This had promise but:

[Raxus]

I was a kid when Yugioh was released. I enjoy, thus, playing with the old cards and the old rules. I found no way to do either thing. If they get rid of the silly deck limit (I enjoy my hundred card or sixty card decks, leave me be :P), and let me play with whatever "banned" cards I want with my friends, who also enjoy only the most OG of OG rules and cards.
But until then, we'll keep using that ganky freeware p2p server that's on the internet.

I just don't get the logic; why clearly make and market a game to all generations of yugioh players, and then force them to all play with the modern ruleset that is designed to incorporate cards of this generation, and will hamper old ones? Why have no way to differentiate generations of cards?

(And before you say "lol get used to new cards and rules," we could argue all day about how the new generations have a ludicrous cost/power ratio and I don't find a war of godly attrition entertaining. I/my friends also enjoy making fun theme decks that were never designed to be ultra competitive, so we don't play with other people because of course they'll win, winning all the time isn't the point)

[Risotto]

What old cards are you prevented from using? Graceful Charity?

No one can help you with the "lol100card" deck thing, but all the old cards are in the game, and if you just want to play with friends, then you can make old decks.

You are making it sound like all the old cards are banned. They arent.

[Vayne]

This game is so good because it has lot variation of deck. If u want to play using deck on classic yugioh then u can make it like dark magician deck n etc. But for me its fun to try synchro from yugioh 5d. Hvnt try xyz n pendulum yet but will try later. If this game only hv old deck. It will be too plain n boring. The most fun thing for me in this game is make new deck n test it!

[Ironside]

Rules haven't changed drastically and if you're talking about new game mechanics then it's the part of the game evolving. Yu Gi Oh would've have died a long time ago if it had stuck with "old rules and cards" such tribute and fusion summoning. People would get bored!

NEW updates and game mechanics had to be introduced. Now if you refuse to play the game with with the new game mechanics then don't play it and stop whining.

[mimizukari]

for one, if you wanna use old cards, when you're invited into a lobby you can pick an illegal deck, plus during story/challenges, you're allowed to use illegal decks. games change and evolve, this game will keep up with the latest rulebook whether you want it to or not. go play an older game when only the older cards existed if you want old rules, also the old deck limit was 80, not hundred, and it moved to 60 because 80 can never be consistent, not even in lightsworns.

[President Trump(Murphy)]

You can play with the cards you want so long as it isn't a ranked match. The reason certain old cards are now forbidden and limited is because as new cards came out, those old staple cards went from being good cards to being game changing cards.

[Legion Main]

The only thing thats changed is the first turn draw restriction, and the field spell limit, the 60 card limit was for the better. And with the ban limit no longer enforced in offline--like they always should have done in the first place (seriously how ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ annoying is it for a game to give you a card theyre telling you you can never use?)--you can use all the cards.

Have you ever wanted to try the notorious Yata-garasu Chaos emperor dragon combo? I know i always have and its as broken as they say.

[KaosReigns]

OP, dont waste your breath. Some of us will understand, but you will be forced to choke on the fanboy rooster for the entire thread.

They seem to think the "honour system" will work with this.

I agree with you, and this is also my deciding factor on wether I bought this or not. No traditional, no thanks. I was unaware about the card deck limit though.

[Legion Main]

Originally posted by KaosReigns:

OP, dont waste your breath. Some of us will understand, but you will be forced to choke on the fanboy rooster for the entire thread.

They seem to think the "honour system" will work with this.

I agree with you, and this is also my deciding factor on wether I bought this or not. No traditional, no thanks. I was unaware about the card deck limit though.

How is anyone here a waste of breath fanboy by saying the game is fine and they like it as it is? Or that maybe the OP is missing something? Are you that rude just because people disagree with you and the OP?

[Raxus]

@KaosReigns these darn kids and their newfangled ways of doing things hahaha

@everyone else, I respect your opinions and you've brought up valid points, but I would've at the very least appreciated a way to sort all the cards by generation. It's mind numbing to try and remember exactly which cards were from back then, and way too much work when I already have my freeware dueling p2p thing that we've got our setlist already setup on. Good to know that the ban list isn't enforced online because that just sounds dumb.

I might pick it up in the future if it goes heavily on sale, and see if it's possible to reconstruct my decks n stuff with little pain.

[mimizukari]

Originally posted by raxus4:

@KaosReigns these darn kids and their newfangled ways of doing things hahaha

@everyone else, I respect your opinions and you've brought up valid points, but I would've at the very least appreciated a way to sort all the cards by generation. It's mind numbing to try and remember exactly which cards were from back then, and way too much work when I already have my freeware dueling p2p thing that we've got our setlist already setup on. Good to know that the ban list isn't enforced online because that just sounds dumb.

I might pick it up in the future if it goes heavily on sale, and see if it's possible to reconstruct my decks n stuff with little pain.

kaosreign is a known troll, did you see his call of the haunted thread? doesn't even know how the card works and debated it for 5+pages.

[KaosReigns]

Originally posted by Shiki Ryougi:

Originally posted by raxus4:

@KaosReigns these darn kids and their newfangled ways of doing things hahaha

@everyone else, I respect your opinions and you've brought up valid points, but I would've at the very least appreciated a way to sort all the cards by generation. It's mind numbing to try and remember exactly which cards were from back then, and way too much work when I already have my freeware dueling p2p thing that we've got our setlist already setup on. Good to know that the ban list isn't enforced online because that just sounds dumb.

I might pick it up in the future if it goes heavily on sale, and see if it's possible to reconstruct my decks n stuff with little pain.

kaosreign is a known troll, did you see his call of the haunted thread? doesn't even know how the card works and debated it for 5+pages.

*yawn* I wish I saw this earlier.

Yes, you are right, but oyu are also wrong, watch.

Give me the OFFICIAL rules, in other words, the official words from Konami, that this rule exists and is in fact a real rule. This is all I want, this is all I was asking for. Which you wont do, and instead argue with your fake facts.

Until you can provide that, I will continue to believe that COTH is being used incorrectly.

7000+ cards, and ONLY COTH does that? Yerp.

@ OP - Sorry mate, I wont be posting again after this, it will only devolve into a retarded child fight with him.

[Torchbound]

Originally posted by KaosReigns:

7000+ cards, and ONLY COTH does that? Yerp.

Sorry to disappoint mate, but not the only one.


On topic, I see the idea of having old ruling about first-person draw and one field, but how far should we go? Should we also have the Duelist Kingdom rules (i.e. "my flying monsters gain an attack bonus because we're in the air!!!" or summoning the maze monster transforms the game rules completely)?
I think this is a modern game, with modern rules, it's fine. If you want something old. There you go.[yugioh.wikia.com] It's free!

[mimizukari]

Originally posted by RevenTL:

Originally posted by KaosReigns:

7000+ cards, and ONLY COTH does that? Yerp.

Sorry to disappoint mate, but not the only one.


On topic, I see the idea of having old ruling about first-person draw and one field, but how far should we go? Should we also have the Duelist Kingdom rules (i.e. "my flying monsters gain an attack bonus because we're in the air!!!" or summoning the maze monster transforms the game rules completely)?
I think this is a modern game, with modern rules, it's fine. If you want something old. There you go.[yugioh.wikia.com] It's free!

don't forget fiendish chain. this dude just doesn't understand the rulebook or how the wording makes a difference + xyz material never leaves the field. so even safe zone wouldn't leave on xyz material, he thinks all forms of going to graveyard are destroyed, no point trying to convince people who don't know the basic rules of yugioh.

[KaosReigns]

Originally posted by Shiki Ryougi:

Originally posted by RevenTL:

Sorry to disappoint mate, but not the only one.


On topic, I see the idea of having old ruling about first-person draw and one field, but how far should we go? Should we also have the Duelist Kingdom rules (i.e. "my flying monsters gain an attack bonus because we're in the air!!!" or summoning the maze monster transforms the game rules completely)?
I think this is a modern game, with modern rules, it's fine. If you want something old. There you go.[yugioh.wikia.com] It's free!

don't forget fiendish chain. this dude just doesn't understand the rulebook or how the wording makes a difference + xyz material never leaves the field. so even safe zone wouldn't leave on xyz material, he thinks all forms of going to graveyard are destroyed, no point trying to convince people who don't know the basic rules of yugioh.

Funny how I was playing from the start of this games release until the Synchro, and the ONLY card that did this was in fact COTH. XYZ never did. Keep on the good fight bud, but its obvious we actually come from different rulesets.

Also, im still talking the electronic for this, if you play Power of Chaos, ANY of them, this issue will actually show itself instantly.

Tabletop, as I said before, unless you can PROOVE, with links, an official ruleset with this particular rule, you will never convince me its a real rule. Rules dont change based on a judges decision.

Link with COTH
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bG_mpQlWo60

Show me XYZ please.

[Italord]

Old rules? Lol, the rule basis were the same since the beginning of TCG, just some things has changed like no draw phase for the first turn player and 2 field spells activated simultaneously. If you used to play like a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ following those crap rules from the beginning of the anime, I just feel sorry for you because the real card game never was like that.