Bug with Natsuki and the poem minigame? (Beware SPOILERS)

[Anezka de Astora]

So I already completed the game, saw the credits and reinstalled the game.

Now I'm playing again to see what happens when I chose other dialogue options. Sayori has already been deleted by Monika and I'm going with Natsuki's "route". After the day Natsuki and Yuri had a fight and Natsuki left class crying, I chose every word in the minigame for Natsuki's poem correctly (all 20 of them), but she doesn't like the poem, while Yuri does and Monika says it is very metaphorical like Yuri's poems. Also I got the scene in which you read a book with Yuri, and after that Natsuki goes mad because I didn't read manga with her, and I got a END, though the game went on and she was still in the club :\

Is this a bug with the minigame or something, or is this how it is supposed to happen?

[HypetheKomodo]

This is how it's supposed to happen. Yuri's obessive personality forces you to hang out with her and ditch Natsuki, even if your poems are directed towards her. Monika further pushes you that way because she knows what it will do to Yuri.

I do encourage continuing to dedicate your poems to Natsuki, though: You get unique scenes involving her, which you have already seen!

[Anezka de Astora]

Originally posted by Flustered:

This is how it's supposed to happen. Yuri's obessive personality forces you to hang out with her and ditch Natsuki, even if your poems are directed towards her. Monika further pushes you that way because she knows what it will do to Yuri.

I do encourage continuing to dedicate your poems to Natsuki, though: You get unique scenes involving her, which you have already seen!

Oh, okay. It's a bit sad we don't get to know more about Natsuki. I got a poem about her "papa" in my first run, so I wanted to know more.

Thank you :)