What are the best ways to get the two remaining hidden achievements?

[Bogart]

Game was awesome.

Captain Did It and Abandon Ship. I finished the game 100% but have these two remaining. I can use the rewind feature on my completed save file but all the solvable fates are already done so I can't make any alterations. And I can't do Captain Did It because you can't change fates once they are correct.

[worstcase11]

Someone on this forum offers a savegame for the 'Captain did it' achievement to copy.

However, if you want to get the achievements both by yourself you need to start a new game.

You'll get 'Abandon Ship', if you have watched all the death scenes aboard but leave the ship when the storm comes without entering all possible fates.

For Captain did it, you have to sort a picture to every name correctly, but enter a death by the hand of the Captain to absolutely everyone including the captain himself.
(Also I think they need to be wrong causes of death even for those crewmembers the capatin actually killed)
So for example if someone got shot by crewmember x, chose 'was killed by the captain with an axe'.

[Pckables]

Originally posted by worstcase11:

(Also I think they need to be wrong causes of death even for those crewmembers the capatin actually killed)
So for example if someone got shot by crewmember x, chose 'was killed by the captain with an axe'.

I can confirm the causes of death DON'T need to be wrong for the most part. When I was going through, I was putting "spiked by the captain" for a lot of the spike deaths since it seemed sillier to me.

On the other hand, you may need to have 0 correct fates at the end for the achievement to count. For safety, I intentionally put the wrong causes of death for the few people actually killed by the captain.
I could be wrong about the 0 correct fates part, but I didn't want to risk it.

[Odwolf]

You don't even need to identify the people for Captain Did It. I just entered "killed with an axe by the Captain" for all 58 (except for the captain; he shot himself).

And the only person I identified was the captain. I left the rest unknown and still got the achievement after leaving the ship and waiting for the cutscene afterwards to end.

So regardless of how you write how the captain killed them, it won't matter if you leave them unknown.