguely remember scott saying that wasn't meant to be himself and that Animdude (playable; not the hard mode boss) and the "Freddy in Space" boss were the only two representations. if i can find it again, i'll link it. if you find otherwise, send me a link. please know that i'm only accepting info from scott in this kind of case.

Either way, it doesn’t make sense for Desk Man to be Henry, at least not the Henry from FNaF 6. Henry didn’t die to Baby murdering him, he died to the fire at the end of the game. Plus Desk Man is a character in FNaF World, the game that has Purple Guy fighting in the same party as Springtrap and the Puppet. The Puppet would never fight with Springtrap or Purple Guy. Purple Guy and Springtrap fighting together make no sense anyway because they are the same person.

FNAF World is more symbolic than literal, like how in the clock playthrough you basically create the FNAF 3 minigames that allow the nightguard to set the spirits free. Baby might have been the last animatronic Henry helped William create and after he found out what Baby and the rest of SL animatronics were really created for, it 'killed' his spirit at a creator. Or maybe Scott just wanted to tease his next game.

[Caped Crochetder]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von rashann:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sp4rt4n1295:

Either way, it doesn’t make sense for Desk Man to be Henry, at least not the Henry from FNaF 6. Henry didn’t die to Baby murdering him, he died to the fire at the end of the game. Plus Desk Man is a character in FNaF World, the game that has Purple Guy fighting in the same party as Springtrap and the Puppet. The Puppet would never fight with Springtrap or Purple Guy. Purple Guy and Springtrap fighting together make no sense anyway because they are the same person.

FNAF World is more symbolic than literal, like how in the clock playthrough you basically create the FNAF 3 minigames that allow the nightguard to set the spirits free. Baby might have been the last animatronic Henry helped William create and after he found out what Baby and the rest of SL animatronics were really created for, it 'killed' his spirit at a creator. Or maybe Scott just wanted to tease his next game.

i'm just getting confused at this point. either way, i still doubt springtrap is dead due to reputation, and lefty's up to interpretation right now. if i could, i'd delete or lock this discussion thread because there's just so much **** wrong with the ending and everything that led up to it.

[great]

Springtrap survived the first fire because he escaped, something he couldn't do in this one. And EVERYTHING in the building burnt, including Lefty.

[76561198421173448]

ಠ~ಠ waw

[Rollerwings]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Crater's Grail ™:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von breadspy:

...Although I still say Henry and Mike should've sneaked out the secret exit, watched it burn to the ground to make sure they got Springtrap this time, then exchanged high fives. :)

You've just unlocked the "Screw this, let's escape!" Ending!

Already wrote the fanfic for that one! The link's in my profile.

That's really interesting about Sad Desk Man in FNaF World versus Henry. He did refer to his creations as games, but then he also admitted to making Baby and she physically appeared to kill him. That's a great theory that it was his creative spirit and not himself that was killed off. And while FNaF World wasn't entirely canon, it was interesting that the only characters from the games who made it to the Flipside were either animatronics or characters who had died in the games. It's as though the Flipside wasn't a land for the living and Sad Desk Man seemed to be the sole exception.