where can I find garlic, tomato, apple, carrot farm in vanilla?

[BowMan]

I loot them from jarls or inns but I never see their farming

they don't exist in vanilla?

[Steelfleece]

I get bushels of carrots and apples from bandit hideouts, especially forts. Some garlic and i'm sure tomatoes too.

[steventirey]

Those things can not be harvested. There are no farms where they grow, and you can't plant them in farm plots at your homes. You have to find them on tables or in some container. Or hanging up somewhere, in the case of garlic.

[Skumboni]

You can grow carrots, because I am growing some now. But not the others.

[steventirey]

Originally posted by Skumboni:

You can grow carrots, because I am growing some now. But not the others.

You are right. Carrots can be grown with the plots added by the Heathfire DLC. They just don't grow anywhere else in the game. It was tomatos that is the only vegetable in the game that isn't grown anywhere in the base game or Hearthfire plot.

[Fear2288]

Even though carrots can be planted, I don’t think there exists any farm in the vanilla game that has them.

I’m genuinely surprised I’ve never seen a mod that adds a harvestable plant versions of the others (though there may be one for apple trees, but I think they’re just in the wild and can’t be planted) unless they’re in some kind of large overhaul I’ve never looked at.

[Ihateeverybody]

The lore reason is apples and tomatoes are not suitable for the general climate. Maybe a little more water and heat intensive then occurs.

There are definitely mods for growing tomatoes. I don't think I have used them but I have seen them on nexus. I know Apples are in Beyond Skyrim: Bruma.

Tomatoes:
https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/62012

[Perplex]

Originally posted by steventirey:

Originally posted by Skumboni:

You can grow carrots, because I am growing some now. But not the others.

You are right. Carrots can be grown with the plots added by the Heathfire DLC. They just don't grow anywhere else in the game. It was tomatos that is the only vegetable in the game that isn't grown anywhere in the base game or Hearthfire plot.

Which is strange as you can build a greenhouse. Those pots should be able to grow tomatoes.

[Perplex]

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:

The lore reason is apples and tomatoes are not suitable for the general climate. Maybe a little more water and heat intensive then occurs.

There are definitely mods for growing tomatoes. I don't think I have used them but I have seen them on nexus. I know Apples are in Beyond Skyrim: Bruma.

Tomatoes:
https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/62012

There is winter apples IRL so that explanation is not very good.

[alexander_dougherty]

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:

The lore reason is apples and tomatoes are not suitable for the general climate. Maybe a little more water and heat intensive then occurs.

Lol.
Tomatoes aren't suitable to the climate. But Scandinavia has been growing Apples since the Viking age, and Riften is nearly British climate, so Apples should definitely grow.

[Ihateeverybody]

I will take ya alls words on the apples. I haven't tried to grow anything since the late 70's; early 80s and that was a bean plant or something in school.

The technical answer is "Likely" They didn't want to bother with Trees as they would likely take more than one of the square plots they made with Hearthfires.

I want to say I have seen mods with growing apples so ...you know Mods.

https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/133519

[mikk011]

More Growable Plants https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/3880 Allows you to grow fruits/vegetables and also exotic stuff like Jarrin Root.

[Morgan Fun Gamer]

I think you can find them in barrels or other containers in the vanilia game in cities like Whiterun or Solitude or towns like Riverwood any town or city in the game I think but not sure about some.