Black Desert

Black Desert

Auditore Oct 8, 2017 @ 9:33pm
Worst trading system in an MMO by far...
Today marks the 3rd week spent trying to buy pearl items, from the market place and still Not a single ♥♥♥♥ing purchase....

You have failed to purchase item

You have failed to purchase item

You have failed to purchase item

You have failed to purchase item

You have failed to purchase item

It goes on and on for weeks...

This is getting really out of hand, This is by for the worst Auction house type trading system I myself have experienced in any MMORPG, This is not how I want to spend my time in this game and I'm really getting fed up because I've already wasted nearly 3 weeks trying to buy a single item but only to have it say "You have failed to purchase item" Which really angers me out because I've been afking more than actually playing the game itself...


EDIT: I keep debating with my self that if it's worth it to buy horse armor from the market place once a coupon event is here, but I don't know how much it's going to give off...,
Last edited by Auditore; Oct 9, 2017 @ 5:58pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 56 comments
Jo Oct 8, 2017 @ 11:59pm 
Ebay it certainly isn't. Whoever devised this "auctionhouse" (very misleading term as it's more like a random lottery and if the winner doesn't buy it it then goes up for grabs) didn't have a clue. Tbh I gave up trying to get Pearl items as I'd rather not spend my ingame time camping at the marketplace for hours on end. I look in from time to time if I need something in particular and just go to the "buy" options rather than bidding.
Auditore Oct 9, 2017 @ 12:21am 
Originally posted by Jojo:
Ebay it certainly isn't. Whoever devised this "auctionhouse" (very misleading term as it's more like a random lottery and if the winner doesn't buy it it then goes up for grabs) didn't have a clue. Tbh I gave up trying to get Pearl items as I'd rather not spend my ingame time camping at the marketplace for hours on end. I look in from time to time if I need something in particular and just go to the "buy" options rather than bidding.
I've been trying to obtain a Horse outfit set and recently a valkryie outfit set for weeks now and I'm debating with my self do I just buy the horse outfit from the store??
axelmonster Oct 9, 2017 @ 1:39am 
Originally posted by Jojo:
Ebay it certainly isn't. Whoever devised this "auctionhouse" (very misleading term as it's more like a random lottery and if the winner doesn't buy it it then goes up for grabs) didn't have a clue. Tbh I gave up trying to get Pearl items as I'd rather not spend my ingame time camping at the marketplace for hours on end. I look in from time to time if I need something in particular and just go to the "buy" options rather than bidding.
It's not called auctionhouse anywhere in game, so not sure where you got this "misleading term" from.
DanielUK Oct 9, 2017 @ 4:45am 
Originally posted by axelmonster:
Originally posted by Jojo:
Ebay it certainly isn't. Whoever devised this "auctionhouse" (very misleading term as it's more like a random lottery and if the winner doesn't buy it it then goes up for grabs) didn't have a clue. Tbh I gave up trying to get Pearl items as I'd rather not spend my ingame time camping at the marketplace for hours on end. I look in from time to time if I need something in particular and just go to the "buy" options rather than bidding.
It's not called auctionhouse anywhere in game, so not sure where you got this "misleading term" from.
sarcasium ♥♥♥♥! u know what he ment! marketplace! auctionhouse-marketplace same thing
axelmonster Oct 9, 2017 @ 5:22am 
Originally posted by Fury_FX:
Originally posted by axelmonster:
It's not called auctionhouse anywhere in game, so not sure where you got this "misleading term" from.
sarcasium ♥♥♥♥! u know what he ment! marketplace! auctionhouse-marketplace same thing
But it's a marketplace, not an auctionhouse.

The words are not synonymous, I really don't agree that they are the same thing.

On a marketplace, you place your goods up for sale for the price you think it will sell at, and it's up to the customers if they want to buy it or not. First come, first serve. BDO has a price managed market place, so there is a minimum and maximum limit to possible price. ESO would be an example of an unmanaged market, where you can set prices however high or low you want.

In an auction house, you put up an item with a starting bid, people then place their bids and at the end of the bidding time the highest bidder gets the item. Prices can be managed or not, usually there is a minimum and maximum starting bid allowed by the game.


For the record, sarcasium is not even a word.
Originally posted by Auditore:
I've been trying to obtain a Horse outfit set and recently a valkryie outfit set for weeks now and I'm debating with my self do I just buy the horse outfit from the store??
Horse Outfits are the hardest to get of all Pearl Items. High Demand with very low supply. Pets are the second hardest, more in Numbers with a really high demand. Directly followed by Value Packs. Outfits are somewhat 'easy' to get, since the demand is far less.


Still: Every single pearl Items on the Market is brought by a player who spend real money while the Ratio Money to silver is pretty bad. And not to forget: There are just two markets. NA and EU. This means you compete with all the channels you see while logging in. Thousends of people bidding on the same thing you do. On top of that: Players are only allowed to sell 5 Pearl Items per Week, this keeps the Numbers of Pearlitems on the Market lower too.


How high you value your own town should determine if you better of spending the money personally into Pearlitems instead of playing lottery against thousends of others.
DCid Oct 9, 2017 @ 9:55am 
This is the price you have to pay to stop complete and total abuse of the in-game market system by Gold Sellers and players who love to inflate the market to the point where only the richest 1% can buy anything.

We veterans put up with it because the free market system ran by players is much, much, much worst and prone to abuse.

We've had several people come here to complain about the in-game market system. And they blatantly admitted they were Gold Sellers and players from other MMOs like WoW who admitted they wanted to inflate market prices like they did in WoW to make other players suffer.
BarfingPanda Oct 9, 2017 @ 11:17am 
One of the worst downsides to this game.
Usually your better off going and farming certain materials you need for crafting or going between farming for black stones and buying a couple off the market.

People literally camp the marketplace annoying af. Pre-orders dont work out too well.

Stil like it though.
Last edited by BarfingPanda; Oct 9, 2017 @ 11:20am
Y_u_no_come Oct 9, 2017 @ 11:20am 
It's hard but not impossible. If you're talking about the outfits, I've won a total of 6 out of hundreds of bids. Hundreds. I'm still trying to get a ninja Narasawa outfit. It takes patience.
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Marketplace is fine. Its u who doesnt understand it.

Pearl items r hard to get cause 90% of them is pre-ordered for x2,x3... x5 values. Highest pre-order gets it. Nothing random there.
Try understanding the system yourself first.

The auction-system is one of the reasons why I stopped playing.

"F2P" and especially asian games, where the developers go out of their way to make your gameplay an absolute misery to force you to spend cash in their microtransaction-system.
Last edited by Swagmaster Love 🇪🇺; Oct 9, 2017 @ 12:03pm
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Originally posted by Mercy:

The auction-system

As someone already mentioned - Its not the Auction house/system. Its the MarketPlace. Learn the difference.

MP is fine. Building a monopoly is not possible unlike in some other MMOs like WoW where u have Auchtion House.
Now I get it. Thanks mate.
Game is still a tideous moneyextortion noone should ever touch though.

Unless you have a few thousand Euro to throw in the bin.

As for the "noone gets to have the monopoly."
That's just naive.
It's there for a reason: To keep the developers monopoly on extortion.
Last edited by Swagmaster Love 🇪🇺; Oct 9, 2017 @ 12:16pm
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Originally posted by Mercy:
http://lmgtfy.com/?iie=1&q=black+desert+bidding+system

400 Hours in Black Desert and you don't have a clue as to how it works.
That's just sad mate.
LoL im not the one that quit the game cause butthurt. I make 1 billion silver per month because I understand the system perfectly.

So git gud or cut with the crying.
Amazing.
I waste my time with better games while you grind silver in Black Desert.
I'm just on another level when it comes to gitting gud.
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Originally posted by Mercy:
Amazing.
I waste my time with better games while you grind silver in Black Desert.
I'm just on another level when it comes to gitting gud.
LoL muppet. First u say i have low play-time aka 400 hours. Now u say Im wasting my time grinding silver in BDO. Get yr story composed a lil better. U muppet.
I said the opposit. you* you* your* you*
Cowtipper Oct 9, 2017 @ 12:36pm 
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Originally posted by Mercy:

The auction-system

As someone already mentioned - Its not the Auction house/system. Its the MarketPlace. Learn the difference.

MP is fine. Building a monopoly is not possible unlike in some other MMOs like WoW where u have Auchtion House.
Next up for the glowy brained folks here is the pre order function.Anyone care to try and explain that abortion of a function go right ahead.
Originally posted by unreal.status:
Pearl items r hard to get cause 90% of them is pre-ordered for x2,x3... x5 values. Highest pre-order gets it. Nothing random there.
Pearl Items cant be pre-ordered at all. They just dont fall under the 10-15 minute quere time before they show up. Instead they come up at the next Market Tick. Which is between Instant and 2 Minutes.

Originally posted by unreal.status:
Next up for the glowy brained folks here is the pre order function.Anyone care to try and explain that abortion of a function go right ahead.
What is the problem? Around 30% of items put onto the market check if there is a pre-order up. If there is it gets pre-ordered, overwise everyone has a chance to bid on them. The Bid is a lottery, on person gets it. (Failed to purchase = Someone else won but didnt checket yet; Already sold = Someone else won and checked for it; Invalid Quanity = Someone else won, checked for it and didnt but the full amount in, leaving less back (most happen by accident))

You hate the system? Only the rich hate it because they cant just easily buy everything. With the system in Place it might be random who gets the item, but at least everyone has an equal chance. Even the casual player which just enough money to buy the item he wants.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 56 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Oct 8, 2017 @ 9:33pm
Posts: 56