Factorio

Factorio

檢視統計資料:
jonbrave 2020 年 8 月 20 日 上午 1:18
Should I buy a 2GB graphics card for Factorio?
I am doubtless a Luddite compared to many of you. My PC is a 5(?) year old Windows 7, 8GB RAM, SSD, i5-2500 3.3GHz CPU, NVidia GeForce GTS 450 with 1GB VRAM, 24-inch monitor 1920x1200.

I am perfectly happy with this. It does everything I want at good speed.

Most of my games are 2D, turn-based, non-RTS. And the gfx are fine.

I love Factorio. With it hitting 1.0, I decided it was time to try to set "high resolution sprites" in the settings. It rejected my 1GB card as being pathetic, and said I would need 2GB. I haven't seen this in other games I have (you should be able to see my list of games here if you want).

Looking around I see something like an NVidia "GT710 GV-N710D5-2GL 2 GB GDDR5" for about $55.

If I buy this, will I be bowled over by the impressive HD sprites? Or will I go "Oh, that's all", and wonder why I bothered? I don't think it will make my gaming any faster(?).

Is there any point asking someone if they'd care to upload comparative screenshots of low- versus high-res in Factorio?
< >
目前顯示第 31-43 則留言,共 43
jonbrave 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 12:34 
@TheBird
Thanks for answering the question, interesting reading.
ChillCore (已封鎖) 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 1:14 
You could play it on your fancy laptop by installing (unzipping the version form their website) Factorio on a USB stick and make it save locally in the config file
That way none of your work laptop's files are changed and you do get to test better graphics.

Startup, saving and loading may be a bit slower but should work fine ;)
Silverbird 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 1:20 
引用自 Huperspace
your PC is already almost 10 years old, CPU and GPU are from Oct 2010.
I would prefere to buy a complete new one around 400-500€ from discounter.
I second this.
Even a budget gaming PC is cost effective considering they can easily last another 10 years.
If you buy an outdated graphics card for an outdated PC it will probably last you a year or two, at most.
I got a pretty good prebuilt for 600-700$ (pc, keyboard, mouse, no monitor) off newegg; look for sales and check benchmarks so you know what you're buying.
最後修改者:Silverbird; 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 1:21
Zarinthal 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 5:13 
A friend of mine just dropped off his girlfriends old gaming rig, a Phenom II X2 555 with a GTX 460 with 2X8 GB DDR3. It stopped booting but I got it up and running and I'm going to be testing a few games over the next couple of days. I know not to have high expectations, but I was also gaming on a GT 710 just 3 years ago, so I'm not particularly snobby myself haha. I would be more than happy to report Factorio performance on that machine for you, as your system is much better.

I will say, the GT 710 was awful for gaming, not nearly enough cores , and I bought the DDR3 version to boot. It's not that it didn't look good, it's that it couldn't keep up with much of any games on lowest setting save for 10 year old + games. It just isn't a gaming card, even modestly. an RX 550 is sometimes less than a hundred dollars and it outperforms a GT 710 by miles. The GT 710 even struggled with Esport titles on an FX 6300 system, but they did run kind of...mostly ish.

But again, I will let you know how it looks on a GTX 460 for reference

Also, if you are handy, you can build a brand new system with an Athlon 3000G or R3 3200G for $300-$400 US, and that's regular retail. Something like that, today's integrated graphics, much better and should run Factorio just fine as far as I can tell
Drizzt 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 9:53 
引用自 Zarinthal
a Phenom II X2 555 with a GTX 460 with 2X8 GB DDR3

that was a similar spec PC a family member of mine had before their last rebuild (although they had far less system RAM) - the GTX 460 should give no problems with factorio since it was able to handle graphically intensive games (relative to factorio) like Far Cry 3 at 1440*900 fine

the CPU is only dual core (which prevented Far Cry 4 from even loading), but was from a good line of AMD CPUs for the time, but it may have an affect on performance due to the lower number of effective threads (not relevant to the OP since it is only the GPU they are looking for)

as an additional note to the good information on nomenclature provided by a previous post, GTX does not signify high in terms of low end, mid range, and high end, (and has actually changed how it has been used over the years), but prior to RTX it generally signified a higher end mid range card or a standard high end card, with the last 2 digits being more significant with regards to the "range" - so the GTX 460 was at the higher end of the mid range (as opposed to a GTS or a 450), with the 430/440 being low end, 450/460 mid range and 470/480/490 being high end

i tend to go for the higher end of the mid range, since i am often lower resolution than the cutting edge - so was 1024*768 while everyone else was going widescreen, 1366*768 instead of Full HD, and now i'm 1080p while others are going for ultra wide and 4K - and so i find the upper mid range gives me the most bang for my buck

but as stated - a lower end modern card should be fine for factorio, or many different second hand mid range cards (which keep the price low, but always need to be wary about where you get a second hand card from since they can have been very badly treated to the point that they will boot but will heat your system up to supernova temperatures within seconds) - so worth getting from somewhere with a 1-3 month warranty for second hand gear
最後修改者:Drizzt; 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 9:53
Benph 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 10:32 
I wanted to add a couple of points.

First, the I5 2500 is a great chip, and still plenty fast for many things. You’ll probably only see a problem if you go to some modern games or spend 3000 hours playing factorio and try to build a giganticly over sized base. (This is a trick comment. There is no such thing as an oversized base.)

Second, you might very well be able to extend the useful life of that system with a couple of cheap upgrades. If you added 8GB RAM, added a small SSD for Windows and whatever games you are running currently, and find the free upgrade to Win10 that I think is still available if you dig for it, you should get a few more years of good performance for under $100.

Note that the Win 10 upgrade is also useful because Win 7 security updates have stopped, but the security holes have not. That computer is a menace and danger to everything else on any network it is on that is ever connected to the Internet.

Lastly, the video card is going to limit you pretty soon, so as others have suggested you might keep an eye out for cheap upgrades there.
Zaflis 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 10:32 
2GB VRAM may be enough for vanilla game but when you add mods they may take up another big slice of it. Not to mention background processes like Chrome or Steam with GPU acceleration enabled. 4GB is sort of bare minimum in today's standards, i feel comfortable with 6.
Silverbird 2020 年 8 月 22 日 下午 11:27 
All this vague generalization is making my eyes roll...
Use this website to compare performance of various graphics cards, old and new alike: https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/

2GB 5 years ago is not the same as 2GB today...
Zarinthal 2020 年 8 月 23 日 上午 12:03 
引用自 Silverbird
All this vague generalization is making my eyes roll...
Use this website to compare performance of various graphics cards, old and new alike: https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/

2GB 5 years ago is not the same as 2GB today...
yeah, without factoring in DDR type, frequency, overall VRAM bandwidth, PCIe gen etc not to mention the GPU itself, then it really isn't much of a conversation, but there are some accurate generalizations scattered about. But it is true the OP question is inherently flawed, along with many of the responses to it.

引用自 Drizzt
引用自 Zarinthal
a Phenom II X2 555 with a GTX 460 with 2X8 GB DDR3

that was a similar spec PC a family member of mine had before their last rebuild (
I did manage to unlock the Phenom "hidden cores" in the bios, stable at stock frequency with all 4 cores on. I haven't tried overclocking it yet because I have some baseline benchmarks to run still, but I am at least going to lock the CPU frequency at 3.2Ghz because she wants to mostly play games. She just asked me if I could get it to boot, but I went ahead and fully rebuilt the whole thing, cleaned it up with alcohol and deciding if overclocking is worth trying.

In my personal system, I went from a GT 710 to a refurbished r9 270 I bought for $100. It lasted about 2000 hours of gaming (I work from home, it was a little over a year, which is about 80 days worth of gaming in under 400 days). That card borked out but I found an R9 380 on Amazon for $70. I can't believe it lasted 5 minutes, yet it has lasted 2 years but about the same number of hours. (I made friends haha, but then global human malware happened). I was tempted to flip it for profit and buy a newer card, but I decided the better value was to drive it til the wheels fell off because it was so much better than I ever needed.

Anyway, I try to keep all my old tech for testing purposes, reference (nostalgia, hoarding). My friends like to ask for help and advice on upgrades because they don't know how to type "(game name) on (CPU) (GPU)" into youtube for some reason. I've played a lot of rando indie games over the years, and people always ask "can I run it on these specs" and get flooded with bogus responses from pretentious regurgitators so I will link a video and discuss my experiences with them and offer to run tests on comparable hardware for reference, whatever that's worth. Unfortunately, in my observations, few developers update their system requirements in the steam store page, even when years of early access updates, despite it being fairly simple to change, so I am always willing to try and lend my .02

Drizzt 2020 年 8 月 23 日 上午 12:25 
引用自 Silverbird
All this vague generalization is making my eyes roll...
Use this website to compare performance of various graphics cards, old and new alike: https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/

2GB 5 years ago is not the same as 2GB today...

yes video card (and CPU) benchmark comparison sites are useful for seeing the relative power of different cards - but not so helpful if you are trying to find the cheapest option to play a specific game - since even when the sites include some game benchmarks, often there won't be a game comparable to the one you are interested in, and even if there is something similar, each game has unique performance constraints and may be more CPU or GPU bound, or have specific memory needs.

hence why asking on a forum for the game in question may get you some more useful responses where people, for example, let you know that they have been able to comfortably run the better graphics using a modern integrated GPU or an older low to mid range card with a certain amount of memory of a particular type (DDR3, 4 etc)
Zaflis 2020 年 8 月 23 日 上午 11:48 
引用自 Silverbird
All this vague generalization is making my eyes roll...
Use this website to compare performance of various graphics cards, old and new alike: https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/

2GB 5 years ago is not the same as 2GB today...
You don't need to care at all about GPU performance or speed when it comes to Factorio, it's all about how much space (VRAM) it has for the massive texture atlas. Somewhere 2 years ago they showed FFF where after optimizations the HD atlas still goes a bit over the 2GB, if i remember right. Then they implemented texture streaming so some graphics are held at HDD or SSD at the cost of processing when game needs to show those cached textures. Some GPU's use physical RAM to act as a secondary storage when VRAM is not enough but that too depends on GPU and it's never as fast as real VRAM. Factorio is still from the low end of hardware requirements, try Skyrim or Minecraft with mods or something with all the 3D shape data as well... 2GB won't fit anything.
Idlemind 2020 年 8 月 23 日 下午 1:12 
引用自 Lou Tenant
No. No No No. Never buy GT Graphic Cards for Games.
Buy a used GTX 970, 780 or 680. Or an Amd RX 580 / 570. All these card will handle Factorio easily.

And the Sprite resolution isn't that noticable. I have to compare screenshots to realy notice.


I am still happily rocking a GTX 970.. maybe if the PS5 can do better I'll consider upgrading to stay ahead of the consoles but otherwise it's a solid video card.
Zarinthal 2020 年 8 月 23 日 下午 1:23 
This has been a neat reference tool, but of course it's very general testing, so actual results WILL vary haha There are 2 lists, one is ranking newer cards on specific benchmarks, the second is more of a long term compilation of general ranking. I use it as a STARTING POINT a lot when I compare system requirements for games to actual systems people play on
https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/gpu-hierarchy,4388.html

Edit: don't bother looking at the prices on that list, they re like pcpartpicker, an aggregation that doesn't get every listing or necessarily update for sales etc. search your preferred shop directly for accurate pricing
最後修改者:Zarinthal; 2020 年 8 月 23 日 下午 1:29
< >
目前顯示第 31-43 則留言,共 43
每頁顯示: 1530 50

張貼日期: 2020 年 8 月 20 日 上午 1:18
回覆: 43