About the Killer Being Caught

[WeltaChara]

As you may recall, in FNaF 1 there was a new article about the killer being caught, and after FNaF 2, we all thought this meant some guy was framed for it. Well, I'm going to provide an alternative theory.

What if the killer WAS caught. I mean, we now know that there are two Aftons, so what if the one who (I think) is purple guy, William Afton, WAS caught on tape and arrested. This would then tie in with the theory that Michael would then be sent by his father to the FNaF 1 location, be mistaken by the dead children to be William (hence why we see purple guy in the FNaF 3 minigames when we play as a dead child, and the line "but then, they thought I was you" said by Michael) and almost get killed by the springlocks ("I should be dead").

Note that this is just a thought I had and it isn't perfect, so lease let me know what you think.

[Rudy]

Good theory! I've been thinking about this myself and I've kinda came to the same conclusion.

[WeltaChara]

Originally posted by Savage:

Good theory! I've been thinking about this myself and I've kinda came to the same conclusion.

Thank.

[Witt]

Good theory...


That's all I have to say.

[Madame Bones]

This is good and backed up really well.

[N̸i̵g̴h̸t̸]

Nice theory, and just a little info on TFF, there is a page dedicated to the newspaper clippings and does in fact say that the killer was inprisoned and charged. And your theory fits perfectly with this, because Michael could of called William in the jail at on of those calling stations.

[Rollerwings]

That is a good theory and would explain why William had to send Michael to CBEaR instead of just going there himself.

One thing, though, if Willie was in jail at the time, how to explain the murder victims seen at the FNaF2 pizzeria?

Another thing, although William would likely have faced the death penalty for such heinous crimes, his sentence would probably not have been carried out anytime too soon. There's always the hope that an imprisoned, convicted killer will reveal the whereabouts of his victim's remains in exchange for better conditions in prison...or there's also the chance that he'll reveal them by talking to his fellow inmates, who then talk to the jail guards. It's happened!

[JustThatOneGuy13]

Who knows. Maybe he wanted to Free Baby inorder to break him out. In which the final game will take place in prison where William is locked up in Solitary Confinment with the guard having the key.

I doubt that Scott would have that important detail to just say that someone innocent was framed.

[the unknowable one]

well see, actually william was a killer, he killed the first child outside the diner, and its his fault his daughter and youngest son were dead

the "was it me" teaser in fnaf 4 was micheal questioning if it was really him, and then later asking

"was it you" realizing that his father had actually started building killer robots after that, because his father had fled,

the person they caught, referred to william killing the first child, micheal as we know from fnaf 3 and the end of fnaf SL, has not been caught and is now on a mission to find william.

so now baby and spring trap are doing one of 2 things

A-micheal is searching for william, and baby is searching for micheal to stop him before he kills the last living member of their family

B-they are both trying to kill william

[flightc0re]

Originally posted by dagonsTendril:

well see, actually william was a killer, he killed the first child outside the diner, and its his fault his daughter and youngest son were dead

the "was it me" teaser in fnaf 4 was micheal questioning if it was really him, and then later asking

"was it you" realizing that his father had actually started building killer robots after that, because his father had fled,

the person they caught, referred to william killing the first child, micheal as we know from fnaf 3 and the end of fnaf SL, has not been caught and is now on a mission to find william.

so now baby and spring trap are doing one of 2 things

A-micheal is searching for william, and baby is searching for micheal to stop him before he kills the last living member of their family

B-they are both trying to kill william

They're both coming for Wet Willie he's fuccd.

[the unknowable one]

well actually i think part A is more plausible because remember baby actually tried to save micheal but got scooped and ennard used her ability to pretend to lure micheal into the scooper

[the unknowable one]

baby never wanted us to die, she only wanted to stop ennard because ennard stopped listening to her and became desperate for freedom

[WeltaChara]

Originally posted by breadspy:

That is a good theory and would explain why William had to send Michael to CBEaR instead of just going there himself.

One thing, though, if Willie was in jail at the time, how to explain the murder victims seen at the FNaF2 pizzeria?

Another thing, although William would likely have faced the death penalty for such heinous crimes, his sentence would probably not have been carried out anytime too soon. There's always the hope that an imprisoned, convicted killer will reveal the whereabouts of his victim's remains in exchange for better conditions in prison...or there's also the chance that he'll reveal them by talking to his fellow inmates, who then talk to the jail guards. It's happened!

I imagine he would be caught after FNaF 2, but before FNaF 1.