[Spoiler] Did you tell Rachel

[Timmy the Dragonborn]

I told her, what would happen if you don't?

[MarsKiller]

Well.. Just like they said... Rachel will be happy with her Father...

[Timmy the Dragonborn]

Originally posted by MarsKiller:

Well.. Just like they said... Rachel will be happy with her Father...

But as her friend, Chloe got to tell her the truth, Rachel for sure does not want her best friend lying to her.

[prizkilla]

Of course.

She's gonna know the truth sooner than later, o wait..

[MarsKiller]

But... Would you break a releationship with her father to make her unhappy for the rest of her life? Or would you lie and keep her happy? Make a choice.. (I know... I stole it from the game)

Originally posted by Prizkilla ♔:

Of course.

She's gonna know the truth sooner than later, o wait..

That hurts....

[Timmy the Dragonborn]

Originally posted by Prizkilla ♔:

Of course.

She's gonna know the truth sooner than later, o wait..

Wait entil she realises that her best friend tried to lie to her? She used to say that the only one she can trust is Chloe.

[Timmy the Dragonborn]

Originally posted by MarsKiller:

But... Would you break a releationship with her father to make her unhappy for the rest of her life? Or would you lie and keep her happy? Make a choice.. (I know... I stole it from the game)

But as you can see in the truth ending, she is still quite happy with Chloe even if you told here the truth and she did talked to her mother for once.

[prizkilla]

Originally posted by Dragonborntim:

Originally posted by Prizkilla ♔:

Of course.

She's gonna know the truth sooner than later, o wait..

Wait entil she realises that her best friend tried to lie to her?

No.

I checked your profile, and you have already played through Life Is Strange

She's dead before she knows the truth

[Avalanche]

I know for sure, if my dad did that, i would want to know.

So i told her the truth.

I know for usre if my other half kept that secret from me to protect me, i would never forgive her.

[Timmy the Dragonborn]

Originally posted by Lithari:

I know for sure, if my dad did that, i would want to know.

So i told her the truth.

I know for usre if my other half kept that secret from me to protect me, i would never forgive her.

Yep, sometimes we do value truth above relationship.

[MarsKiller]

Originally posted by Dragonborntim:

Originally posted by MarsKiller:

But... Would you break a releationship with her father to make her unhappy for the rest of her life? Or would you lie and keep her happy? Make a choice.. (I know... I stole it from the game)

But as you can see in the truth ending, she is still quite happy with Chloe even if you told here the truth and she did talked to her mother for once.

The issue is.. I didn't saw it yet.. I just coudn't hurt her more.... Knowing i did anyway :(

[Excrucian]

I hesitated but I told her the truth. It's not directly because whe told Chloe that she was the only one she could trust but more along these lines:

If I didn't and she found out (Not going into any meta about her time of death, LiS and so on) then whe would've felt betrayed by not only her father, but also her best friend and lover. Which would create hella more pain and issues then. By telling her now, I risked her being angry at Chloe but if she were, I was banking on the fact that she'll sooner than later realise that this was both the right thing to do and what she wanted, leading for her to ask Chloe's forgiveness and surely strengthening their bonds. As it turned out, she didn't even get angry at Chloe for more than a second...

Well, at least that's how I saw and played it. :)

[DR GOO]

By the time I got to that part I had stopped caring about the game and characters, they blew it with this episode and they know it. Keep cringing Deck9, 3/10 for Ep3 10/10 for the other 2.

[Tzunny]

Ofc, truth always, she deserve the truth finally!

[SuperNotMatt]

You tell the people you love the truth.

I was almost going to hide it from Rachel (Sera was pretty persuasive), but then I realized that I had Chloe tell William that she would want to know if he'd ever lied to her in the final dream (hallucination?) sequence. I thought it was really powerful when he said he couldn't answer that because he's dead. Basically, life is painful and people are imperfect. Chloe's "perfect" relationship with William only exists in the past, and it's only perfect because William is gone and Chloe chooses to see it that way.

And I've had personal experience with this in my own life, as I'm sure most of us have. When you tell people the truth, no matter how difficult it may be, at least you know where you stand with each other. The truth was painful, sure, but Rachel would not have been better off with a friend who lied to her. That would just have made Rachel's life even more fake than it already was, and you could add Chloe to the list of Arcadia Bay's liars. If you tell Rachel the truth, at least she'll know that Chloe is honest.

Like Rachel said in the beginning of the episode, she feels like Chloe is the only person she can trust. I couldn't break that trust, and I didn't want to.

[mutantbeth]

I told her the truth. It was hard cause I did like the father, but maybe he should think twice before dealing with criminals