The Puppet: Already Unmasked? And The True Villain of FNAF

[The Everygamer]

Hello, everyone. I'm new to steam, but I've been following the FNAF lore for quite a while, and I've come up with some interesting conclusions.

First off, let's talk about the Puppet. Everyone everywhere who knows anything about FNAF has been craving this guy's story. But what if we already know it? What if it's been right under our noses the whole time? I propose to you, the FNAF Community, that The Puppet is in fact possessed by Henry No-Last-Name-Given's son. The very son that was William Afton's first victim, and drove Henry to let Circus Baby out of her box (now that I think of it, how'd Baby end up back in Anamatronic Alcatraz anyway?) to kill him. Let's look at the facts: it's been all but confirmed that The Puppet was The Purple Guy's first kill, and it's been said that Henry's son was Afton's first victim. So, it should be pretty obvious who's been pulling the Puppet's strings.

Next, let's talk Afton. Personally, I think he only killed five kids, with their bodies never being found, which of course led to Afton getting off and skipping town, only to return years later as a bad copy of himself. But what if Afton didn't skip town? What if he was literally right under everyone's noses? I propose that sometime between Afton getting off for killing those first five kids and his return. Sister Location happened, and the "Afton" who returned to kill those next six kids was in fact Ennard.

So, what are your thoughts on my theories?

[JW12345 (Exotic Butters):]

under the puppet's mask is a endo head

[JenkoRun]

Remember the child you see pink guy kill in the FNAF 2 minigame?, that's the kid that possessed the Puppet.

[The Everygamer]

Exactly! It's Henry's son's murder that's reenacted in 8-Bit!

[JW12345 (Exotic Butters):]

10/10 theory

[Mitchell Man]

HighKings_Ruin původně napsal:

Remember the child you see pink guy kill in the FNAF 2 minigame?, that's the kid that possessed the Puppet.

bcain56308 původně napsal:

Exactly! It's Henry's son's murder that's reenacted in 8-Bit!

I am not even gonna comment on that one because Silver Eyes is NOT canon, it's a reimagining of the story and also, why is people still at this when clearly it's not canon and has no official part of the lore!

[JenkoRun]

Also, your theory on Ennard being in Afton's skin has been officially debunked with the new Cutscenes introduced in the Custom Night's.

Ennard leaves Micheal's skin after a few days due to the skin decaying.

[The Everygamer]

Oh... Well, at least I've still got my Puppet therory.

[Lord Egg]

miguimitchell původně napsal:

HighKings_Ruin původně napsal:

Remember the child you see pink guy kill in the FNAF 2 minigame?, that's the kid that possessed the Puppet.

bcain56308 původně napsal:

Exactly! It's Henry's son's murder that's reenacted in 8-Bit!

I am not even gonna comment on that one because Silver Eyes is NOT canon, it's a reimagining of the story and also, why is people still at this when clearly it's not canon and has no official part of the lore!

It can be used as reference material though

[Mitchell Man]

The Santadragonninja původně napsal:

miguimitchell původně napsal:

I am not even gonna comment on that one because Silver Eyes is NOT canon, it's a reimagining of the story and also, why is people still at this when clearly it's not canon and has no official part of the lore!

It can be used as reference material though

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H91rPIq2mN4

[Lord Egg]

miguimitchell původně napsal:

The Santadragonninja původně napsal:

It can be used as reference material though

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H91rPIq2mN4

William was in the games and book
The murders happened in the games and the book
The two cannons connect at some points, the book and games are realated, while your theory for the games can't only contain evidence from the book, it can contain some evidence.

Sammy's death was clearly the book version of the save them minigame

[Mitchell Man]

The Santadragonninja původně napsal:

miguimitchell původně napsal:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H91rPIq2mN4

William was in the games and book
The murders happened in the games and the book
The two cannons connect at some points, the book and games are realated, while your theory for the games can't only contain evidence from the book, it can contain some evidence.

Sammy's death was clearly the book version of the save them minigame

I haven't read the book so I mean I read some of it but I think the games and book are a different thing by means it is a separate continuity.

[Varian Parryin']

Your first theory is quite interesting. But I'm not sure if Henry really exists in game universe. We didn't hear about the person like him in the games.

Second one... Well... The SL protagonist is Michael, not William, so... Nothing more to speak about.

[Lord Egg]

Wour de Luck původně napsal:

Your first theory is quite interesting. But I'm not sure if Henry really exists in game universe. We didn't hear about the person like him in the games.

Second one... Well... The SL protagonist is Michael, not William, so... Nothing more to speak about.

1. He could be phone guy
2. -_-

[Salvation_crucifix]

miguimitchell původně napsal:

HighKings_Ruin původně napsal:

Remember the child you see pink guy kill in the FNAF 2 minigame?, that's the kid that possessed the Puppet.

bcain56308 původně napsal:

Exactly! It's Henry's son's murder that's reenacted in 8-Bit!

I am not even gonna comment on that one because Silver Eyes is NOT canon, it's a reimagining of the story and also, why is people still at this when clearly it's not canon and has no official part of the lore!

Um...William Afton, anyone? Watch Game Theory. And anyone who knows Scott knows that he, well, "bends the truth" a bit.

[Lord Egg]

chrisbutler2765 původně napsal:

miguimitchell původně napsal:

I am not even gonna comment on that one because Silver Eyes is NOT canon, it's a reimagining of the story and also, why is people still at this when clearly it's not canon and has no official part of the lore!

Um...William Afton, anyone?

That was an odd placing of the face palm