Deadspace 2 Remake: Please build it in UE5

[VersataMeridian]

If there's any plans to make a remake - please do it in UE5. I think DS1 remake was fantastic but I keep wondering how would its performance and fidelity have held up if it was made in UE5 engine instead of Frostbite?

[-=THe M@TRiX=- [DK]]

I mean The Callisto Protocol is an amazing looking game, but even then, it it has that UE vibe that most UE games have. Also as most UE games, objects are just static geomitri without proper physics - mostly everything looks nice and all, but are in fact "just" static objects with nice textures.

The UE is over used imho. Unity is even worse though, but that engine is mostly used by indies anyway.

[RedYokai]

are u kidding me? ur asking for the basically the same graphics as frostbite minus all the optimization. i had to wait almost a month to play callisto protocal because the ♥♥♥♥♥♥ Unreal engine is terribly optimized. FRosbite engine has always been really great.

[VersataMeridian]

Originally posted by RedYokai:

are u kidding me? ur asking for the basically the same graphics as frostbite minus all the optimization. i had to wait almost a month to play callisto protocal because the ♥♥♥♥♥♥ Unreal engine is terribly optimized. FRosbite engine has always been really great.

Funny! "UE5 is terribly optimized" . My credential are over 100 hours in building models and training models in UE5 and building small sandbox RPGs and also in Unity. Meaning Its not elaborate but its still more than most of tantrum throwers here who dont know the first thign about game design. I'm in a lot of developer forums wher we discuss engine mechanics. Frostbite is mature. UE5 is equally mature. Games are flawed 80% due to bad code and 20% because of Engines.

You cant pluck one game out of thin air and make a generic statement "UE is terribly optimized". Clearly very little understanding of how games are made

[Foxrun]

I hope it sticks with frostbite

[alien_tickler]

that wont even run good on a 4090 bro

[indigo]

It's going to stay Frostbite.

[VersataMeridian]

Originally posted by indigo:

It's going to stay Frostbite.

I like the confidence in which this guy declared this...almost as if he was the CTO of the firm deciding

[RedYokai]

Originally posted by LordSentinel:

Originally posted by indigo:

It's going to stay Frostbite.

I like the confidence in which this guy declared this...almost as if he was the CTO of the firm deciding

i mean it is. why would ea switch from their in house engine witch has consistently shown good performance and great graphics, to UE. I hate Battlefield 2042, but its a beautiful looking game. common sense dude, try it.

[VersataMeridian]

Originally posted by RedYokai:

Originally posted by LordSentinel:

I like the confidence in which this guy declared this...almost as if he was the CTO of the firm deciding

i mean it is. why would ea switch from their in house engine witch has consistently shown good performance and great graphics, to UE. I hate Battlefield 2042, but its a beautiful looking game. common sense dude, try it.

"Why invent cars when horse and buggy run just fine"

[bad at cs.]

Originally posted by LordSentinel:

Originally posted by indigo:

It's going to stay Frostbite.

I like the confidence in which this guy declared this...almost as if he was the CTO of the firm deciding

Why do you think they took the time working on Frostbite to make it able to handle something like Dead Space where they literally had to rewrite pieces of the engine to allow the seamless ship to go around and dump it right after?

I'd say it's almost a lock, the new features and tech they wrote for DS1 are either going to a DS2 remake next or a new game.

[VersataMeridian]

Because There are moer threads on the performance issues on DS remake than actual threads.

[bad at cs.]

Originally posted by LordSentinel:

Because There are moer threads on the performance issues on DS remake than actual threads.

Eh, the only issues I had were frame drops at the first ship in the dock cutscene and the final boss. Ran fine for the most part even on a 3060 Ti but I only play at 1080p still.

[DescipleOfZen]

UE can stick it.

[Cabalius]

Originally posted by RedYokai:

are u kidding me? ur asking for the basically the same graphics as frostbite minus all the optimization. i had to wait almost a month to play callisto protocal because the ♥♥♥♥♥♥ Unreal engine is terribly optimized. FRosbite engine has always been really great.

It's not always the engine, it's how the developers use it. You can give a Developer a gold-encrusted turd, but if they have no knowledge of Engine programming or Game design, then they'll never be able to polish it. Yes, un-optimised engines exist, but majority of the faults do still lead to the user. Look at the AAA Industry, there's some good examples that shows bad Engine usage with inexperienced Developers, or bad Engine-self. You also need to understand that with UE5 you also have to deal with the A.I tree, more complex, more it'll take a hit on your game.

[Alucard †]

What's with the UE5 hype?
I see these kind of threads in various game forums "update it to UE5" this "make next game in UE5" that.

Even in game forums where having it made in UE let alone UE5 makes absolutely 0 sense.

What the ♥♥♥♥, people?

Do ya love playing games in unoptimized engines or something?