What is your favorite faction?

[MadCrusader]

My top 3:
Dawnguard, ♥♥♥♥ vampires!
Stormcloaks, ♥♥♥♥ the Thalmor and anyone who appeases them!
And the College of Winterhold, magic is the best way to play.

[bruiser419]

Messaggio originale di MadCrusader:

Messaggio originale di bruiser419:

With mods: Companions (The Growl mod makes werwolves awesome)

Vanilla: Toss up between the College and the DB. Depends on my mood that particular day.

I NEVER join the Dark Brotherhood, too evil.

Evil is subjective.

To me the DB is similar to a gun, a knife, or any other weapon. It's the person who contracts the DB to kill someone who is the true good or evil just as the person holding the weapon is good or evil. If no one wanted anyone dead, the DB wouldn't exist.

And one could make an argument that the LD is also evil then, as he does a lot of killing when fetching things and just in general. Unless one sneaks thru every dungeon and doesn't kill every bear, wolf and other creature he comes up against, there's some evil in him.

[|AthalonxARC|]

Bards College, the best questline in all of Skyrim.

[★♫Dartnet♫★]

Myself

[theo]

Messaggio originale di bruiser419:

Messaggio originale di MadCrusader:

I NEVER join the Dark Brotherhood, too evil.

Evil is subjective.

To me the DB is similar to a gun, a knife, or any other weapon. It's the person who contracts the DB to kill someone who is the true good or evil just as the person holding the weapon is good or evil. If no one wanted anyone dead, the DB wouldn't exist.

And one could make an argument that the LD is also evil then, as he does a lot of killing when fetching things and just in general. Unless one sneaks thru every dungeon and doesn't kill every bear, wolf and other creature he comes up against, there's some evil in him.

Every single individual member of DB is evil therefore it's evil

[alexander_dougherty]

Messaggio originale di bruiser419:

Messaggio originale di MadCrusader:

I NEVER join the Dark Brotherhood, too evil.

Evil is subjective.

Evil is subjective, because morality is subjective, but it's hard to argue that a guild of Assassin's is good...... Assassin's Creed only gets away with it because they choose which contracts they do, and they impose a moral code......

To me the DB is similar to a gun, a knife, or any other weapon. It's the person who contracts the DB to kill someone who is the true good or evil just as the person holding the weapon is good or evil. If no one wanted anyone dead, the DB wouldn't exist.

And one could make an argument that the LD is also evil then, as he does a lot of killing when fetching things and just in general. Unless one sneaks thru every dungeon and doesn't kill every bear, wolf and other creature he comes up against, there's some evil in him.

LD?
You mean the hero of the game, that would be the DB (Dragonborn).....

And that arguement is sophistry, a gun does not choose to fire, a knife does not choose to slice or stab.... but an ASSASSIN CHOOSES TO KILL FOR MONEY..... that negates any arguement for good, it leaves moral neutrality as a possibility, but nothing good.

[fmalfeas]

Also, have you sat and listened to the Dark Brotherhood members talk. They are sadistic murderers who take immense pleasure in the fear and suffering of their victims. They're not dour, duty-bound executioners who don't see another option to resolve the problem than death.

[MadCrusader]

Messaggio originale di fmalfeas:

Also, have you sat and listened to the Dark Brotherhood members talk. They are sadistic murderers who take immense pleasure in the fear and suffering of their victims. They're not dour, duty-bound executioners who don't see another option to resolve the problem than death.

Right?! The only kill even remotely good was Babette’s vigilante justice against a pedophile. Festus bragged about killing a priest with experimental magic and lamented that he didn’t quite turn the priest inside out, and Babette had the nerve to crack a joke about Brynjolf killing a Khajiit monk and stealing his loincloth.

[Cookie]

Messaggio originale di MadCrusader:

Right?! The only kill even remotely good was Babette’s vigilante justice against a pedophile. Festus bragged about killing a priest with experimental magic and lamented that he didn’t quite turn the priest inside out, and Babette had the nerve to crack a joke about Brynjolf killing a Khajiit monk and stealing his loincloth.

Arnbjorn. Brynjolf is that sexy bastard in the Thieves Guild.

[Qua2ar]

Team Brynjolf.

[MadCrusader]

Messaggio originale di Cookie:

Messaggio originale di MadCrusader:

Right?! The only kill even remotely good was Babette’s vigilante justice against a pedophile. Festus bragged about killing a priest with experimental magic and lamented that he didn’t quite turn the priest inside out, and Babette had the nerve to crack a joke about Brynjolf killing a Khajiit monk and stealing his loincloth.

Arnbjorn. Brynjolf is that sexy bastard in the Thieves Guild.

My mistake, you’re right. I got the names mixed up partly because both men are just different kinds of degenerates. Brynjolf is a thief and Arnbjorn is a murderer.

[MadCrusader]

Messaggio originale di Qua2ar:

Team Brynjolf.

♥♥♥♥ thieves.