Alternative Birthday

[chickadee]

Do Stardew Valley have alternative birthday?
So few days ago I pay Robin to make a barn.
The next day she come. The day she come is the same day with her birthday.
I can't give her a present hahaha.
It's really annoying for me but if Stardew Valley don't have alternative birthday I will just keep play.

[mmmmarygray]

I am not sure what you mean by "Alternative birthday".

Are you asking if the NPCs can have more than one birthday a year? If so the answer is no, they can not.

[Proteus]

IIRC you can give Robin presents even when she is busy working at your farm (I think I once gave her an egg, when she was currently upgrading the coop)

[Tumalu]

Robin is the only example, and it only happens if you actively tell her to build a building big enough that you can't talk to her mid-job (coops/stables/silos I think you all can still talk/gift), at which point if you wanted her birthday so much you could have just not had her build a barn for a few more days.

So, I don't think there's really a problem here.

[chickadee]

Originally posted by mmmmarygray:

I am not sure what you mean by "Alternative birthday".

Are you asking if the NPCs can have more than one birthday a year? If so the answer is no, they can not.

Have you ever play Harvest Moon?
Well the NPC on that game have alternative birthday.
The main function is if we missed the day we can give that NPC on the other day.

[chickadee]

Originally posted by Proteus:

IIRC you can give Robin presents even when she is busy working at your farm (I think I once gave her an egg, when she was currently upgrading the coop)

I try to give her a honey but I can't reach her. The dialog box keep say "Under Construction" and that's make me feel sad about Robin 'cause she is the only NPC in town that I didn't give present when her birthday. Poor Robin.

[chickadee]

Originally posted by Tumalu:

Robin is the only example, and it only happens if you actively tell her to build a building big enough that you can't talk to her mid-job (coops/stables/silos I think you all can still talk/gift), at which point if you wanted her birthday so much you could have just not had her build a barn for a few more days.

So, I don't think there's really a problem here.

When she upgrade house I still can talk to her but when she make a barn I can't talk with her.
I just feel sad because she's the only NPC in town that didn't get birthday gift. Hahaha.

[TJgalon]

when she making the barn, she in the back of the barn, so the back side should be where you talk to her.

[chickadee]

Originally posted by TJ_galon:

when she making the barn, she in the back of the barn, so the back side should be where you talk to her.

No. Yesterday when she making the barn she is in the middle like when she making the coop. Maybe she in the back of the barn if she upgrade the barn.