Throwback to a negative review of NITW

[Adrian]

As much as I love NITW even over 2 years since originally playing, I like to look past me liking it and actually look at its problems
I had a problem with the ending, dialogue of mae being stupid sometimes, among other things so I decided look online for anyone with similar opinion and I end up finding this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CbPs7FP5uI

So their mic is cut out till like 1:11:21 and even then, the whole rant about it doesn't really begin to show until mae looks at herself in the mirror and it progresses from there. I'd start at 1:31:25 for that.

My problem with this is that the entire rant on its own is pretty redundant and involves one dude targeting the most conspicuous bullshxt and kind of forcing it onto the other, though one part I do agree with is the party scene dialogue but that's about it aside from them not liking the ending, or some of the dialogue. I don't really need to go further because I'm not writing a review of a review? You'll mainly hear the same criticism, its usually over the use of 'ugh', tacos being mentioned a few times in the beginning, or 'eff', just really miniscule shxt and taking those placements for actual feelings (ugh) or cussing (eff) literally and running off with it as actual criticism.

I post this here because I want to ask if anyone felt what was said was fair or if they disagree with how they were presenting their opinion as if it was biased in some way. Bothers me a bit to see the video and it did my friend too so I came on wondering what other people from the community thought

also its like 7 hours but if you skim it or do it up till the party point, you'll get what I mean

[Mjäll]

That was interesting. I agree with you, their criticisms were quite stupid although I probably thought more negatively of the game when I first played it