Forming Reinforcements

[Warlight]

stuck on this puzzle for Cao Cao. here's the breakdown:

Roles:
-Leader: Leads the fleet
-Adjudant: Administers Affairs and Supervises subordinates (politics?)
-Surveyor: Determines the naval route
-Lookout: keeps watch over enemies

Candidates:
-Wen Pin--> no1 in leadership and military, no.4 in intelligence and politics
-Wang Can-->low naval aptitude, lowest military and leadership rank
-Cai Mao-->3 abilities ranked 2, no abilities ranked below 4th
-Zhang Yun-->lowest intelligence and politics
-Yuah Huan--> low naval aptitude, no3 in intelligence

this is kinda hard since Cao Pi doesn't give you an indication on where you got it wrong

CONFIRMED COMBINATION IS:
Cai Mao -->Leader
Yuan Huan --> Adjudant
Wang Can --> Surveyor
Wen Pin --> Lookout

Credit to Rogue

[Verdakyll]

Cai Mao first and Wen pin last
don't pick Zhang Yun
don't know which one was second or third

[Warlight]

confirmed Wen/Yuan/Cai/Wang doesn't work

[Rogue]

Cai Mao, Yuah Huan, Wang Can, Wen Pin or
Cai Mao, Wang Can, Yuah Huan, , Wen Pin

Can't remember which one, think it's first. But Cai Mao and Wen Pin is the correct order.

[Warlight]

CONFIRMED COMBINATION IS CAI/ YUAN /WANG/ WEN. thanks for the tip Rogue

[Keytee Tamira]

Can anyone explain to me the logic behind confirmed formation?

Maybe it's because i'm not native english speaker, but i just think that the ones we have to choose have qualities that are quite opposite to what they should do.
Like, why Wen Pin, who has good leadership qualities, is a Lookout, instead of a Captain?

[Warlight]

Keytee Tamira a écrit :

Can anyone explain to me the logic behind confirmed formation?

Maybe it's because i'm not native english speaker, but i just think that the ones we have to choose have qualities that are quite opposite to what they should do.
Like, why Wen Pin, who has good leadership qualities, is a Lookout, instead of a Captain?

can't remember lol look at that post date. at this point, as long as it works, does it matter if it makes sense? the puzzle itself TBH wasn't too good at making sense anyway. that's why this thread existed.