Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley

檢視統計資料:
Kokoro 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 10:53
Stardew valley vs rune factory 4
I've been on the fence on buying stardew valley for awhile now. I wanted to ask anyone in the community who has also played rune factory 4 for their opinions. Is this game far superior to rune factory? What does it bring to the table that rune factory doesnt
< >
目前顯示第 1-15 則留言,共 16
FluffyGuy 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 10:55 
rune factory 4 sucks , this game Stardew valley, is WAY BETTER
ASwarmOfKittenz 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:00 
Rune Factory series has better waifus.
Kokoro 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:09 
引用自 FluffyGuy
rune factory 4 sucks , this game Stardew valley, is WAY BETTER
Could you give me reasons WHY it's better?
Virdrix 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:13 
引用自 Garo
Is this game far superior to rune factory?

No. Stardew Valley is not a alternative to Rune Factory. Yes SV has a simple Combatsystem but Focus is on Farmlife like the Harvest Moon Games.

Things that makes Rune Factory 4 better:
- Combat
- much more Crafting (only Armor/Weapons)
- Dating System
- Story
- real Dungeons
- Skills, RPG Part in general

Stardew Valley is a great Game and in my opinion better then the original Harvest Moon Franchise but its not a Game like Rune Factory.
RF: RPG with Sim Part
SV: Lifesim with a bit Combat
最後修改者:Virdrix; 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:14
Garlboh 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:14 
Rune Factory's combat system is much, much better, this has an overall "lite" feeling to that area, with only a few weapon choices with little difference in playstyle, small enemy roster, 2 dungeons with little visual design and so-so controls which impact combat. Not to forget there isn't really armor in this game or armor/weapon crafting. You get boots and rings, that's it. Boots being non-craftable.

The farming however, so much better in this game, not only do you get an extremely large piece of land, there's flooring, fences, lots of different devices, such as sappers, crap pots, oil makers, etc etc. There's a lot here and it's a massive expansion compared to Rune Factory.

Basically, this is more of a life sim while Rune Factory is more of an RPG.
最後修改者:Garlboh; 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:17
Dio 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:21 
It's better than all 2d harvest moons available, but Rune Factory has better waifus and combat. They are both great games that complement eachother, and the waifus in Stardew Valley aren't half bad. It's just that the character portraits make them look like pissy tumblr feminists. I wish he kept the older, cuter portraits :(
Megakruemel[GER] 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:34 
Hmmmm... this is a hard one. Rune factory 4 has way better characters with changing dialogue and all that stuff + the story is kinda nice. Stardew valley is a long time investment, like runefactory 4 is but you need to do a few things to get items for the community center that kind of suck. I mean it is a good way for you to get to know the whole game and all it offers but i think the request box in rune factory 4 did it better.
On the other hand both offer great freedom, which can be hardly found in other games. Even harvest moon feels like a slave driver game by now (damn watering taking up 50% of my time in my first year).
On the whole point of setting i would suggest rune factory 4 is better, since the fantasy universe it is placed in is just superior, yet i do feel more relaxed in stardew.
In terms of gameplay both are great too. If you liked farming in general you will enjoy stardew, only the livestock seems kind of underwhelming. Crops get leveled with fertiliezer, which is fine but rune factory 4 had all those micromanaging aspects of ground quality and whatnot, which was really interesting too. My biggest regret is that you can't grow crops out of season in stardew.

Summerized i would say you should try both and see what you like more yourself. I nearly always play games just because i can and i got to say i enjoy both BIG TIME. They are similiar but not the same. The aspect i am missing in stardew valley is the monster variety, monster taming and the usefullness of livestock. A little bit more micromanagment, like ground quality like in rune factory 4 would not hurt but it is really relaxing to just plant whatever you want, too.
The characters in rune factory 4 feel more alive simply because they have more lines each day but stardew valleys characters have a lot of thought put into them as well.
All in all stardew feels more relaxing and rune factory feels more complex and big but also more rewarding.
While stardew definetly has a few aspects i would have liked to have known before (new locations unlocked, where to find some heart-events, how grass, silos and hay works etc.) it is still relaxing once you get the hang of it, to just farm away and rebuild the community, while rune factory is centered more around the rpg aspects perfectly integrated into farming but with rpg still being the main genre.

I definetly think both of those games, stardew and rune factory 4, made it into my top 10 game easily, stardew valley still rising in rank. Comparing them is hard but there are aspects that are similar. I do think you should try stardew out but without expecting rune factory 5 in there. If you just see it as it is, it is a very good game.
最後修改者:Megakruemel[GER]; 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:36
Fyre 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:38 
I like how 'better waifus' keeps coming up. Honestly the girls in this game were such a huge disappointment. None of them seem to have any actual personality. Even in HM they were at least tropes (shy nerd, pretty ditz, tomboy, etc) but in SV I can't even really put them in one of those boxes because they lack even that amount of 'depth'.

I find myself picking whoever seems the easiest to woo.
Dio 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:40 
引用自 Fyre
I like how 'better waifus' keeps coming up. Honestly the girls in this game were such a huge disappointment. None of them seem to have any actual personality. Even in HM they were at least tropes (shy nerd, pretty ditz, tomboy, etc) but in SV I can't even really put them in one of those boxes because they lack even that amount of 'depth'.

I find myself picking whoever seems the easiest to woo.

I think that has more to do with them not being complete stereotypes, like in the harvest moon games. The girls in Stardew Valley have real personality and grow over time, it just takes a while to get to know them. I'm just mad that all the good girls in the game are taken or "too old". Just like in Rune Factory 3, only in this game the bachelorettes aren't even lolis :(
Fyre 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:49 
引用自 PFC Andersson 29ID
引用自 Fyre
I like how 'better waifus' keeps coming up. Honestly the girls in this game were such a huge disappointment. None of them seem to have any actual personality. Even in HM they were at least tropes (shy nerd, pretty ditz, tomboy, etc) but in SV I can't even really put them in one of those boxes because they lack even that amount of 'depth'.

I find myself picking whoever seems the easiest to woo.

I think that has more to do with them not being complete stereotypes, like in the harvest moon games. The girls in Stardew Valley have real personality and grow over time, it just takes a while to get to know them. I'm just mad that all the good girls in the game are taken or "too old". Just like in Rune Factory 3, only in this game the bachelorettes aren't even lolis :(
I can't even imagine how many people immediately started up the game, saw Robin and just went 'THAT ONE' only to be as disappointed as I was. Even Caroline or the purple-haired woman felt like better choices than the ones available but of course can't pick them either.
Inari 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 11:50 
They are both good. I like the RF art more, simply because, well its more polished :P But people are already modding everytrhing to look nicer.

Other than that, SDV seems overall much nicer, more to do, more charm to everything.
The only thing I wish is that it had the town atmosphere RF4 had, like people audibly greeting you as you run by them the first time a day or things like that ^^
Dio 2016 年 3 月 2 日 下午 12:07 
引用自 Fyre
引用自 PFC Andersson 29ID

I think that has more to do with them not being complete stereotypes, like in the harvest moon games. The girls in Stardew Valley have real personality and grow over time, it just takes a while to get to know them. I'm just mad that all the good girls in the game are taken or "too old". Just like in Rune Factory 3, only in this game the bachelorettes aren't even lolis :(
I can't even imagine how many people immediately started up the game, saw Robin and just went 'THAT ONE' only to be as disappointed as I was. Even Caroline or the purple-haired woman felt like better choices than the ones available but of course can't pick them either.

Yup, Leah and Penny are nice enough but Robin and Caroline are clearly superior
Mountain Man 2018 年 7 月 6 日 上午 9:26 
引用自 Fyre
I like how 'better waifus' keeps coming up. Honestly the girls in this game were such a huge disappointment. None of them seem to have any actual personality. Even in HM they were at least tropes (shy nerd, pretty ditz, tomboy, etc) but in SV I can't even really put them in one of those boxes because they lack even that amount of 'depth'.

I find myself picking whoever seems the easiest to woo.
That's kinda like real life, isn't it? Ha ha!
最後修改者:Mountain Man; 2018 年 7 月 6 日 上午 9:27
swamies 2018 年 7 月 6 日 上午 9:31 
If you want an unbiased opinion on which game to buy, maybe asking in the Stardew Valley discussion page isn't such a good idea since everyone here adores the game.
Mountain Man 2018 年 7 月 6 日 上午 9:31 
引用自 Andersson 29th ID
I'm just mad that all the good girls in the game are taken or "too old".
This, too, is like real life.
< >
目前顯示第 1-15 則留言,共 16
每頁顯示: 1530 50

張貼日期: 2016 年 3 月 2 日 上午 10:53
回覆: 16