Caroline might be a witch HEAR ME OUT

[BennyNinjaPandaSquad]

Please give credit if u make a bid bout dis

So your probably think “Benny is crazy” but I’m not

So when you look at Caroline you might think she’s a normal mom with green hair but she’s not
She’s a witch

So Abigail is her daughter and has purple hair but if you dig deep you will find that her hair never fades from purple, she is NOT Pierre‘a real daughter, Caroline used to see the wizard and that the wizard has a daughter in the valley. “But Benny that only proves Abigail is the wizard’s daughter” well if you start the dark talismans quest (after you complete the community center) you will find it that the wizard had a wife that turned green and cursed anything in sight so some of you are thinking “okay that makes sense Caroline is a witch” and some of you are thinking “ dude, the wizard is like 1000 years old and the witch has a house” but you see the witch Is never home and only appears doing cut scenes when she gives you a black chicken or your slimes black what Caroline has green hair, which means that she might put a hex on herself to make her look human and not like a witch that’s why she needs the greenhouse to call her down because the hex only works when she is calm. Boom there it is that’s my theory. It may sound like nonsense, but it was something it came up with in the shower so yeah. (I would add pictures, but I’m lazy) pls upvote and award

[Antidote#77]

Who let bro cooked?

[BirbNotBird]

Originally posted by Antidote#77:

Who let bro cooked?

I did. And I truthfully regretted it.

(jk aside, it's a pretty bad farming for awards though)

[Problem Solver]

Or maybe Caroline only transforms into the witch at certain times of the year. Like when there is a new moon. Your theory does has merit.

Further details: The wizard says he was married to the witch and had a daughter. He hints its one of the townsfolk. Abigail who is the daughter of caroline but not pierre has the same hair color as the wizard and is drawn to the wizard tower frequently. Abigail even hangs out in the graveyard at night. (cut scene)
The witches hut has a teleporter in the basement that will teleport the player to the wizard tower. This same teleporter could very well teleport Caroline to her secret tea room in the back of their store.

[DasaKamov]

Originally posted by BennyNinjaPandaSquad:

Please give credit if u make a bid bout dis

I'm not hip to my fellow youth these days - how do you make a "bid" about someone else's post? Is it up for auction?

(Also, the actual with in Stardew is obviously a seperate person from Caroline, green hair does not equal green skin, and my MC's hair is teal-that-never-fades, so hair color has nothing to do with nothing. :b )

[SapienChavez]

upvote? huh?