Kill or spare Sinding?

[Elaini]

I decided to kill him, because even if he couldn't control himself, I really dislike child killers, and his life as spared probably isn't going to be grand anyway...

So in a nutshell, I just let him out of his misery.

[Malaficus Shaikan]

First time i did i spared him.
At the time i didnt really know much about wherewolves.
Since that time i put him out of my misery.

From me the world is black and white.
You are either part or a threat to sociaty.
Jail are for those who can be reform into being part of sociaty.
You have proven you are a threat to sociaty.
Crime: lack of self control.
Your judgement is: too dangerous to live.

[Grave Angel]

Spare him. There are too many hunters for just one werewolf. No honor to kill with a croud.
Kill him after hunters gone. He too dangerous and lack of self-control.
Discover bonus award ::)

[Elaini]

Originally posted by graveangel:

Spare him. There are too many hunters for just one werewolf. No honor to kill with a croud.
Kill him after hunters gone. He too dangerous and lack of self-control.
Discover bonus award ::)

I wouldn't say too many. If you have played as a werewolf you know how easy it is to kill many and get away with it as long as you transform in secret. It comes in handy for Dark Brotherhood. But I don't like Dark Brotherhood.

Also remember that Aela says about being a werewolf. Some lycans won't separate the animal from themselves anymore, and become feral. Sinding must be such a case. I'd much rather trust Aela than Sinding. At least she has some sanity left, even if she's deep into being moon born.

And no, my thinking isn't black and white. I just see Sinding as one of the feral werewolves, beyond aid, self control and social security. But it's Hircine I blame for it.

Ironic that when I let Sinding out of the misery of being feral werewolf, I actually do Hircine's bidding.

[Malaficus Shaikan]

Originally posted by Elaini:

Originally posted by graveangel:

Spare him. There are too many hunters for just one werewolf. No honor to kill with a croud.
Kill him after hunters gone. He too dangerous and lack of self-control.
Discover bonus award ::)

I wouldn't say too many. If you have played as a werewolf you know how easy it is to kill many and get away with it as long as you transform in secret. It comes in handy for Dark Brotherhood. But I don't like Dark Brotherhood.

Also remember that Aela says about being a werewolf. Some lycans won't separate the animal from themselves anymore, and become feral. Sinding must be such a case. I'd much rather trust Aela than Sinding. At least she has some sanity left, even if she's deep into being moon born.

And no, my thinking isn't black and white. I just see Sinding as one of the feral werewolves, beyond aid, self control and social security. But it's Hircine I blame for it.

Ironic that when I let Sinding out of the misery of being feral werewolf, I actually do Hircine's bidding.

I know what you mean.
I was fighting these falmer and my weapons where barely making a dent.
When i tranformed to fully upgraded wherewolf.
It was childs play to clear the entire ruin.
Tobad i had to use the wait function when i was done before i could start looting/interacting with my seroundings.
Biggest downside of being a wherewolf is that you cant control when it ends.
Second biggest downside is that you can only use it onces a day.

[SpeedFreak1972]

I spare him need the ring I play often as werewolf.

[Heroscare]

Help him kill the hunters
Kill him once he talks to you about thanking you and living in the grotto and blablabla
Get Saviour's Hide from Hircine
Leave the grotto and get Ring of Hircine from Hircine
???
Profit!!!11!!11!1!

[Metric Guard]

There is a way to get both items without using the console, just spare him, go outside, and when Hircine starts to talk to you, immediately exit out of the conversation and go back and kill Sinding. Then just go back out and talk to Hircine and he'll give you the ring. It's a pretty good 2-in-one exploit if I do say so myself.

But yeah, if you're a werewolf fan, sparing him and getting the ring is the best option.

[iMihalis]

But nobody has actually answered the question. Most of the people here say that you should spare Sinding because you'll get a ring or you should follow Hircine because he will give you something good. Nobody has answered WHY I should kill or let Sinding live. So. SHOULD I KILL SINDING OR LET HIM LEAVE? AND WHY?

[Metric Guard]

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

But nobody has actually answered the question. Most of the people here say that you should spare Sinding because you'll get a ring or you should follow Hircine because he will give you something good. Nobody has answered WHY I should kill or let Sinding live. So. SHOULD I KILL SINDING OR LET HIM LEAVE? AND WHY?

p l e a s e
d o n ' t
n e c r o
2
y e a r
o l d
t h r e a d s

[iMihalis]

Originally posted by MuteGuardian7:

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

But nobody has actually answered the question. Most of the people here say that you should spare Sinding because you'll get a ring or you should follow Hircine because he will give you something good. Nobody has answered WHY I should kill or let Sinding live. So. SHOULD I KILL SINDING OR LET HIM LEAVE? AND WHY?

p l e a s e
d o n ' t
n e c r o
2
y e a r
o l d
t h r e a d s

Is this english? I have no idea. Also, I did not speak to you :)

[Uncle64]

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

Originally posted by MuteGuardian7:

p l e a s e
d o n ' t
n e c r o
2
y e a r
o l d
t h r e a d s

Is this english? I have no idea. Also, I did not speak to you :)

Translate.
Please dont necro 2 year old treads.

Do you have issues whit english?

And yes he did speak to you, since you actually did NECRO one two year old tread.
Get it?
You did wrong. Not him.
Go and find the round corner in the dark now.

And about the issue in the tread, there are 5000 treads that takes up Sinding.
And yes I did kill him.

[iMihalis]

Originally posted by Uncle64SwE:

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

Is this english? I have no idea. Also, I did not speak to you :)

Translate.
Please dont necro 2 year old treads.

Do you have issues whit english?

And yes he did speak to you, since you actually did NECRO one two year old tread.
Get it?
You did wrong. Not him.
Go and find the round corner in the dark now.

Lel I did NOT speak only to him for one answer. He came out of nowhere and said a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. So YES it is HIS fault. You know what? If you want to answer to my question, then feel free to do so. If not, then DON'T DEAL WITH IT!

[Uncle64]

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

Originally posted by Uncle64SwE:

Translate.
Please dont necro 2 year old treads.

Do you have issues whit english?

And yes he did speak to you, since you actually did NECRO one two year old tread.
Get it?
You did wrong. Not him.
Go and find the round corner in the dark now.

Lel I did NOT speak only to him for one answer. He came out of nowhere and said a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. So YES it is HIS fault. You know what? If you want to answer to my question, then feel free to do so. If not, then DON'T DEAL WITH IT!

Then you say the same to me.
DONT
NECRO
2
YEAR
OLD
POSTS.

Get it?

[iMihalis]

Originally posted by Uncle64SwE:

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

Lel I did NOT speak only to him for one answer. He came out of nowhere and said a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. So YES it is HIS fault. You know what? If you want to answer to my question, then feel free to do so. If not, then DON'T DEAL WITH IT!

Then you say the same to me.
DONT
NECRO
2
YEAR
OLD
POSTS.

Get it?

I will do whatever I want, if you like :)

[Uncle64]

Originally posted by Ⓘ ⓁⒶⒼ:

Originally posted by Uncle64SwE:

Then you say the same to me.
DONT
NECRO
2
YEAR
OLD
POSTS.

Get it?

I will do whatever I want, if you like :)

No, you cant, those are forum rules set by Steam. You are not free to post or write what you want here.
Break those rules and risk your self for banned. That is fine for me. I simply dont care.