Do you think any of them deserved it?

[Radio Freeman Guy man]

This time around, did any of the people that died deserve to die?

This time around, I would say that all of them except Chiaki deserved it, especially Nagito, the others at least tried to come off as sympathetic in their motivation, Nagito was just trying to get everyone killed.

[76561198218459843]

I would say Peko did not deserve it because of the fact that if she didn't do what she did, Kuzuryuu would have killed Mahiru instead and be pinned as the killer, she was protecting him at all costs.

[Tsushima Yoshiko]

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

[neildittmar]

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

Hmm... one could argue that they all did something wrong since with the exception of Chiaki and Usami/Monomi, they were remnants of Ultimate Despair

In and of the game itself though... TeruTeru killed out of selfishness to get off the island. Despite his sympathetic story, He was willing to get everyone else killed to save himself. That puts him squarely in the "deserved execution" category.

Despite how much I liked Mikan, she deserved execution as well. Though the Despair Disease was inflicted upon her, it did nothing more than bring back her memories where she had been corrupted by Junko. Ultimately, she killed Ibuki and Hiyoko for her "beloved."

On the other hand, as much as I loathed Gundam, I could make an argument that he may not have deserved execution. The duel to the death between him and Neko(Mecha)maru was mutual and essentially for the greater good of the group. Subjectively though, I wished he had died sooner since he is one of my least (if not the least) liked characters in the series.

Chiaki didn't deserve to "die" for many reasons, mostly ones that focus around the sheer ridiculousness that was the Nagito murder/suicide, the mess of a trial that followed, and a conclusion that required more than a little reaching.

[FLFL Koizumi]

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

PRECIOUS CINIMON ROLLS.
TOO PURE

[Tsushima Yoshiko]

Originalmente postado por neildittmar:

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

Hmm... one could argue that they all did something wrong since with the exception of Chiaki and Usami/Monomi, they were remnants of Ultimate Despair

In and of the game itself though... TeruTeru killed out of selfishness to get off the island. Despite his sympathetic story, He was willing to get everyone else killed to save himself. That puts him squarely in the "deserved execution" category.

Despite how much I liked Mikan, she deserved execution as well. Though the Despair Disease was inflicted upon her, it did nothing more than bring back her memories where she had been corrupted by Junko. Ultimately, she killed Ibuki and Hiyoko for her "beloved."

On the other hand, as much as I loathed Gundam, I could make an argument that he may not have deserved execution. The duel to the death between him and Neko(Mecha)maru was mutual and essentially for the greater good of the group. Subjectively though, I wished he had died sooner since he is one of my least (if not the least) liked characters in the series.

Chiaki didn't deserve to "die" for many reasons, mostly ones that focus around the sheer ridiculousness that was the Nagito murder/suicide, the mess of a trial that followed, and a conclusion that required more than a little reaching.

I know man, Chiaki is my favourite character and this game just killed her in that messed up way

[Radio Freeman Guy man]

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

I like both of those girls, but if you've finishd the game (or at least got to the last trial) you'd know that They were Junko's lackeys.

[FLFL Koizumi]

Originalmente postado por Radio Freeman Guy man:

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

I like both of those girls, but if you've finishd the game (or at least got to the last trial) you'd know that They were Junko's lackeys.

Prove to me they did wrong.
You cannot.
They just got mixed with the wrong crowd.

[Tsushima Yoshiko]

Originalmente postado por Radio Freeman Guy man:

Originalmente postado por Yasamura:

MAHIRU AND IBUKI DID NOTHING WRONG

I like both of those girls, but if you've finishd the game (or at least got to the last trial) you'd know that They were Junko's lackeys.

Dude, I know... What I said they did nothing wrong is after they put in this Virtual World Program

[Ba'al]

I think Hiyoko should of had more character development before they rushed in and killed her. Real shame there, I saw improvements.

[MegaMan]

I'm going to be alone in this but I think only one person truly deserved their death.

1. Teruteru did have a selfish desire, but his main goal was to kill Nagito who had clearly revealed his intention to start the killing. I'm sure Teruteru was hoping he could get away with the kill, but I want to believe his original intention was to protect everyone else from a clear madman.

2. Peko is the only deserved death, IMO. With her skills, she should have been able to jump in and stop Fuyuhiko without having to perform the kill herself. Her logic as to why she wasn't a person during the trial was also a bit silly and she should have known it wouldn't go anywhere (with Fuyuhiko either being too nice or Monokuma rightfully calling ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥). There's a chance Fuyuhiko would have ordered her to make the kill later, but I don't think he would have.

3. Everyone had the potential to snap if they remembered their personalities as Remnants of Despair, so anyone inflicted with that Remembering Disease would have done the same thing. Just an awful version of the disease to catch, I believe Mikan would never have killed otherwise.

4. Gundham's death hit me hard. I definitely believe he did what he did for the greater good of the group and he could just as easily have been the one killed instead. He fought fairly and his sacrifice restored the hope of everyone else.

5. Nagito was simply not seeing the whole picture at the time of his death. He made the choice everyone struggled to do at the end of the game and tried to kill everyone so they didn't revert back to Remnants of Despair, but he didn't know about the method to overwrite their previous memories that would become apparent in the final area.

[CuckleNuts]

Technically, all of them pretty much deserved death since they are actually the Remants of Despair and did a lot of ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up ♥♥♥♥ before they were put into this program. It was only due to Naegi Makoto and friends were they given a second chance at life if they could complete the program and fufill its original intention. If we were solely talking about if they deserved death after the murders, then I don't think any of them did. I mean, if they weren't put into such a crazy, bizzarre situation in the first place, then they wouldn't have to slowly lose their sanity and commit awful crimes.

[Mr. Manual]

I'm not gonna bother putting black bars. This is a spoilery topic in a board that's marked for spoilers, so anyone here is asking for it.

That being said, I'm sure neither Nekomaru nor Gundham deserved their deaths. They were trapped in an impossible situation where everyone was starving to death, so there was really no choice. That being said, though, I think it was pretty manly how they had a duel to the death as opposed to a simple backstabbing. I'd argue for Hiyoko's case too, since she's not a complete jerk to everyone. She was nice to Mahiru, who was nice to her. Given enough time, I'm sure she'd accept anyone who didn't straight up give her crap all the time.

[Radio Freeman Guy man]

Fun fact: Hiyoko was originally going to survive instead of Fuyuhiko.

[76561198218459843]

Originalmente postado por Radio Freeman Guy man:

Fun fact: Hiyoko was originally going to survive instead of Fuyuhiko.

I heard of that, I want to say I'm glad they changed it but... I feel like I'll get attacked.

[forweg]

Originalmente postado por Fuyuhiko Kuzuryuu:

Originalmente postado por Radio Freeman Guy man:

Fun fact: Hiyoko was originally going to survive instead of Fuyuhiko.

I heard of that, I want to say I'm glad they changed it but... I feel like I'll get attacked.

I really wish they hadn't changed it. Fuyuhiko is such a boring, bland "nice guy" after his personality changes and he does nothing relevant past Chapter 3.

His original personality is WAY better imo.