Stick of Truth was better

[Rifled]

1st you won't find SPTFBW in my steam account as I bought it on Uplay. Overall I liked stick of truth better. Maybe it was just because it was so new and awesome and this game feels like a re-costume with slightly altered combat. The multitude of minigames became very boring rather quickly. Stick of Truth I almost fell out of my chair laughing many times, not to say that Fractured but Whole is not funny as it did have its moments but just not as funny as the first one. If you are a fan of south park you will like it but honestly I wish I waited until it was on sale.

[RobCv]

But if you dont own sot and you buy this one, you get sot for free. Still decent buy!
Yeah. Sot proggression feels and was better. Customization was better. Jokes were better. Fights were better. Amount of characters you met was much better! But i liked fight grid system in the new game.

[Deamo]

FBW best game 10/10

[Perish_Song]

Hands down the stick of truth was funnier, and way more controversial. There isn't a way to explain how much funnier the jokes and battles were without spoiling it but when you compare fighting day laborers in chaos costumes to fighting zombie natzi fetus' it's clear they were told to turn it down a few notches.

[Exarch_Alpha]

It felt fresher.

If someone made a TES game every two years you youl would complain about the lack of new stuff just as you complain about this one.

Fresh dialogue, combat system, world interaction... that´s stuff that takes YEARS to develop.

And FFS don´t tel me Stick of Truth had good replay value because else = troll. SOT only had ONE ending. FFS.

[NecroMaster]

Let's see what this game has that stick of truth had.

Offensive jokes: check
Tv show references: check
Strategic gameplay: check
Role play: check
A plot that was just straight up insanity: check

I feel this game has almost everything stick of truth had.
It could have used more collectibles but that's my only complaint.

[RobCv]

Originally posted by Wilson the Gentleman Scientist.:

Let's see what this game has that stick of truth had.

Offensive jokes: check
Tv show references: check
Strategic gameplay: check
Role play: check
A plot that was just straight up insanity: check

I feel this game has almost everything stick of truth had.
It could have used more collectibles but that's my only complaint.

it didnt have one very important thing. south park characters which were in sot. just a fraction of them!

[cdarklock]

Originally posted by Rifled:

this game feels like a re-costume with slightly altered combat.

Yep. And altered combat is altered. Not better. Not worse. Just different.

A lot of what's changed since SoT... like filling out your character sheet... is just not fun. I mean, I get the social implication. We do tend to define things about ourselves for no real reason except to tick a box in our head, just like filling in a blank on our character sheet. And whatever you choose for anything - skin colour, gender, religion, etc. - it doesn't actually matter. But I get it, already. I don't need to sit through the lesson every damn time I play through the game.

Lots of stuff in the game is like that. Limits replayability for little if any reason. I still love the game, but it seems like I was having more fun in SoT after more than a week.