Steam telepítése
belépés
|
nyelv
简体中文 (egyszerűsített kínai)
繁體中文 (hagyományos kínai)
日本語 (japán)
한국어 (koreai)
ไทย (thai)
Български (bolgár)
Čeština (cseh)
Dansk (dán)
Deutsch (német)
English (angol)
Español - España (spanyolországi spanyol)
Español - Latinoamérica (latin-amerikai spanyol)
Ελληνικά (görög)
Français (francia)
Italiano (olasz)
Bahasa Indonesia (indonéz)
Nederlands (holland)
Norsk (norvég)
Polski (lengyel)
Português (portugáliai portugál)
Português - Brasil (brazíliai portugál)
Română (román)
Русский (orosz)
Suomi (finn)
Svenska (svéd)
Türkçe (török)
Tiếng Việt (vietnámi)
Українська (ukrán)
Fordítási probléma jelentése
Hozzászólási szabályok és irányelvek
73 
Hozzászólás jelentése
Thank you!
or maybe he fell in one of those passages and broke his neck.
And Edith's mum realized it and sealed up the rooms to prevent another death.
It would've been nice, but then Walter wouldn't have reason to freak out like that. He mentions in his letter about "whatever killed barbara", and apparently thinks it ia literally a monster
The developer mentioned in an interview that Milton actually "took a door to another dimension". Though don't take it too serious since it's pretty much an easteregg relating to another game they did called The Unfinished Swan.
As for Kumar, Dawn and lastly Edi, there's no real know in the game that i know off put personally it could be a slow-killing and contagious illness like HIV, but of course that's a pretty long shot and rather unlikely. It would explain why Dawn and Edi could see their death coming even if it was inevitable. There is the possibility that Edi died during child birth, but since her words very much read like she had at least some time with him and didn't write them in a hurry, i doubt she had written those while dying on the childbed.
No, she definitely died. What strikes me the most about her death is whatever it was was enough for Walter to be traumatized enough to baracade himself in the basement for literally years. If she simply disappeared I'm not sure that would be enough. In my mind he witnessed her murder, whether it was from her boyfriend, or someone else.
-Molly: Possible combination of things. Either the holly, or possibly some poisonous mushrooms. She definitely started hallucinating after eating whatever it was. The part about her choking on the mother rabbit, and holding her breath for a very long time makes me think death by suffocation.
-Barbara: Not sure. Possibly killed by her psychopathic boyfriend. It did say he was her biggest fan, and he could've been completely nuts. She kicked him out and he may have not taken it well. The comic said her trip to a comic convention got cancelled because her father was injured, so I dunno how a group of fans killed her. Only an ear remained, yet she has a grave site? Did they bury the single ear there in a coffin? Weird.
-Calvin: He flew off a cliff into either the rocks below, or possibly the water. He had a broken leg, so he couldn't swim. So he possibly drowned.
-Gregory: Drowned in the bathtub. Sad.
-Gus: Either killed by the flying debris/tent, or was struck by lightning. Either is a possibility. The poem did say the thunder was much closer, but the father just said to turn the music louder. AND he was flying a kite during a thunder storm. Idiot.
-Sam: Got knocked off a cliff by a deer and probably died from the fall.
-Milton: Disappeared. A dev claims he really did go through a magic door and wound up in their other game "The Unfinished Swan", but on closer inspection of his room I found a wide bristle paint brush next to the door that could've painted the door. There's gold shoe prints going from the 2nd floor of the castle down to the painted door, and then they disappear at the door. Why would he do this? There's no sign of a puddle of paint on the floor where he stepped in it, then proceeded to the door. So he clearly did this intentionally. I think he took his shoes off, painted the bottoms gold, then proceeded to actually plant fake footprints leading to the fake door. Also, the flipbook shows Milton making a flipbook and he plays back his own flipbook in the flipbook, which shows him painting the door and going through it. This leads me to believe that Milton drew the flipbook, left it behind, and also painted the door, handle, left the gold footprints, then he snuck away from the house in bare feet so as not to disturb anyone or leave gold foot prints anywhere, washed the gold off somewhere, put his shoes back on and ran away from home in fear of the same curse that got other family members. He had access to all the secret cooridoors and read about all his dead relatives. So he probably ran away. Whether or not he's still alive, I have no idea.
-Walter: People still claim he got run over by a train. However, his little room was right above train tracks. The daily earthquakes were trains passing by. They just suddenly stopped one day after being in use for every day for 30 years. Why so suddenly? It was a week or so of complete silence and no earthquakes, so he finally left his room and walked down the tracks. However, it doesn't really say what actually happened to him. I know the game has train lights and a train sound and there's a little memorial thing next to the tracks where he possibly died, but the guy was obsessed with trains, so maybe that was all fictional. Maybe the monster he had been hiding from was actually the family curse, and he finally left his room only to drop dead of a heart attack right on the spot. I know there's train track debris and a drop off. Maybe the trains stopped because of that. So why would a train be going through there if they knew there was no track left?
-Lewis: Some say decapitated, but I don't know if you can put your head into the tiny blade area that chops off a fish head. Also that last area we travelled along a conveyer belt. Perhaps he hopped onto the conveyer belt that takes the salmon to the next place where they're processed further, as in being ground up and canned? So he fell into the grinder. Nasty thought.
-Edie (Edith Sr.): Drug overdose. I know this is a stretch, but if you look near her bed there's bottles full of medications, yet one of them is laying on it's side completely empty. Dawn states that several of Edie's meds say not to drink alcohol while on these meds. People die from meds and alcohol mixing all the damn time. So either overdose or alcohol and med combining.
-Dawn: Died from cancer. She got better for a while, meaning it went into remission, but then she got worse again. All too familiar chain of events here.
-Edith: I've gone around and around with this one, but upon finding out her birthday and the date of her death, when they left the house, and when she revisited the house, I really can't deny it was death by childbirth. She wrote everything her son read while she was sitting on her bed in the house during her visit when she was 17 years old and 22 weeks pregnant with her son. And she was still 17 when she died, only a month away from turning 18. From how she wrote it, it seems like she never meant for him to read the journal until after she died. I guess it was given to him when his foster parents or caretakers felt he was old enough to handle reading it and visiting her grave site at the house.
Barbara - scared to death from a joint prank gone wrong by her boyfriend and their friends. It fits with the theme and story of her segment (she was trying to act scared and scream, her boyfriend tries to help her by scaring her, gets booted out the door but neglects to tell her there were other people in on it). The urban legend of the girl scared to death is also a common one (staked dress in graveyard). Angry mob and psycho killer just sounds too fantastical to be true.
Milton - meets an untimely end exploring some remote region of the house. Gets injured and unable to seek help. Fits with the magic door theme of exploration.
From the game developer's standpoint, I think Barbara was just a tongue-in-cheek reference to the 'final girl' in slasher pics. "They're coming to get you Barbara!" from Night of the Living Dead, the Halloween theme music in her segment, and her birth and death date both being October 31st.
Odin, Molly, Calvin, Sam, Walter, Gregory, Gus, Lewis, Dawn and Edie were pretty straight forward, though in most cases I don't believe they happened exactly like they were presented in the game, where embellishing and mythologizing the truth is a major theme. And keep in mind none of the books could have kept a detailed account right up to their respective demises and most of the causes of death were probably reconstructed after the bodies were discovered.
Being scared to death makes no sense. Her ear is in the music box for a reason. Throughout the entire story there is radio commentary about a psycho killer with a hook, she fights him "mysteriously" only after she's kicked her boyfriend out. It's very clear to be one of two things; A) her boyfriend was the killer and radio pieces are meant to signify that or even possibly her subconscious knowledge that her BF is a stalking psycho or B) there really was a killer around and they got to their house. This is a pretty common stalker theme with celebrities clearly alluded to through the BF. There's also the aspect of her brother being scared to death by what he heard/saw and mentally breaking afterward.
The mob thing is silly too. No child star who was known for a scream has an entire group of rabid enough fans to mob and kill them. The scared to death thingmight work if it weren't for those two things though, her brother being scared into psychosis and her ear in the music box.
I don't think Walter is nearly as confusing people are trying to make it to be either. The timeline seems to be getting messed up with a few people. Yes, there's no trains and rubble on the track in the present when Edith gets there, but that doesn't mean it was like that when Walter died. More than likely the track was closed *because* he died there. It's possible it was barely used at that point and his recollection was foggy, or it was still being used just far less frequently and he got hit by one of the few trains still operating there.
Walter apparently saw something horrible that night that scarred him for life to the point where he lived in a bunker/cave under the house. He was so afraid of it that instead of leaving the logical way, which is through the door to the house, he instead broke down a wall with a sledge hammer to escape his personal prison. He either saw a serial killer hack and slash his sister, or he saw an actual manifestation of the curse in monster form.
It's also possible that Walter was told about the curse when his father got injured on the saw. Maybe Edie even exclaimed, "It's the curse!" when it happened. So that night he was both afraid of the curse and his sister's killer, and then was scarred when he saw or heard it happen while he was hiding under his bed.
Remember, the comics aren't necessarily all true, most of them were probably made up based around urban legends of how Barbara died. It's possible that the ear in the music box was fake too, and while I'm no police detective or anything, I'd assume that they'd take the entire music box, but in the house it's still there.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I do think that this theory still stands.
A quote from the article the wiki refers to:
The amount of fluoride in a tube of fluoride toothpaste is sufficient to kill a child.
It is told that she had "disappeared" after Dawn and Edith left the house and when they sent a van from a nursing home for Edie. She was just not there.
Now, if you think about it, while we were wandering in the cemetery, we saw that Edie had a gravestone with her date of death written on it. How is that possible when Edith stated many times that Dawn and she had never came back to the house after that last night?
My assumption is that it was Edie who put her gravestone there. She was most probably the one who in the first place designed all the other tombstones there, considering that she was very much into keeping symbols of her family members' deaths. And her tombstone was exactly in the same style with the others there, symbolizing herself with an open book shape on top of it, a resemblance to the stories she has collected and immortalized of the deaths of her family members.
I like to think that her body was not found when the van from the nursing home came. Explaining why it is mentioned as a "disappearance" rather than just that she was "dead". Then she decided that she can't live anywhere else, as the house was literally her whole life and history. So she got her tombstone made (It was maybe only the date that was lacking and the tombstone was prepared before?) and put it just besides Sven's and went to the sea, swimmimg towards the old house resulting with her drowning. This also gives the story about her trip to the old house on Edith's birth date a meaning and explains why her body was not found immediately, resulting with her "disappearance". I can't see anyother way such an old lady might disappear unless she has gone to the sea.
The word used was not "disappeared". The correct quote would be, "she has already gone." It's quite common to use the term "gone" as leaving this world as in death, not every expression have to be taken so literally here.
I'd assume that it's possible that Edie had already prepared her tombstone way ahead of time considering her view almost on the verge of celebrating death. But I doubt that it was her that put in the date afterwards. She's 97 years old on a walker, using chair lift to ascend stairs in her own home. How would she climb the hill to the cemetery? Or for her to chisel a stone from night to morning?
It's more likely that Dawn goes back to the house without telling Edith. There are signs of her doing so as well, the fence at the very beginning was bended and Edith said that there must have been someone else who trespass before. Moreover, both Lewis and Edie's room was sealed. Who would have sealed those doors but Dawn. Lewis door might be sealed in the last day, but I doubt Dawn would seal Edie's door that night.
While I doubt that she went to the sea in that last night, I agree with your interpretation of her trip to the original house. Most likely she was in a delirious period at the time, fantasizing of the sea receding so far. When she write about the fog that came down that caused her to get turned around, it wasn't fog that happen, it was a wave pushing her back to the shore. She fainted and had a vision of reaching the house, of someone waiting there turning on the light, probably symbolizing that she was almost dead and go into the light that day.
See the correlation here, Grandma Edie, during her bout of fantasy, almost died of drowning herself. Lewis, during his bout of fantasy, decided to chop off his head. That was the reason Dawn decided to go away. So that Edith doesn't get infected with Edie's fantasy, that had killed both of her son (arguably Milton missing was also because he liked to imagine stuff). That was the reason Dawn was so furious for Edith to read another one of Edie's story.