I know what Charlie Has! Theory!

[Psyanide53]

Alright folks I have given this some thought and here is my theory on what Charlie has that Springtrap wants from her in the Twisted Ones Novel.

First let's rule out what it's NOT.

1) Biometrics. Springtrap isn't after her fingerprints, blood, eyeballs for retinal scanning, or voice for some kind of voice recognition, otherwise the animatronics would've just take her eyes, chopped off a hand, etc and then left the rest of her behind. No, instead, Freddy kidnapped her in her entirety, alive.

2) Her knowledge of Henry. Sprintrap said specifically in the novel, "You have something that belongs to me." which indicates that what he wants from Charlie is an item - a physical thing. Therefore we can rule out some secret procedure that her father Henry performed or some memory that has to do with her father.

3) A Place that She Knows. We can rule out that what Springtrap is look for is a place that Charlie may know because since the storm that ripped through the town - every place that Charlie knows of from her childhood has been horrifically damage, and after the book - everything becomes damaged beyond repair. Even though she has a photographic memory and there may be some place we have not visited yet - there is no indication given from Springtrap that he wants Charlie to lead him somewhere.

So what is it? Quite simple. It's Theodore.

There are clues pointing to why this is the item Springtrap is looking for and I'm going to explain to back up my theory.

First and most obvious. It's Plushtrap and we all know it. Plushtrap always has a connection to Springtrap - it's his Minime.

Second, Theodore is mentioned so often in this book he might as well be a main character. Scott might as well have put a flashing red sign up that said THIS IS THE THING SPRINGY WANTS! Charlie even takes his head with her to go face the animatronic's alone and talks to him, he is that important.

But most thought provoking of all, why would Henry give his daughter a golden bunny doll, if Afton was the character who wore the golden bunny suit? Why not a mini Golden Freddy doll that says "I love you" after the mascot he wore?

My theory is that Henry found out William doing something dastardly and stole whatever it was he was working on, then hid it in Theodore, and put it the one place Afton would never suspect: his daughter's own toy. While Springtrap was stuffed into that crawl space behind Pirate's Cove, he had plenty of time to think over where Henry might have stashed what he wanted, and when the storm released his animatronics yet they didn't find Theodore in the house, he knew that he had to find Charlie as she would have no doubt have been the one to take her beloved doll.

So what are your thoughts on this?? I would love to hear your ideas and theories!

[Witt]

Originally posted by VittiDubs:

Alright folks I have given this some thought and here is my theory on what Charlie has that Springtrap wants from her in the Twisted Ones Novel.

First let's rule out what it's NOT.

1) Biometrics. Springtrap isn't after her fingerprints, blood, eyeballs for retinal scanning, or voice for some kind of voice recognition, otherwise the animatronics would've just take her eyes, chopped off a hand, etc and then left the rest of her behind. No, instead, Freddy kidnapped her in her entirety, alive.

2) Her knowledge of Henry. Sprintrap said specifically in the novel, "You have something that belongs to me." which indicates that what he wants from Charlie is an item - a physical thing. Therefore we can rule out some secret procedure that her father Henry performed or some memory that has to do with her father.

3) A Place that She Knows. We can rule out that what Springtrap is look for is a place that Charlie may know because since the storm that ripped through the town - every place that Charlie knows of from her childhood has been horrifically damage, and after the book - everything becomes damaged beyond repair. Even though she has a photographic memory and there may be some place we have not visited yet - there is no indication given from Springtrap that he wants Charlie to lead him somewhere.

So what is it? Quite simple. It's Theodore.

There are clues pointing to why this is the item Springtrap is looking for and I'm going to explain to back up my theory.

First and most obvious. It's Plushtrap and we all know it. Plushtrap always has a connection to Springtrap - it's his Minime.

Second, Theodore is mentioned so often in this book he might as well be a main character. Scott might as well have put a flashing red sign up that said THIS IS THE THING SPRINGY WANTS! Charlie even takes his head with her to go face the animatronic's alone and talks to him, he is that important.

But most thought provoking of all, why would Henry give his daughter a golden bunny doll, if Afton was the character who wore the golden bunny suit? Why not a mini Golden Freddy doll that says "I love you" after the mascot he wore?

My theory is that Henry found out William doing something dastardly and stole whatever it was he was working on, then hid it in Theodore, and put it the one place Afton would never suspect: his daughter's own toy. While Springtrap was stuffed into that crawl space behind Pirate's Cove, he had plenty of time to think over where Henry might have stashed what he wanted, and when the storm released his animatronics yet they didn't find Theodore in the house, he knew that he had to find Charlie as she would have no doubt have been the one to take her beloved doll.

So what are your thoughts on this?? I would love to hear your ideas and theories!

WILLIAM IS SO AWFUL!!! HE WANTS TO STEAL A PLUSH!!! Such a great character.

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by Coffy™:

WILLIAM IS SO AWFUL!!! HE WANTS TO STEAL A PLUSH!!! Such a great character.

Once he has that plush he can control the world man! Every animatronic will be under his control! ANIMATRONIC ARMAGEDDON WILL DESCEND! REPENT! REPENT!

And it's more of like, broken into pieces now, and the head is in one place and the body parts are still in Charlie's dorm - so now it's like some friggin scavenger hunt quests. #LAME

[SenshiOfSadness]

Why kidnapping Charlie if he could threaten/ask where it is?

Is something inside Charlie's body, a part of her mechanical body (I believe that she's a soul in a robotic body). In other words, Charlie is going to undergo unconsented surgery (not that this isn't new to her).

[Witt]

Originally posted by SenshiOfSadness:

Why kidnapping Charlie if he could threaten/ask where it is?

Is something inside Charlie's body, a part of her mechanical body (I believe that she's a soul in a robotic body). In other words, Charlie is going to undergo unconsented surgery (not that this isn't new to her).

Every time you talk about Charlie, I know how it will end ;)

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by SenshiOfSadness:

Why kidnapping Charlie if he could threaten/ask where it is?

Is something inside Charlie's body, a part of her mechanical body (I believe that she's a soul in a robotic body). In other words, Charlie is going to undergo unconsented surgery (not that this isn't new to her).

I'm hoping that you can elaborate on this theory that you have a bit as I have a couple counter arguments to it.

Springtrap didn't have a lot of time to threaten or ask her where "it" was, considering he was stuck in Pirate's Cove, and when he got out there was the chase and the fight after he had a brief amount of time to reveal that he was still alive and still an evil bastard.

Also, I have to disagree with you that Charlie is a robot as there is no concrete proof that she is one. She has aged like a normal human, eats, drinks, goes the bathroom, grows hair, cries, bleeds, etc which a robot certainly isn't capable of doing.

IF Afton put something inside of her against her will at a young age it would have had to have been something cybernetic and organic that didn't cause her white blood cells to attack it, otherwise her body would have rejected it and an infection would have started where it had been implanted. Doctor's would have had to do emergency surgery to remove it otherwise she would go into toxic shock or sepsis and die. This is the case with all foreign objects that enter the body that cannot be broken down and removed by the body's natural defenses.

But I would love to hear what you have to bring to the table.

[Sp00ky_Matt]

I give you props, you didn't relate the books to the games so good job

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by Matt:

I give you props, you didn't relate the books to the games so good job

Why thank you Matt, but you are still a Virgin. <3

[Bringin' Shreksy Back]

They want Charlie's skin, for baby

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by PsychoticSpade🎱:

They want Charlie's skin, for baby

I see you make joke, Commrade. But if raging animatronics only want skin of pretty girl, why not just take skin and leave her to rot in field and drag skin back to Bunny-Man?
No reason to take pretty girl alive if all you need is skin.
*drinks from vodka bottle*

[TheWolfman]

I think Charlie is a dude....

Honestly since those disks can alter what you see I think Charlie was kidnapped, Henry was killed by Will, then Jen was approached, told to keep Charlie and tell him she's a girl. He know thought he was a girl

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by eMSACHICK:

I think Charlie is a dude....

Honestly since those disks can alter what you see I think Charlie was kidnapped, Henry was killed by Will, then Jen was approached, told to keep Charlie and tell him she's a girl. He know thought he was a girl

Are you assuming Charlie's gender? When she is clearly described as a girl?

TRIGGERED !!!!!

[Connosu]

Theodore is purple right?

[Psyanide53]

Originally posted by Conn414:

Theodore is purple right?

I thought he was golden, but I may have to go back and read through TSE and verify his color here in a few.

[SenshiOfSadness]

Originally posted by VittiDubs:

Originally posted by SenshiOfSadness:

Why kidnapping Charlie if he could threaten/ask where it is?

Is something inside Charlie's body, a part of her mechanical body (I believe that she's a soul in a robotic body). In other words, Charlie is going to undergo unconsented surgery (not that this isn't new to her).

I'm hoping that you can elaborate on this theory that you have a bit as I have a couple counter arguments to it.

Springtrap didn't have a lot of time to threaten or ask her where "it" was, considering he was stuck in Pirate's Cove, and when he got out there was the chase and the fight after he had a brief amount of time to reveal that he was still alive and still an evil bastard.

Also, I have to disagree with you that Charlie is a robot as there is no concrete proof that she is one. She has aged like a normal human, eats, drinks, goes the bathroom, grows hair, cries, bleeds, etc which a robot certainly isn't capable of doing.

IF Afton put something inside of her against her will at a young age it would have had to have been something cybernetic and organic that didn't cause her white blood cells to attack it, otherwise her body would have rejected it and an infection would have started where it had been implanted. Doctor's would have had to do emergency surgery to remove it otherwise she would go into toxic shock or sepsis and die. This is the case with all foreign objects that enter the body that cannot be broken down and removed by the body's natural defenses.

But I would love to hear what you have to bring to the table.

Here's a video, look at the Charlie part, it's from the middle of it more or less (it fits my idea more or less): https://youtu.be/fyZcMlbB1Xg

Also in my theory for the whole lore located on the section Michael's Mechanical body: https://fnaflore.com/community/articles/theory/timeline-mega-theory-senshiofsadness/

Also about the body defenses, unless it is recognized by the body it can lay over there for a long time (titanium stuff for example).

Having a soul gives paranormal abilities like producing mucus and blood. (remember the FNAF 1 newspapers, the bodies have long been removed and they still leak blood).

And let's not forget that Scoot in this year's April fools mentioned terminator as the plot of the film.

[Psyanide53]

Oh God not the Black footed ferret *facepalm*

Okay here's what I have to debunk his "Charlie is a robot" theory: Robots don't bleed, robots don't have to go to the bathroom, they don't cry tears, and they don't age or grow which Charlie HAS done.

And I'm sorry but I have to disagree with you. Souls which are spiritual and incorporeal do NOT produce physical bodily functions such as: breathing, blood & fluids. The reason the animatronics from FNAF one are on a murderous and vengeful rampage, leaking of blood and mucus is because the children's bodies ARE STILL inside the suits. Remember from the newspaper clippings in the games "the bodies were never found" the newspapers never said the bodies were removed!

And no, again, I am a nurse. If a foreign body regardless of it's material make up enters your body that hasn't been medically sterilized and you aren't put on regular drugs to suppress your immune system to keep it from attacking the foreign body - you will get an infection, it will be found and you will have to have surgery to remove it or die.