is it better than silent hunter 3?

[Vilkas]

is it better than silent hunter 3 with GWX3 ? Asking for my dad who plays SH3 since 2006

[MeowThai]

much better

[Pruciak]

Not a hardcore SH3 player but Uboat is better in my opinion.

[dbond1]

Another long time subsimmer who reveres SH3 and SH4 here. But I prefer UBOAT for many reasons. Personal preference really. I won't say which is 'better', as that is subjective. But I do prefer this game over those at this point.

[XLjedi]

ALAAAAAAaaarm! CRASH DIVE!!!

I'm gonna run deep now to avoid the barrage of thread depth charging this is going to endure.

[Bang Bang Feuer Frei]

Depends on what you see as "better". The graphics? Yeah, sure. No surprise really. The models of the boats? Sure, again. Fully modeled inside and you can walk from bow to stern. A lot more systems of the boats are usable, too, and have to be used or not depending on your realism settings. Is it more stable? Oh yes. It loads faster, savegames usually work and not only if you save on the surface with nobody around you. Does it have more boats than SH3? Nope, so far only Types II and VII, in different versions, though. But no IX or XXI yet. The crew management also takes up more of your time than in any SH I have played. It all feels a bit more "in depth", you even have to make sure your boat is fully equipped before going out. The handling and operating of the boat is similar to SH which is no surprise, again, but still different in details.
So anyway, is it a good submarine game that brings you that commanding a WW2 German sub feeling? Yes, definitely. Is it more modern than SH3? Of course it is. Would I recommend it? Sure. Does it take some getting used to for someone who is an SH3 vet? Yes, I think so. But that can be rewarding. It can be customized in many ways. Last but not least, there are mods out for it as well, just have to check whether or not they work with the full release that is out now and getting updates.
Is it better than SH3 with GWX? That is up to you to decide.

[Bussard_x]

Yes it is better. A newer generation sub sim, 14 years between release (early access) with more options, better graphics and is easy modable. If you like Silent Hunter 3 you will absolutely love UBOAT.

[StuKa]

I think most would agree Uboat is the better game, although that doesn't mean SH doesn't have features that would be nice in Uboat.

Modded to vanilla is not a fair comparison either, considering the Uboat modding template isn't quite fixed yet, and therefore the vast majority of legacy mods can't be updated for full release yet.

$10 this is gonna get overrun by the "This game isn't Silent Hunter, therefore it's garbage" crowd.

[Raphx]

yes

[Bussard_x]

Currently playing UBOAT on 49" OLED 5120x1440. SH3 is max 1024x768, and does not run any more on my current machine. Yes SH3 is outdated but will not be forgotten, I gave the DVD package a special place in my vitrine as appreciation for many hours simming.

[er.tz]

The most importan thing to ask is; Where are the silent hunter developers?

Well, who knows.

Uboat has developers and modders, so it is and it will be an evolving creature for the better. SH is a dead project wich reached its limit long ago.

I have asked my IA about wich game is better and she told me that:

Which is better?

"Both games have their own strengths, and the choice between Uboat and Silent Hunter 3 will depend on individual preferences:

Uboat might be more attractive to those seeking a modern experience, with an emphasis on crew management and narrative elements, along with realism options that can adapt to various play styles.

Silent Hunter 3 remains a classic in the submarine simulation genre, ideal for players who prefer classic gameplay, greater simplicity in management, and an established community with numerous mods.

Both games offer unique and satisfying experiences, so the best approach is to try both and see which one best fits your play style."

[Madigan]

Originally posted by Bang Bang Feuer Frei:

Depends on what you see as "better". The graphics? Yeah, sure. No surprise really. The models of the boats? Sure, again. Fully modeled inside and you can walk from bow to stern. A lot more systems of the boats are usable, too, and have to be used or not depending on your realism settings. Is it more stable? Oh yes. It loads faster, savegames usually work and not only if you save on the surface with nobody around you. Does it have more boats than SH3? Nope, so far only Types II and VII, in different versions, though. But no IX or XXI yet. The crew management also takes up more of your time than in any SH I have played. It all feels a bit more "in depth", you even have to make sure your boat is fully equipped before going out. The handling and operating of the boat is similar to SH which is no surprise, again, but still different in details.
So anyway, is it a good submarine game that brings you that commanding a WW2 German sub feeling? Yes, definitely. Is it more modern than SH3? Of course it is. Would I recommend it? Sure. Does it take some getting used to for someone who is an SH3 vet? Yes, I think so. But that can be rewarding. It can be customized in many ways. Last but not least, there are mods out for it as well, just have to check whether or not they work with the full release that is out now and getting updates.
Is it better than SH3 with GWX? That is up to you to decide.

+1

[Swarmtek]

Depends if you are comparing a modded out version 19 years of modders making it better (plus dev patches, etc.) or just a simple stock Silent Hunter 3.

I never played a fully modded out Silent Hunter 3, it was always stock back in the day, and I am enjoying UBOAT more. There just feels like there is much more depth to the game overall and many more ways to play it. It can be a super casual "shot torps at ships" game, a crew management game where you supervise all of them doing the work, or you can jump right in and twist all the knobs/buttons yourself. Silent Hunter 3 tried some of this but didn't do it as well in hindsight.

SH3 was the best we had at the time and UBOAT just improves on it in every way.

Plus the devs for UBOAT seem to be onboard with modding so this game can really go places in the next few years.

[Vilkas]

Most of you dont read that im asking for a DAD, I havent played SH3 for too long. and I dont mean Clear Vanilia SH3, but GWX3 mod, which I think some of you missed too.

But thank you for the answers, I will pass it on to my father, maybe I will buy it for him and he will test it out.

[Vlad Tepes]

I have to say that after .. I don't know how many.. years.. I'm finally converted over to a new WW2 sub sim. I do appreciate all the effort that all of the modders put forth over the years for SH3,SH4,SH5.. just incredible..
but I have to say this game does it all for me. I no longer have to install a huge list of mods and hope they work... tweaking, etc.. just to get it working.
This game (right out of the box) is incredible (imho), the graphics are great, the gameplay is great, the mechanics are great. The flexibility of being able to play casual all the way to pretty serious is amazing to me.
I guess I'm saying yes, it is better of course, in just my opinion.
I felt a little sad but have removed all of my SH series now..
This game has just brought it all too far for me to go back.

[er.tz]

Originally posted by Vilkas:

Most of you dont read that im asking for a DAD, I havent played SH3 for too long. and I dont mean Clear Vanilia SH3, but GWX3 mod, which I think some of you missed too.

But thank you for the answers, I will pass it on to my father, maybe I will buy it for him and he will test it out.

Buy the game for your dad as a present that is the best you can do