what makes this game better the battle stations pacific

[WigWam]

i want to know because im thinking of buying one of them

[^Steel-Savage^]

Whether it's better or not, probably depends entirely on what you consider better - or worse.

They are certainly quite different games (based on seeing BS Pacific, I have only played BS Midway).

AF is turn based and feels more like a traditional wargame with miniatures; it's much less 'arcadey' than BSM/BSP.

AF is more of a WW2 naval battle generator, which has a very limited air element but as well as a custom battle generator and a large set of historical battles, has two types of campaign in which the battles you face are generated agaisnt a sort of background wargame you participate in, but don't control. A very different kettle of fish.

[Edward Panzer]

honeslty if you like feeling like you incontrol of a ship and a much moer faster pased naval combat go with BSP but if you want a slower RST go with atlantic.