[Poll] Which dad did you do your first playthrough with?

[Babyhuehnchen Слава Україні!]

http://www.strawpoll.me/13512992

[zommie]

craig
joseph (i was totally confused reading posts about him and his ending- but when it happened i was srs devastated)
damien
robert (haha didn't smash on my first playthrough- but did for the acheviement)
brian (didn't really like the whole competitive basis but i love him)
mat
hugo

overall it was super fun! time to go back to get the rest of the acheviements!

[cheesed to meet you]

Brian > Damien > Hugo > Joseph > Robert > Mat > Craig

Did first two dates with everyone first however. Was looking forward to Brian the most, ended up liking Damian more.

[Sentientmonkey]

So far Brian>Robert>Hugo>Craig.
Brian is my Dream Daddy for sure, if only the Dadsona wasn't such a jerk. And I haven't actually finished Craig yet. I'm savoring this game.

I'm also not even sure if I'll do Joseph's.

[tofu]

joseph.. which led to me researching if there was a better ending than what i got and -

THE REGREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEET

[Penn]

Brian because I absolutely loved him from the start. He and Hugo are tied for my favorite dads tbh, but I love them all lol

[thanatos101b]

I did Joseph first because he seemed to have the most potential for an interesting storyline (I was mildly disapointed).

Then I did Robert because he and Craig were the sexiest.

Then Mat (kinda just picked him at random).

Then Brian (because he was the second farthest right on the top row after Robert).

Then Hugo (because he was the second farthest right on the bottom row after Joseph).

Then Damien (because he was next to Hugo).

Then Craig because I wanted to end the game on a good note.

[Viktor]

Robert > Craig > Mat... that for the moment, the rest will be Damien, Hugo, Brian anf lastly Joseph (Not because I don't like him but people suggested play him the latest) and I think I like them all but Robert and Craig are the best for me following closely by Mat.

I liked Brian before talking to him, since then I will play his route just to complete it but I dislike him the most (I really don't get along with competitive people and when Amanda got embarrased because of his teeths in the first confrontation with him I decided I kinda hate him lol I'm protective Dad)

[Zehith]

Damien -> Craig -> Robert -> Mat -> Jospeh -> Brian -> Hugo

All in all, the first three are the only ones I really liked. I like all the characters as characters, but for me, I only really enjoyed Damien, Craig, and Robert's routes.

[fantasmagorica]

I... I went for Joseph first. Still haven't recovered from that.

My fav so far is Damien, though.

[StompMeFlat]

On my first play through, I dated everyone to two dates (even the jerk Robert if you slept with him night #1) and picked my favorite. I ended up going...

1. Craig- He's the best. Great with his kids, great with you, and great with annoying moms thirsty for him. And that 3rd date felt wonderful. Not only fun, but you really get into the pressure he feels on him and it makes him a deeper character.

2. Robert- Wanted to find out the mystery around him, I failed him the first time in a rather dumb fashion. Since I never slept with him but my lying wasn't on par with the tour... he accused me of only caring about the sex and not about his kid. I didn't know anything really of his kid and never slept with him... so screw off Robert. Anways, I redid it to get the good ending and it felt better but still lakcing since he'll never change. He won't. >.>

3. Joseph- The demon man! I find blond men really attractive, so I wanted to give him a shot even if I saw all the cult stuff in advance. Turns out, I think his "cold hearted lying" is more or less made up by the fans. I think (if excluding the weird cult crap) he really is just a nice guy that feels trapped in his horrible relationship and slipped at least once (with Robert) into cheating so is in no regards innocent. But I mean... at least he tries to take care of the community and at least he tries to take care of his kids? Mary is a lot worse than him and I wanted to get him away from her... and it fails in the end. Looks like there is no happy ending with Joseph. And the Cult Ending coming reality will just worsen it and make more people hate on him. v.v

4. Hugo- I wasn't expecting much from him. I'm not into wrestling either. In the end, I kind of like the guy, I feel he gets less love than he should. I just wish the dog stuff was in his storyline instead of Damien, so I could of patched up things between him and Ernest. I want that little punk to be happy.

5. Damien- I went into it waiting for the transgender moment and missed it entirely. I liked his first date best and the second was cool to. I wasn't that fond of the last one in terms of him or Mary though. I LOVED the dog with Ernest and Hugo though. The ending for him and his son just seemed dull or well.... boring as Damien put it.

6. Brian- Was a toss up between him or Mat. Went with Brian and kind of regret it. I love Daisy. And I liked my kid bonding with her, but I wasn't into the dads facing off or Brian really.

7. Mat- I really like his kid's sprite, she's adorable. Too bad she had little to no role. Lol. Anyways I found him sort of cute. I don't know, I guess I didn't feel too much wow factor with him. Probably more dates and he could of been more interesting to me.

So TLDR

Play Order
Craig > Robert > Joseph > Hugo > Damien > Brian > Mat

[Poi]

Damien > Craig > Joseph > Mat > Robert > Hugo > Brian

The only ones I liked were Damien, Robert and Hugo though. Dames is by far my fave <3

[Reminus]

Mat > Brian > Damien > Craig so far.
I'm working up to Hugo and Robert (No, I did not sleep with Robert, but I'll probably do it later for the achievment and to see how the route differs) and as for Joseph...

Well, he was going to be my option after Mat, but I rather hold off until his route is fixed.

[pennywhistle]

I'd planned to do Mat first, but after hearing the spoilers about Joseph decided I'd get him out of the way. I even like the guy, but as someone who had parents who stayed together waaaayyyyy too long (literally as soon as I learned what divorce was I wondered why the heck they hadn't done that yet) his story hit close to home in a different way than I think they meant it to.

[barbayat]

引用自 pennywhistle：

I'd planned to do Mat first, but after hearing the spoilers about Joseph decided I'd get him out of the way. I even like the guy, but as someone who had parents who stayed together waaaayyyyy too long (literally as soon as I learned what divorce was I wondered why the heck they hadn't done that yet) his story hit close to home in a different way than I think they meant it to.

I felt the same way, I was like "Oh Joseph, it's a question of whether you still love each others, it's whether you being together is good for the kids." But then again the whole setup around them feels way too heavy a subject for a game that has fun lighthearted tone. I mean, I love the third date with Joseph when it's cheesy and fun, but if I think too much about it, it's just way to simplistic. I'm sure even then you could've resolved things on a more lighthearted note- but who knows what the ending is that is apparantly blocked by bugs.

On topic, dated Hugo after that, really loved it, too - looking kind of forward to everyone's third date except Robert (but the achievement hoe in me will do it anyway)

[pennywhistle]

Though, you know, weirdly at the same time I don't think I'd have been happy if he had gone through with leaving for the dadsona? Like, they hardly know each other. Joseph needs to realize that even if he's alone he and everyone in his family will ultimately be happier if he and Mary divorce and do it because of that, not because he has a crush on a guy he's only spent a good hunk of time with a couple times when they might find that they're incompatible in an actual relationship.

I'm just going to assume that is what eventually (and probably sooner rather than later) happens post-Joseph ending, and he and Dadsona do eventually end up in a relationship but go into it much more slowly because it'll take Dadsona time to trust him again.