Should I kill Erandur?

[KOBOLD]

I really need help. Is it better to kill him or let him live?

[WombatSasquatch]

If you are going for the achievement that requires all Daedric artifacts, then yes, you should kill him. This will let you keep the staff from that quest.

Otherwise I usually let him live; I like having Joshua Graham follow me around Skyrim.

I hope that helps.

[KOBOLD]

Originally posted by WombatSasquatch:

If you are going for the achievement that requires all Daedric artifacts, then yes, you should kill him. This will let you keep the staff from that quest.

Otherwise I usually let him live; I like having Joshua Graham follow me around Skyrim.

I hope that helps.

I tried letting him live in one save, and brutally murdering him with my elven my in another. The second one was the most fun, but I went with the first.

[Brandybuck]

Neither is better. In one case you get to be evil and get an evil reward. In the other you get to be good and get a good reward. Does your character not have characterization? What would your character do? Is he/she a good person or a bad?

[Flavio Nicolao]

No don't kill it!!!!!!

[newjeans PR manager]

Originally posted by Brandybuck:

Neither is better. In one case you get to be evil and get an evil reward. In the other you get to be good and get a good reward. Does your character not have characterization? What would your character do? Is he/she a good person or a bad?

This.

My character started out as a goody-two shoes but as he saw the horrors of the world he started desensitizing to the value of life. He will kill if he has to- but he tries to avoid it.

In this case he would kill Erandur.

[Washing Machine]

Stab him for another fancy stick to place in your house's weapon rack.
The Oblivion staff looked tons cooler though.

[Caenis Snow]

I didn't kill him.

[SpeedFreak1972]

Well I killed him once however mostly I let him live need a follower more then some daedric artifact.

[Eat3n]

Originally posted by 15fps:

Stab him for another fancy stick to place in your house's weapon rack.

Aint that the truth? Most of the Daedric items end up in a chest, a rack, or a mannequin.

[Trigger]

let him live and destroy the staff, if you play as a goody-two shoe.

[Bartholemew Quintavious IV]

♥♥♥♥

[Chi]

I killed him cause he annoys me. But that's just me. Go with your character's morals, makes the game more fun :)

[sim 35th]

I didn't kill him (who would doubt here of those ones who knows me here).

[﴿ BoneBreaker.dk ﴾]

lol after veramina told me to kill him becous he would betray me hit levitated and started casting some kind of magic (to remove the barrier i assume) i thought he was about to attack me so i killed him :P

[Arkon]

I had a character who is only there for the good of skyrim but still killed him because thats a new and shiny stick in my collection or just a few more gold