You know how Michael Afton's voice and the voice at the beginning of the game sound familiar?

[ImmenseAndrew]

I'm pretty sure if you go to Scott's voices.com profile, they're both voiced by PJ Heywood. Anyway, they sound extremely alike.

You may just think that it's because it's William Afton's son and that's why they sound alike, but they're too similar and sound exactly the same. What am I trying to get at? In the opening cutscene of the game, we're never told the first name of the person speaking--all he's called is "Mr. Afton."

What if "Mr. Afton" in the beginning of the game refers to Michael Afton?

(I'm probably extremely late on this, plz don't be mad)

[Chu]

Messaggio originale di ImmenseMudkipz:

Messaggio originale di Fredoi:

So according to you, Scott was killed by baby? 😑

There is a Scott Cawthon final boss that looks nothing like Desk Man, you know.

"Father, it's me, Micheal........they thought I was you...."

Do you really think that Scott looks like his avatar in real life? lol

Desk Man was the guy who made all the other mini games. I'm not sure how to word this exactly, but Scott was obviously the one making those games. Obviously, Scott didn't die, but I kinda like to think that there's this thing about Desk Man that makes him like Scott, but then somehow also like Henry, from the Silver Eyes. Henry was, after all, the one who made the animatronics for the pizzarias (William Afton handled all the financial stuff). Scott is technically the creator of Baby, along with every other thing Fazbear related in the game's series, but in the game's universe, Henry is also kind of that guy as he created all the animatronics. In the Silver Eyes, Henry is killed by his own animatronic (it might have been suicide, we don't really know). But anyway, he dies from his own animatronic, just like Desk Man does.

Another thing, it doesn't make sense if William Afton is Desk Man, because that would mean that Baby killed him and that he is dead.

Ok, no. Henry does not exist in the games universe. Notice how Henry was the one with the family in Silver Eyes and it's swapped around in game, it's the same with their other roles excluding the murdering part, lol. William afton created the animatronics in the games universe, there is no evidence of a Henry. Also, William is at the start of the sister location game talking about the design choices of baby, which a creator would know about.

Scott is represented as animdude.
Why would you say that he created the mini games when he specifically mentions baby, who is an animatronic and never seen in any minigames?

Yes it does make sense that he's William as in the
book, the creator of the animatronics was murdered by one of his creations. Also, fnaf world isn't cannon.

One more thing, the voice actor for William and Micheal has both of those names on his voices.com page.

[Dani]

Messaggio originale di MichaelO2000:

Acutely, if you go to the voice actor's profile bio, you'll see he has a list of the characters he's played. And he lists BOTH "Michael Afton" and "William Afton", they're two different characters

+

[Psyanide53]

Messaggio originale di ImmenseMudkipz:

Messaggio originale di VittiDubs:

Right now there are three Aftons that we know that exist in the universe: William, Michael and Willaim's daughter who is yet unnamed, therefore using logical reasoning based off of the evidence that we currently have, since Michael wasn't revealed until the end of the game, and it can't be the daughter, the logical conclusion is that the "Mr. Afton" they refer to at the beginning of the game is none other than William Afton.

And as Fredoi has been so kind to point out, there were only 3 Aftons who were voiced in the game: William and Michael, and the daughter (and the first two were played by the same guy but the point is there are only two male Aftons to choose from).

It's not necessarily the "logical conclusion." That could be the twist. Everyone assumes Mr. Afton to be William Afton, but when we're finally introduced to Michael Afton, it turns out that the character at the beginning was him.

That wouldn't make any sense, if we go based off of what you say then where did William's voice happen in the game if not in the beginning? The guy played the voice of two people: William and Michael. Again, we know Michael's voice speaks is at the end of the game, so logically, the Afton that speaks at the beginning of the game must be William. Its the first of only 2 times in the game that a male Afton speaks. Why is that so hard for you to accept?