What Remains of Edith Finch

What Remains of Edith Finch

View Stats:
happyskunky Jun 18, 2022 @ 1:11pm
To the very very few people leaving a bad review
You must REALLY REALLY all be absolute peaches to deal with and be around in real life ! jesus christ
< >
Showing 31-45 of 48 comments
kangirigungi Mar 12, 2023 @ 9:59am 
Originally posted by Niob:
I mean there are objective negative points to made:

Only full HD available
Fair point, but that's a minute technical detail, and not something that would warrant a negative review of an indie game. I mean, it still has more detailed graphics than many indie games.

Originally posted by Niob:
Very narrow field of view with no slider to change (makes it unplayable for a good chunk of people because of motion sickness)
Again, fair point.

Originally posted by Niob:
No manual saves
As linear this game is, there is no need for them. Most adventure games nowdays don't have manual saves.

Originally posted by Niob:
Extreme pop in outside
I don't understand that, sorry.

Originally posted by Niob:
Pretty pricey for a 2 hour game
That's not objective. I can totally understand someone finding it too expensive, but that's still a subjective point, as other people might find that it's worth it.
Flickmann Mar 12, 2023 @ 10:12am 
Originally posted by kangirigungi:
Originally posted by Niob:
I mean there are objective negative points to made:

Only full HD available
Fair point, but that's a minute technical detail, and not something that would warrant a negative review of an indie game. I mean, it still has more detailed graphics than many indie games.

Originally posted by Niob:
Very narrow field of view with no slider to change (makes it unplayable for a good chunk of people because of motion sickness)
Again, fair point.

Originally posted by Niob:
No manual saves
As linear this game is, there is no need for them. Most adventure games nowdays don't have manual saves.

Originally posted by Niob:
Extreme pop in outside
I don't understand that, sorry.

Originally posted by Niob:
Pretty pricey for a 2 hour game
That's not objective. I can totally understand someone finding it too expensive, but that's still a subjective point, as other people might find that it's worth it.

Only extremely financially irresponsible people would find the price point of this game worth it. Thank goodness I got a refund.
c_Alien Mar 12, 2023 @ 12:30pm 
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Originally posted by kangirigungi:
Fair point, but that's a minute technical detail, and not something that would warrant a negative review of an indie game. I mean, it still has more detailed graphics than many indie games.


Again, fair point.


As linear this game is, there is no need for them. Most adventure games nowdays don't have manual saves.


I don't understand that, sorry.


That's not objective. I can totally understand someone finding it too expensive, but that's still a subjective point, as other people might find that it's worth it.

Only extremely financially irresponsible people would find the price point of this game worth it. Thank goodness I got a refund.
So... I take it you bought the game for the full non-sales price, you were surprised that it was so short, which means you didn't care to read any reviews. And then you abused the refund system to undo your series of wrong decisions?
And that is what you call "financial responsibility"?
Or am I interpreting too much into your short statement?
Niob Mar 13, 2023 @ 8:57am 
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Niob:
Extreme pop in outside

I don't understand that, sorry.

Stand in front of the house and see how it loads the hd textures if you get closer
kangirigungi Mar 13, 2023 @ 12:57pm 
Originally posted by Niob:
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Niob:
Extreme pop in outside

I don't understand that, sorry.

Stand in front of the house and see how it loads the hd textures if you get closer
No, I've played the game several times, but I haven't noticed, or at least it didn't bother me enough to remember it. But someone who gives a negative review based on that and screen resolution shouldn't even consider buying an indie game and they would spare themselves a guaranteed disappointment.
Gelfan_Dothea Mar 13, 2023 @ 4:49pm 
The game is worth about $10. If you paid more it's a bad game. If you paid less it's a good game. You can pretty much leave it at that.
Flickmann Mar 14, 2023 @ 12:34am 
Originally posted by :
Originally posted by Flickmann:

Only extremely financially irresponsible people would find the price point of this game worth it. Thank goodness I got a refund.
So... I take it you bought the game for the full non-sales price, you were surprised that it was so short, which means you didn't care to read any reviews. And then you abused the refund system to undo your series of wrong decisions?
And that is what you call "financial responsibility"?
Or am I interpreting too much into your short statement?
Yes, you're interpreting far too much to try and justify your own crappy decisions. I bought it on a sale, was still disappointed, and finished it within two hours to claim my refund fairly. No "abuse" involved.
The game is just crap. Deal with it.
c_Alien Mar 14, 2023 @ 2:05am 
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Originally posted by :
So... I take it you bought the game for the full non-sales price, you were surprised that it was so short, which means you didn't care to read any reviews. And then you abused the refund system to undo your series of wrong decisions?
And that is what you call "financial responsibility"?
Or am I interpreting too much into your short statement?
Yes, you're interpreting far too much to try and justify your own crappy decisions. I bought it on a sale, was still disappointed, and finished it within two hours to claim my refund fairly. No "abuse" involved.
The game is just crap. Deal with it.
Yeah, that's what I expected. It must have been good enough for you to finish it. You took all it had to offer and still refunded it, which means you abused the system. Then you came to this forum to troll. Tells me a lot about your personality.
No more questions...
Last edited by c_Alien; Mar 14, 2023 @ 2:09am
Flickmann Mar 14, 2023 @ 4:25am 
Originally posted by :
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Yes, you're interpreting far too much to try and justify your own crappy decisions. I bought it on a sale, was still disappointed, and finished it within two hours to claim my refund fairly. No "abuse" involved.
The game is just crap. Deal with it.
Yeah, that's what I expected. It must have been good enough for you to finish it. You took all it had to offer and still refunded it, which means you abused the system. Then you came to this forum to troll. Tells me a lot about your personality.
No more questions...

lmao cope harder dude.
PewienCzlowiek Mar 14, 2023 @ 5:40am 
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Originally posted by :
Yeah, that's what I expected. It must have been good enough for you to finish it. You took all it had to offer and still refunded it, which means you abused the system. Then you came to this forum to troll. Tells me a lot about your personality.
No more questions...

lmao cope harder dude.
So you're saying, that refunding short games after finishing them, is definitely an intended use for steam's refund system
WakkaBlitzBallChamp Mar 14, 2023 @ 11:07am 
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Originally posted by :
So... I take it you bought the game for the full non-sales price, you were surprised that it was so short, which means you didn't care to read any reviews. And then you abused the refund system to undo your series of wrong decisions?
And that is what you call "financial responsibility"?
Or am I interpreting too much into your short statement?
Yes, you're interpreting far too much to try and justify your own crappy decisions. I bought it on a sale, was still disappointed, and finished it within two hours to claim my refund fairly. No "abuse" involved.
The game is just crap. Deal with it.

We have a key moment of the pure hater in this statement. The game was bought on sale, after buying the game the individual was disappointed for the unknown reason, yet the individual still continued to play the game and finished it even thought he was disappointed prior that. Why waste the time with the game you don't like?
As I have already stated, no matter how much haters will try to downgrade this game, the overall rating won't change because majority of people think it is an awesome game.
The game is great. Deal with it.
Flickmann Mar 14, 2023 @ 12:02pm 
Originally posted by PewienCzlowiek:
Originally posted by Flickmann:

lmao cope harder dude.
So you're saying, that refunding short games after finishing them, is definitely an intended use for steam's refund system
As per Steam's official policy:

"You can request a refund for nearly any purchase on Steam—for any reason. Maybe your PC doesn't meet the hardware requirements; maybe you bought a game by mistake; maybe you played the title for an hour and just didn't like it.

It doesn't matter. Valve will, upon request via help.steampowered.com, issue a refund for any reason, if the request is made within the required return period, and, in the case of games, if the title has been played for less than two hours."

Cope harder.



Originally posted by WakkaBlitzBallChamp:
Originally posted by Flickmann:
Yes, you're interpreting far too much to try and justify your own crappy decisions. I bought it on a sale, was still disappointed, and finished it within two hours to claim my refund fairly. No "abuse" involved.
The game is just crap. Deal with it.

We have a key moment of the pure hater in this statement. The game was bought on sale, after buying the game the individual was disappointed for the unknown reason, yet the individual still continued to play the game and finished it even thought he was disappointed prior that. Why waste the time with the game you don't like?
As I have already stated, no matter how much haters will try to downgrade this game, the overall rating won't change because majority of people think it is an awesome game.
The game is great. Deal with it.

If I played the game for less than two hours, you'd be saying I didn't play long enough to get a good enough idea of it. I generally play a game for an hour or two to get a feel for it. Just as I got a feel for this game, it ended.

Keep seething you two.
PewienCzlowiek Mar 14, 2023 @ 12:25pm 
I didn't ask you, if refunding 2h long game is allowed - of course it is, I asked whether you think that's intended function, or just a side effect of the system workings.
Flickmann Mar 14, 2023 @ 1:03pm 
Since the text clearly states "for any reason," and "it doesn't matter," yes, it is the intended function. Why are you trying desperately to cause drama? Nothing better to do?
kangirigungi Mar 14, 2023 @ 1:36pm 
Originally posted by Gelfan_Dothea:
The game is worth about $10. If you paid more it's a bad game. If you paid less it's a good game. You can pretty much leave it at that.
Whether you asked for a refund or not, whether you think that it's worth $5 or $10 or whatever, it's still a subjective merit. I bought it on sale (as I do most games), yet I think it's still worth full price. There is no objective merit of how much an hour of entertainment worth. If you like it, you'll spend more time around it than the pure play time. If you don't, well that's too bad for you, nothing to see here, move along.
Last edited by kangirigungi; Mar 14, 2023 @ 1:36pm
< >
Showing 31-45 of 48 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jun 18, 2022 @ 1:11pm
Posts: 48