Is the FNaF 4 Crying Child, Golden Freddy, or the Marionette?

[Labyrinth]

I think he is Shadow Freddy, personally, but he could be Golden Freddy because:
-He died at his birthday party, and the Happiest Day in FNaF 3 takes place at one
-He had his skull crushed in Fredbear's mouth, Fredbear was his favourite member of the Fazbear crew (Fredbear Plush), and Fredbear is Golden Freddy
-He can't be the Marionette because he wasn't killed by the Purple Guy, but by Fredbear, and the Marionette was killed by him (in the FNaF 2 Cupcake Minigame)

But he might be the Marionette because (but it's VERY unlikely):
-He wears a striped shirt (unlike the other children, who wear single-coloured shirts), it is black with grey lines (similiar to the Marionette's appearance), and in the minigame after Night 4, we see him lying on his knees in a position similiar to the Marionette's position in Mangle's Quest in FNaF 3

P.S. I still think he must be Shadow Freddy :)

[Squidward]

Yeah buuuut we gonna have to rule out him being golden Freddy mainly because the newspaper clippings in fnaf 1 say that 5 children were lead to the back room instead of 4 and the 5th child can't be the puppet because well he's the one that gave all 5 of the fnaf 1 animatronics life

[GhostMami]

The fnaf4 kid is shadow freddy

[Labyrinth]

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

The answer to that question is in Five nights at Freddy's The Silver Eyes

SPOILERS:
in the book it said that william afton killed henrys son sammy and he possessed golden freddy along with 4 other children and the FNAF 4 kid died of getting his headcrushed by fredbears mechanical jaw.

NUMBER 1, the novels are in a different universe from the games, MICHAEL BROOKS possessed Golden Freddy, not SAMMY

[DarkBat]

He could also be Nightmare

[Labyrinth]

Publicado originalmente por Squidward:

Yeah buuuut we gonna have to rule out him being golden Freddy mainly because the newspaper clippings in fnaf 1 say that 5 children were lead to the back room instead of 4 and the 5th child can't be the puppet because well he's the one that gave all 5 of the fnaf 1 animatronics life

NUMBER 2, The FNaF 4 Crying Child died at his birthday party, AND, the Marionette was possessed by the Crying Child who got murdered OUTSIDE of the Diner

[Labyrinth]

Publicado originalmente por FuntimeCharlie:

The fnaf4 kid is shadow freddy

NUMBER 3, why would he be Shadow Freddy/Nightmare instead of Golden Freddy/Fredbear, AND BTW, if you didn't know, Nightmare is real, and why would that Child possess Nightmare, if he thinks it's all a dream

[Labyrinth]

Oh, and are you saying that he might be Shadow Freddy from the FNaF 3 minigames? Well, we know that the Marionette is not there in the first game (probably), but Golden Freddy is, and somehow there are FIVE children cornering Michael Afton (But there is a SLIGHT possibilty that the fifth child is Shadow Freddy)

P.S. Shadow Freddy has nothing to do with the other games (excluding FNaF 2, FNaF 3 and FNaF 4)

[Metbert]

I think he is Nightmare ... and then outside the nightmare become Shadow Freddy.

Anyway just theories.

[Metbert]

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

Publicado originalmente por XeroZeph:

NUMBER 1, the novels are in a different universe from the games, MICHAEL BROOKS possessed Golden Freddy, not SAMMY

Scott said the book is cannon but not too much like a puzzle piece

The book is canon, but it happen in a different universe where some events aren't the same of the game... without knowledge about what is the same and what's not... all the informations from the book aren't solid proofs for a theory, you can still use them... but like I said, they aren't so strong points.

[Dani]

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

The answer to that question is in Five nights at Freddy's The Silver Eyes

SPOILERS:
In the book it said that William Afton killed Henry's son Sammy and he possessed golden freddy along with 4 other children and the FNAF 4 kid died of getting his headcrushed by fredbears mechanical jaw.

Silver Eyes isn't canon to the game timeline, so none of this should be treated as factual evidence for solving the games.

Also, Michael Brooks possessed Golden Freddy, not Sammy.

[GhostMami]

Publicado originalmente por XeroZeph:

Publicado originalmente por FuntimeCharlie:

The fnaf4 kid is shadow freddy

NUMBER 3, why would he be Shadow Freddy/Nightmare instead of Golden Freddy/Fredbear, AND BTW, if you didn't know, Nightmare is real, and why would that Child possess Nightmare, if he thinks it's all a dream

Nightmare and Shadow Freddy are the same thing yes they are real there phantoms they are not real suits or robots

[Lord Egg]

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

Publicado originalmente por Kat-Kun:

Silver Eyes isn't canon to the game timeline, so none of this should be treated as factual evidence for solving the games.

Also, Michael Brooks possessed Golden Freddy, not Sammy.

Evidence?

Carlton litteraly points at golden freddy and says "thats Micheal"

[Lord Egg]

I believe he posseses mangle (please don't kill me)

[Labyrinth]

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

2. You can stop with the capitals and numbers now.

Ok

[Labyrinth]

Publicado originalmente por Kat-Kun:

Publicado originalmente por Mr.Feels:

The answer to that question is in Five nights at Freddy's The Silver Eyes

SPOILERS:
In the book it said that William Afton killed Henry's son Sammy and he possessed golden freddy along with 4 other children and the FNAF 4 kid died of getting his headcrushed by fredbears mechanical jaw.

Silver Eyes isn't canon to the game timeline, so none of this should be treated as factual evidence for solving the games.

Also, Michael Brooks possessed Golden Freddy, not Sammy.

I said that 2 hours ago, in a comment here!