Is this a bug? (ed. It totally isn't)

[Lord1box]

The opponent used (ed.) Give and Take to special summon a monster from his graveyard to my field. This somehow cancelled out the special summon of my monster from my graveyard. Even though the card didn't seem to interact directly with what I was doing.
What's going on here? Is this a bug or am I just missing some rules interaction?

The Replay is Below:

#DuelReplay #DuelLinks
https://duellinks.konami.net/att/050ce545844e4ecce8848ecef8734191de977a2107

[Nosferath]

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

[Orochi Samurai]

Originally posted by Nosferathou:

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

This ^ and yes, your opponent played you like a fiddle.

[Nosferath]

Originally posted by MagmaticMike:

Originally posted by Nosferathou:

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

This ^ and yes, your opponent played you like a fiddle.

Hehehe, this replay reminded me of this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXWcgH8TQ3c

This has to be the most frustrating way to lose a duel.

[Lord1box]

Originally posted by Nosferathou:

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

Thank you. I didn't read Ra's disciple text and only remembered the special summoning part. Pretty cool rules interaction and combo.

[Nosferath]

Originally posted by Lord1box:

Originally posted by Nosferathou:

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

Thank you. I didn't read Ra's disciple text and only remembered the special summoning part. Pretty cool rules interaction and combo.

No problem bro, it happens to all of us.

Also, yeah, that guy pulled a really cool and annoying combo, Ra's disciple is harder to get hid off than it looks, you did good to not waste anymore time on that duel.

[LDvergil/DNDM]

Originally posted by MagmaticMike:

Originally posted by Nosferathou:

Ra's Disciple effect : You cannot special summon monsters, except by the effect of Ra's Disciple.

His effect is the following: When this card is Summoned: You can Special Summon up to 2 "Ra's Disciple" from your hand and/or Deck. Cannot be Tributed, except for the Tribute Summon of "Slifer the Sky Dragon", "Obelisk the Tormentor", or "The Winged Dragon of Ra". You cannot Special Summon monsters, except by the effect of "Ra's Disciple".

Since you were not going to special summon any more Ra's Disciple, you can't special summon at all, your opponent was a smart man.

This ^ and yes, your opponent played you like a fiddle.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBIcvTNdpTI