Sniper: Ghost Warrior 3 VS Sniper Elite 4. Which one is worth your MONEY!

[FROGGY]

Looking and comparing these two games, which do you think is better and why?

[FROGGY]

I say that sniper elite 4 is a better experiance if your looking for a more realistic sniper-shooter game.

It offers great multiplayer and single player missions
The graphics are similar.

[Yij]

Me personally will be SGW3. Reasons being that the developers have improved each passing game immensely, and there really hasn't been a realism based FPS shooter like the IGI series since... the IGI series.

Whilst I like the concept of the Sniper Elite series, Rebellion has acknowledged the bugs of previous titles, but never fixed them. Super accurate AI that can spot you through walls was mentioned as improvements for the 3rd game, but ultimately still remained.

[FROGGY]

AH fair enough. However i feel like the missons are just a repetiton of the last.Find target,kill target senario.Its boring after a while.

[SkacikPL]

SE 4 all the way.

[DELTA]

SGW3, ive played the SE series and its great but i dont like 3rd person games and the ww2 setting isnt very interesting to me anymore

[konrad50023]

SGW series because i have played all the se games and after the 3rd i didnt like it anymore as the ai was stuid af and im also polish and i love how 2 biggest polish gaming compaines are one of the best including cdproject

[Wak]

SGW3 captures the "sniper feeling" much more in my opinion.
Calibrating your scope, understanding the bullet drop, conserving ammo, etc.
SGW3 just makes you feel more sniper-y.

[gabrielonuris]

Actually, it will be both for me. We're in a lack of proper sniper games lately, so everytime Rebellion and CI Games release another one, I buy both.

[Warlord]

Ideally I intend to get both. I've enjoyed the Sniper Elite series for a while now, and I'd rather have 3rd persion than 1st anyway, but Sniper Ghost Warrior 3 has something to offer too. And I care nothing for multiplayer so that has nothing to do with my decision making. Sniper Elite 4 will be WW2 era, and SGW3 will be modern era. So there's that too. If they were both in the same era I might consider one over the other, but since they are not, I won't think about it. The only thing that has bothered me about the SE series is the often thin story telling. Though the gameplay has kept me interested.

I didn't like SGW1, and I cannot remember liking SGW2. After seeing videos and reading about SGW3, I jumped to sign up for the Beta. And I'm glad I did. To me it seems like a vast improvement over the previous two games and makes me actually want to buy it. The only bug I noticed in the Beta was that there were times when it wouldn't allow me to move the bodies, where in other times I could. Not sure the reason for it, but it was a Beta. I haven't seen much to make me think there will be much of a story in SGW3, and I'm hoping they are just holding that back. I do like the "take it however you want" mentality that is in the third game in case I want to switch things up. I like that in any game. Being able to adjust my scope, etc is also very appealing and I wish other series would take that into consideration as well, but they often don't.

[FROGGY]

I just feel like CI interactive is giving us the free seasons pass with the game to make it more compelling for us to buy.This shows that they aren't confident to sell the game on its own and charge the full price. You know the saying ... if its to good to be true it probably is. :)

[Wak]

Originally posted by Supposse2study:

I just feel like CI interactive is giving us the free seasons pass with the game to make it more compelling for us to buy.This shows that they aren't confident to sell the game on its own and charge the full price. You know the saying ... if its to good to be true it probably is. :)

Or they could genuinely be passionate about their new project, and are trying to give back to us for the constant feedback and support?

[LoliNoxTan]

Originally posted by wak:

Originally posted by Supposse2study:

I just feel like CI interactive is giving us the free seasons pass with the game to make it more compelling for us to buy.This shows that they aren't confident to sell the game on its own and charge the full price. You know the saying ... if its to good to be true it probably is. :)

Or they could genuinely be passionate about their new project, and are trying to give back to us for the constant feedback and support?

I agree. Just look at how active they've been in these forums. Such most replies are the same "Send your DxDiag file" but they're just reminding people so they can get more info for the game

[FROGGY]

Well what i suggest is that we wait for the reviewers to decide whether its worth our money. Granted the devs are responding to our feedback but how much of it is actuallly been resloved. Besides i find the game to be very repetitive. All the missions are the same- seek and kill.The AI is just a disaster, very generic voice acting and are so predictable.

[Sharpe]

I'll be going for Sniper Elite 4 next week. I'll be looking in on this from time to time. And yes, I will be looking rather closely at wheter or not what was seen in the beta can be augmented and upgraded (aka fixed).

[Wak]

Originally posted by Supposse2study:

Well what i suggest is that we wait for the reviewers to decide whether its worth our money. Granted the devs are responding to our feedback but how much of it is actuallly been resloved. Besides i find the game to be very repetitive. All the missions are the same- seek and kill.The AI is just a disaster, very generic voice acting and are so predictable.

We only played 2 missions, neither of them were the same.
In one, we redirected satellite dishes, in the other, we assassinated a dangerous war-criminal.
They have fixed the AI, over the course of a 4 day long beta. I'd say that's a lot of dedication.
At first, the AI alerted an entire outpost as soon as they even glanced at you, now it takes them a few seconds to spot you and react.

I don't see many problems with this game as of yet. These developers are truly trying to make an enjoyable experience, and they show it.